Got the EVO 3D yesterday, and the phone being naked is irking my life!!!
Is the Defender too bulky?
I never had a screen protector on my EVO 4G, you think I should have one on the EVO 3D?
The Commuter seems like a smaller, sleeker fit. But I have read of some people saying it isnt tight on the phone from the top or something.
What do you guys recommend?
Or should I not even go with Otterbox?
issafram said:
Got the EVO 3D yesterday, and the phone being naked is irking my life!!!
Is the Defender too bulky?
I never had a screen protector on my EVO 4G, you think I should have one on the EVO 3D?
The Commuter seems like a smaller, sleeker fit. But I have read of some people saying it isnt tight on the phone from the top or something.
What do you guys recommend?
Or should I not even go with Otterbox?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All of this really depends on what you do during your daily routine, what your job is etc. Personally for me the Defender was a bit bulky and it also made it hard to hit the side keys on the keyboard when texting.
A screen protector is your choice. The Evo 3D DOES NOT have Gorilla Glass like some have stated so just do as you see fit. The commuter comes with a screen protector that is actually half decent.
Yes, the Commuter is a little loose at the top but Otterbox will send you a replacement at no charge( the silicone part). Hopefully enough people contact them so they actually remanufacture the case.
All in all, if you work in a place where your likely to drop your phone or you don't really baby your phone like some get the Defender. If you are always careful with your phone I would say just go with the defender.
I have the defender and I agree, the side buttons are hard to hit while it's in portrait. I looked at the commuter, I had the defender and commuter for my OG EVO and the commuter was my primary case. The problem I have with the commuter for the 3D is the way they did the camera pod. There is no protection for the cameras, I have an issue with that. I don't own the commuter for the 3D and all I've seen is the pictures so it might not be as bad as I think. Just something to think about.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
ausch30 said:
I have the defender and I agree, the side buttons are hard to hit while it's in portrait. I looked at the commuter, I had the defender and commuter for my OG EVO and the commuter was my primary case. The problem I have with the commuter for the 3D is the way they did the camera pod. There is no protection for the cameras, I have an issue with that. I don't own the commuter for the 3D and all I've seen is the pictures so it might not be as bad as I think. Just something to think about.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The rubber and hard shell of the Commuter extends out past the camera lens, so there is that bit of protection. It does not cover the lens but if you lay your phone down on a table there is no way you can scratch them.
I agree with the previous posts, it depends on what you need the case for. If you work in a high risk environment for your phone, I'd go with Defender (I'm talking construction, workshops, garage, other manual labor). If you just want some added day to day protection, the Commuter will suit you fine. I have this case and it still keeps the phone slim while protecting every aspect of the case. I have read that this case does not protect as well against drops as the Defender, so if you are clumsy maybe the Defender is a better choice.
As for the looseness of the case, there is a slight gap near the top. Like Winning said, we are all complaining to Otterbox so hopefully they will do a revised model soon once they get enough complaints. Hope this helps.
Check out other threads on the commuter. I bought it and what people are saying is true, there is a noticeable gap at the top, almost like the case was made a little big. You can also see the gap through the headphone jack. I returned it and kept my previous case, the platinum series from BestBuy. I got the blue one. I LOVE this case. It feels good in the hand, and more importantly it fits snug on the phone. I like that it fits snug because there is way less chance of dirt, dust, and debris to make its way in between the case and the phone.
Otterbox Commuter was awesome on my original EVO, however, so I do have experience with Otterbox cases.
Only thing I don't like about defender is the large sides. Makes selecting pain in arse. Other than that it's light and doesn't pull my gym shorts down.
I wanted good protection so I picked up the defender. A thing about that I really like is that it covers up the camera and the lenses. It really isn't that bulky imo and it feels great in the hand.
#Winning# said:
Yes, the Commuter is a little loose at the top but Otterbox will send you a replacement at no charge( the silicone part). Hopefully enough people contact them so they actually remanufacture the case.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wait what? Just go through their contact us page? I would love a new one. the gap is driving me nuts.
Go Defender!
Go Defender, reguardless of what people say, Size does matter..... when it comes to protecting your phone
I have the outter defender because its great and I also get drunk and tend to drop my phone a lot.
Sent from my Ebt Funded Htc Evo 3d
aFoodStampBaby said:
I have the outter defender because its great and I also get drunk and tend to drop my phone a lot.
Sent from my Ebt Funded Htc Evo 3d
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
HA! AWESOME!!!! Nothing is ever as funny as brutal honesty I love it!
Impact.
Impact is the best case Otter makes, and its also the cheapest.
Defender is like carrying 4 cell phones instead of 1.
Commuter is OK, but has no shock absorption or grip.
Impact has shock absorption and grip and looks nice.
I have the defender like others the sides of the screen are a little tough to reach and I wish it was water proof but as far as total phone protection and protection from dust and dirt it's the way to go. I looked at the commuter and the sprint store even let me try it on my phone I did like how slim it was but that was it. But as others have said it's all in personal preference and life style I can't afford to have anything but the best protection because of my job as a firefighter just wish it came waterproof to.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
reply from htc to me re: cases
so i emailed htc about the use of cases with their phones, any physical testing before release, etc., specifically with the evo 3d. here's the reply:
Dear Dave,
I'll be glad to help you out with this information. We certainly do test our phones in a number of manners before they are released, including a number of tests that ensure the durability of the phone. As for recommendation about using cases or not, I don't think we have a stance one way or the other. The phones stand up just fine on their own, but extra protection is always a good thing if you don't mind the bulk. We think of it as more of a personal choice that each person can make. From all reports that I've heard from customers and from my experience with the EVO 3D, it just feels right in the hand without a case; just well balanced and designed. I've also never been much of a case person myself as I just like the way phones feel naturally (at least the ones I buy), so it could be a matter of my opinion. If you feel like you might need a case for your usage of the phone, by all means go ahead and get one; when I do use cases I use Otterbox cases and I'm pretty sure they've already got them available for the EVO 3D. Again, just my opinion, and those do add plenty of bulk, but they're good cases. There are plenty of cases out there, so if you think you need one I'm sure you'll be able to find something you like. However, I think you can rest assured that your device will be safe without one as well.
To send a reply to this message or let me know I have successfully answered your question log in to our ContactUs site using your email address and your ticket number (greyed out).
Sincerely,
Philip
HTC
Want to see what others are saying? Have a question to ask other HTC fans?
Become a fan of HTC facebook.com/htc
Follow us on Twitter twitter.com/htc
Subscribe to our YouTube Channel youtube.com/htc
Explore our development resources developer.htc.com
We are unable to receive replies to this email account. Please visit us at htc.com if you have any questions or need further assistance.
sweet huh? nice honest response. this company could teach lessons on how to get right to it's customers lately
I had the defender... Loved it, got used to the heftiness. BUT since the front edges were so proud and at a steep angle, I couldn't type properly. All the peripheral letters (p l q a # etc) were difficult to press. I had to retype so many times that I returned the case.
Switched to Commuter and seems fine, albeit about half the heft that I liked. Seems to provide decent protection at a low profile. Otterbox is sending me a new Commuter BC I called and said the rubber seems a bit too large. IDK if it is or if I believed it from overanalyzing it from reading forums.
Anyway, I might report back after I chuck this phone against a wall to see how the Commuter really does. Haha
...adjusting to life without the trackball
Ok here's an FYI for all of us. When i was in the Sprint store getting my 3vo and debating what case I wanted and the rep was showing me the commuter I said that after a little while it stretches out and won't fit right ,she told me to bring it back and exchange it , its got a waranty . It might be a pain having to take it back but I don't mind I'm getting a new case. So just a heads up guys.
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
I got the impact at radio shack for 10 dollars. Does what it needs to. The only thing I don't like about silicone cases is the dust that attracts to them easily.
I have both. Like others have said, the commuter seems to fit a bit loose on top of the screen. Its also weird when I grab it as the rubber moves around too much for my liking.
Defender on the other hand, fits perfect. I agree that the area around the screen is a bit high buy I've gotten used to it and have no problem typing. I need a holster setup so that's another plus for the defender. It's not bulky either in my opinion, considering all that's going into the case.
I also have the Seidio Surface with holster. It's ok but offers little protection.
In my opinion, the defender offers the most value for the price. It's also the best looking case in my opinion. Its a very good case all the way around.
My commuter fits awesome better than the two I had for the OG evo
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
I'm quite happy with the Commuter as an interim case.
It has good shock protection and good grip and a thin profile.
It's a great case for me during weekdays in the pocket of my dress shirt.
I'll likely go with Seidio later since I like to use a holster on weekends with jeans or shorts. Not sure why Otterbox ignores that market, but they do .........
Related
Just wanted to see if anyone has any of the Case Mate series cases for the Evo 3d? I was thinking about getting the Tough case, but from a video review on youtube, the case apparently has a random port on the bottom...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mskLfmXEh0Y
Where I have found them online:
http://www.mobilecityonline.com/wireless/store/productdetail.asp?productid=28094#section10
http://www.wirelessground.com/htc-e...3d-case-mate-tough-case-black&channelid=FROOG
Currently have the Defender, but DAMN its bulky
I will never buy another case mate again
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using XDA App
mattfmartin said:
I will never buy another case mate again
Sent from my Nexus S 4G using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Please fill me in lol
i have a casemate and i have been using this badboy since sept! i use this on my evo 4g over my seidio rugged! and i am rough on my ph and dropping it and this casemate is tough! also slides in and out of a pant pocket real good!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
HTCRALEIGHFAN said:
i have a casemate and i have been using this badboy since sept! i use this on my evo 4g over my seidio rugged! and i am rough on my ph and dropping it and this casemate is tough! also slides in and out of a pant pocket real good!
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maybe I will have to reconsider, I would still like to see some more people weigh in. I have the OB Defender right now, and its excellent protection wise just a bit bulky...
The convert from seidio/BB is pretty awesome two good cases plus a nice clip. This is until I can get the ballistic case
Sent from my PG86100 using Tapatalk
I have the Tough Case, just delivered today. It's similar in design to the Otterbox Commuter -- a thin silicone base layer covers the entire phone, while a hard plastic shell snaps around the back, sides and corners.
Pros: The fit is absolutely perfect. The silicone layer over the buttons is just the right thickness -- the power, volume and camera buttons are all covered, but their function is not impeded in the slightest. I was particularly delighted by how well the camera button works, no interference with function or sensitivity at all.
Around the front edge, the silicone layer rises a few millimeters above the screen, so you can comfortably place the phone face down without worrying about scratching the glass. Similarly, the camera lenses and flash are deeply recessed on the back, with perfectly sized openings around each (which, IMO, is how the lenses should've been on the phone itself). You can drag your phone across concrete with no worries, if that's the kind of thing you're into.
The hard plastic outer layer has a smooth matte coating that makes it feel more like silicone than hard plastic, giving it a very nice feel in the hand. It's also covered with a raised, textured pattern, making the phone very unlikely to slip out of your hand. By contrast, the Otterbox Commuter I briefly had on my Hero had a plastic outer shell that was slick and shiny, and the phone slipped out of my hand twice within the two days I left it on (which is why I used it only briefly).
Cons: My only real complaints are aesthetic. I really like the slim, refined look of this phone, and the grippy, textured, matte black surface of this case, while very protective and easy to hang on to, is a tad inelegant, giving the phone more of an industrial feel. It also adds a bit of bulk, which was immediately noticeable when I pocketed the phone with it on (although I will say it's positively svelte compared to some of the other cases I've seen pictured on this forum). The phone does also feel noticeably heavier with this case on.
In response to the OP, the case does have a couple of mysterious ports at the bottom. One lines up with the slot you use to pry the battery cover off, while a smaller one lines up with a tiny hole just to the left of the other (edit: duh! that's the mike, thanks minieod). I don't know why those are there, but they don't do any harm.
Overall, I'd say thumbs up. If you like the basic design of Otterbox cases but want something slimmer than the Defender and easier to hold than the Commuter, this is probably your best choice.
I have the casemate "barely there" case on my OG Evo. I have been using it since shortly after launch and it has been just the right amount of protection without adding a lot of bulk. I keep my phone in a pocket with nothing else so that case helps with day to day wear and more importantly it makes it so the camera glass doesn't touch the table when the phone is laying on its back.
I am thinking of picking up an Evo 3d for my girlfriend in order to replace her dying palm Pre but she is pretty rough on phones. She drops hers a lot and throws it in her purse with keys and change and stuff. The thought of getting her a "glass slab" style phone frightens me. I will probably pick up a barely-there case for the Evo 3d if I get it for her. It's weird that they don't list them on their site but that mobilecity site seems to have them in a few colors for $15. That's a good price IMO and my last one came with a free screen protector. Hopefully that will be enough to protect her phone.
I guess I can also cancel the insurance on my Evo and move it to her 3d if I get it since my account is due for upgrade and hers won't be for two years if i get her the 3d.
po96od said:
The case does have a couple of mysterious ports at the bottom. One lines up with the slot you use to pry the battery cover off, while a smaller one lines up with a tiny hole just to the left of the other. I don't know why those are there, but they don't do any harm.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that "mysterious hole" on the left of the phone you'll want to remain uncovered --- unless you'd rather not talk to anyone ---- thats the microphone
other than that i totally agree with you on the case - i got it at the sprint store and i LOVE it
i had the TPU case from the user who posted on here earlier in june (forgot your username sorry!) and sold them on tpu-cases.com or something like that... it was 8 bucks shipped, and great quality for tpu
but i tried this on when i was waiting at the store picking up my moms evo3d for her bday gift.... and decided to get the case-mate tough, and give her my tpu one
the casemate tough is sleek....i dont agree with po96 on the "inelegant" , because its pretty similar to the style of the battery cover on the 3d....
i like it a lot, and it feels very solid and protected....
i used to use the otterbox commuter on my evo4g and loved it, but i really hated the new design for the 3d....
minieod said:
that "mysterious hole" on the left of the phone you'll want to remain uncovered --- unless you'd rather not talk to anyone ---- thats the microphone
other than that i totally agree with you on the case - i got it at the sprint store and i LOVE it
i had the TPU case from the user who posted on here earlier in june (forgot your username sorry!) and sold them on tpu-cases.com or something like that... it was 8 bucks shipped, and great quality for tpu
but i tried this on when i was waiting at the store picking up my moms evo3d for her bday gift.... and decided to get the case-mate tough, and give her my tpu one
the casemate tough is sleek....i dont agree with po96 on the "inelegant" , because its pretty similar to the style of the battery cover on the 3d....
i like it a lot, and it feels very solid and protected....
i used to use the otterbox commuter on my evo4g and loved it, but i really hated the new design for the 3d....
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
PMed you, guess you might not have noticed. Anyways has anyone else seen these in a Sprint Store? I didn't see one at mine but maybe he was at a non-corporate store?
#Winning# said:
PMed you, guess you might not have noticed. Anyways has anyone else seen these in a Sprint Store? I didn't see one at mine but maybe he was at a non-corporate store?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hey sorry, my PM notifications are not working i guess
i am going to take some pics of mine now and post here
(note: these pics were taken on an Evo3D)
http://imgur.com/a/cCdel
neodorian said:
I guess I can also cancel the insurance on my Evo and move it to her 3d if I get it since my account is due for upgrade and hers won't be for two years if i get her the 3d.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
get the 3d on her plan...swap the 3d to your number, and your evo to hers....at that time you both have two new activated phones...both are now eligible for the TEP
also, now you will have a 3d
minieod, nice pics. I was meaning to post some, but you were way more completist about it than I would've been.
The mystery hole at the bottom is for a lanyard.
i wish it would come with a holster
Phreddo said:
The mystery hole at the bottom is for a lanyard.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
lol
no...its the microphone...when your mouth makes noise, that noise goes into that hole
po96od said:
I have the Tough Case, just delivered today. It's similar in design to the Otterbox Commuter -- a thin silicone base layer covers the entire phone, while a hard plastic shell snaps around the back, sides and corners.
Pros: The fit is absolutely perfect. The silicone layer over the buttons is just the right thickness -- the power, volume and camera buttons are all covered, but their function is not impeded in the slightest. I was particularly delighted by how well the camera button works, since the TPU case I was initially using basically disabled it.
Around the front edge, the silicone layer rises a few millimeters above the screen, so you can comfortably place the phone face down without worrying about scratching the glass. Similarly, the camera lenses and flash are deeply recessed on the back, with perfectly sized openings around each (which, IMO, is how the lenses should've been on the phone itself). You can drag your phone across concrete with no worries, if that's the kind of thing you're into.
The hard plastic outer layer has a smooth matte coating that makes it feel more like silicone than hard plastic, giving it a very nice feel in the hand. It's also covered with a raised, textured pattern, making the phone very unlikely to slip out of your hand. By contrast, the Otterbox Commuter I briefly had on my Hero had a plastic outer shell that was slick and shiny, and the phone slipped out of my hand twice within the two days I left it on (which is why I used it only briefly).
Cons: My only real complaints are aesthetic. I really like the slim, refined look of this phone, and the grippy, textured, matte black surface of this case, while very protective and easy to hang on to, is a tad inelegant, giving the phone more of an industrial feel. It also adds a bit of bulk, which was immediately noticeable when I pocketed the phone with it on (although I will say it's positively svelte compared to some of the other cases I've seen pictured on this forum). The phone does also feel noticeably heavier with this case on.
In response to the OP, the case does have a couple of mysterious ports at the bottom. One lines up with the slot you use to pry the battery cover off, while a smaller one lines up with a tiny hole just to the left of the other (edit: duh! that's the mike, thanks minieod). I don't know why those are there, but they don't do any harm.
Overall, I'd say thumbs up. If you like the basic design of Otterbox cases but want something slimmer than the Defender and easier to hold than the Commuter, this is probably your best choice.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So sounds like you like it better than the Otterbox. I am currently using the Commuter and love the feel of it (didn't feel slippery to me, has a nice texture) but hate the gap at the top. I am getting a new silicone layer from Otterbox to see if that one fits better. I think I might order the Tough Case as well and compare the two. Overall would you say its thinner than the Commuter?
I wish I could find the Tough Case in stores to give it a test before purchasing. I hate having to buy online and pay return costs for shipping if I don't like it but I guess that's what I'll have to do.
*update* Just ordered a Tough Case. There is a 20% off code for their online store: CM06-SP20. The online store has free shipping to US addresses and didn't charge me tax, so $28 total for the tough case (originally $35). Not bad! If I don't like it I can just pay return shipping. I might just keep it for a backup.
mrazzino said:
So sounds like you like it better than the Otterbox. I am currently using the Commuter and love the feel of it (didn't feel slippery to me, has a nice texture) but hate the gap at the top. I am getting a new silicone layer from Otterbox to see if that one fits better. I think I might order the Tough Case as well and compare the two. Overall would you say its thinner than the Commuter?
I wish I could find the Tough Case in stores to give it a test before purchasing. I hate having to buy online and pay return costs for shipping if I don't like it but I guess that's what I'll have to do.
*update* Just ordered a Tough Case. There is a 20% off code for their online store: CM06-SP20. The online store has free shipping to US addresses and didn't charge me tax, so $28 total for the tough case (originally $35). Not bad! If I don't like it I can just pay return shipping. I might just keep it for a backup.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
eep - its on amazon for $30 + free shipping (which is free returns)
Anyone know if either the tough case or the barely there case will fit into the belt holster for the Seido Surface case(aka the plaitunum case at Best Buy)?
I'm currently using a TPU case in the Platinum holster because I like the added camera area coverage of the TPU case. I just hate the camera button covering of the TPU case.
The Case Mate cases look great but I really need a belt clip with them.
the wifes casemate shipped yesterday and will be here this weekend ill toss up pics
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA Premium App
The question is which otterbox case is the best for the atrix? I want a case and wanna know which is the best before I buy it. I've seen alot of posts on this but I have never seen a poll so I made one. If you dont like otterbox then please post what case you prefer and why? Thanks!
Wtf? Q&A section my boy.
Defender is bulky as hell but I'll throw it at the wall if you ask me too.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
jcorio said:
Wtf? Q&A section my boy.
Defender is bulky as he'll but I'll throw it at the wall if you ask me too.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know I'm a dip**** and definetly know better! I am now going to kick my own ass! Mod please move this to q and a or accessories section. thanks!As soon as I seen this post in development I was like wtf I seriously thought I was in accessories section! I can't believe I just did this! Sorry folks!
First off wrong section.
Right now I have the defender and I love it for the most part. I have had the commuter (I hope I am using the right names) and it was good but the silicone got too loose and they sent me the next one up which happens to be the best one they offer. Unfortunately im going to have to get them to send me another silicone part because this one is getting very bad as well. Great case but will need to get used to the warranty process unfortunately.
Oh and fyi I got the first otterbox in July.
Of course you know this is in the wrong section but I think I have to say that before I can reply lol. I am very happy with my Commuter case + Skinomi Techskin screen protector. Yes the rubber section does stretch a bit over time, but nothing too bad, not bad enough to make me want a dif one. And I believe this stretching is due to me removing the case now and then (battery pull or whatever).. I have a buddy with the Defender on his Atrix and he likes it as well. The defender has the hard plastic screen cover/ beltclip that can also be used as a kickstand. The defender is substantially bigger than the Commuter so do not plan on carrying the Defender in your pocket like I do with my Commuter, you will have to clip it hold it or bag it.
I started with the defender, and although I enjoyed tossing it around without worrying about damage, it was wayyy to big for my pocket. After a month I exchanged it for the commuter and I do not regret me decision. The case is fairly slim but sturdy, the back is pretty stylish and it gives the phone a nice weight when holding it.
I had the Defender, I returned it. I had a defender case for my iphone 3gs many moons ago and loved it, but on the atrix there are a few things that annoy me.
1. The screen protector is a nice idea, but as with the 3gs version, it can be annoying if you dislike screen bubbles like many do. I've tried a lot of different things to get rid of them, most work well for a few days, then a bubble appears.
2. Bulky. When the screen is 3.5", a little extra bulk doesn't bother me. When it's a 4.0" screen, it's a little more bothersome.
3. Soft edge of case is loose around the front, often creating a gap.
4. One of the things that annoys me the most is: there's a cover over the hdmi/usb port. It wouldn't be a problem if I had nails, but I tend to keep mine trimmed making it very annoying to open the cover and gain access to the ports.
All of that said, it is still the most protective case I've seen. If you're someone who regularly abuses it, it could be a good choice. On the other hand, if you're someone like me who never drops their phone onto a hard surface, it's a bit much.
Durability...survivability..hands down...the defender is the best..
I don't carry my phone in my pocket..I carry it on my belt and with my job of being in a large hospital's facilities maintenance job...I need something that can stand up to abuse..
What it's not is something that fits in a shirt pocket..suit pants..or suit coat well...
The case is a rugged as what you can get and still be small enough to hold and use properly...The screen protector works well with it..and allows good touch capabilities with the phone...The access ports are good..and the controls are easily worked..
The holder is adjustable and holds the phone well against your side..It locks the phone in well enough you don't have to worry about accidentally having it pop out with jumping hard..or banging it against something..
Which is best...for you...will entirely depend on what you want and need a protective case for..
I for one would rather be not as stylish and not worry about my investment getting damaged...I can't say how you are about these things...
I got mine at the At&T store the day I bought my phone...
Mac
I had the Defender, but like naxir I didn't like the lose silicone around the edges. Got the Ballistic HC case and so far love it. You can also use it without the outer silicone bumper to make it slightly more pocket friendly. Without the outer bumper you don't have to worry about the port covers as they are part of it. I've never even seen the other Otterbox cases for the Atrix, so I can't comment on them.
I have the Commuter. Great case, great quality, a bit less bulky than the Defender, but offers more than enough protection. I suggest you buy a screen shield, too.
You can't go wrong with a TPU case.
Man this phone is so nice and sleek, I'm not sure if I want to put a case on it or not.
Love this phone compared to my evo 4g. Blows it out of the water. Decent battery life as well.
What are your thoughts on cases?
I had started a seidio active vs otterbox commuter thread but didn't get much love. Maybe people are using other cases I haven't thought of. All I am using is a leather pouch.
ideas, thoughts?
I'm using a Commuter that I modified slightly for the car dock. I always second-guess the expensive Otterbox cases but last week the Photon took a trip to the floor and nearly bounced back into my hand. That settled that one.
One from the mall. Black rubberized and i'm happy. I believe its cellairis or something like that
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
One thing I don't like so far is it is a little difficult to push power button. I find myself missing it from time to time. I think the otterbox would help with that but I'm not sure if I wanna give up the lightweight and sleek feel of it.
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
How much bulk does it add?
Kevets said:
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The commuter is roughly 5/8" thick by 2 3/4" wide by 5 1/4" tall.
The phone is roughly 1/2" by 2 5/8" by 5" respectively.
The case is actually a good hand-grip size.
Using the Seidio Active. So far I am liking it. Fits good and nice balance for me between function and protection.
Thanks for that.
Kevets said:
The commuter is roughly 5/8" thick by 2 3/4" wide by 5 1/4" tall.
The phone is roughly 1/2" by 2 5/8" by 5" respectively.
The case is actually a good hand-grip size.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've dropped my phone so many times with my Otter-box Commuter Case and stopped gasping after the third drop I'm clumsy but it's defiantly a great case!
Im using the otter box commuter case and its been great so far, I drop my phone alot and I know that the otter box works great, I dropped a friends evo 3d and the screen shattered,, no bueno especially when your trying to date her
---------- Post added at 12:20 AM ---------- Previous post was at 12:20 AM ----------
Kevets said:
Yeah, sleek and Otterbox don't go together. I prefer caseless but I know it only takes one drop to all but stop my life. I'm finding myself waaaay too reliant on this little device.
Amazon had/has the Commuter for $22, which I think is worth it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I got mine at the sprint store for 20
I first bought my wife this case for her Evo and liked it so much that I got one for my mopho! Its thin, feels like it part of the phone and yet it can take some drops.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/aw/d/B005F9ZQB4?is=300&qid=1318310572&sr=8-2&in=3
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Let me know if you wanna sell the commuter.
rickyhfc02 said:
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
TPU! my sis is rockin one too and ive liked them. fit firm, slid easy into my pocket, good feel in the hand, and they are like 6-7 bucks
might have to step up and get me a TPU case, that thing is sexay!
has anyone found a carbon look case yet? i'd be much much more interested in form than function if one is found!
rickyhfc02 said:
I currently have 2 otterbox cases. 1 defender series and 1 commuter series. Both have their uses. I mainly use the defender for work so I can easily clip my phone into the holster and not leave it laying around in a rush to go do something. It's also amazing for those unfortunate occasions where the phone leaves your hand and makes a 3 or 4 ft dive to the ground. Access to every button and port is also amazing with this case. power/wake button is very easy to press, no problems at all. same with volume rocker and camera buttons. I love the port covers on this case b/c they are extremely durable and long lasting. However, my favoite benefit of the defender case is how easily it can be removed... I know you're thinking "wtf, this guy is an idiot!" Well the reason I say that is b/c i actually sell cellphones for a living and offering otterbox cases is second nature. having installed and removed just about every case they make, many of the other defenders are difficult to remove with the little clips on the internal plastic part of the case which is snug on the phone. The photon defender is almost effortless if you like to trade out ur cases on occassion it is a major benefit
I use the commuter series when not at work b/c I don't typically liek to wear my phone on my hip if I have an available pocket... just my personal preference. Commuter is definetly much less bulk but I also don't like the way that it's designed as far as installing/removing from the phone. It's a bit of a pain. Also, unfortunatly the part of the case that makes it grip in your hand makes it difficult to insert/remove from a normal pocket.
I have decided that I'm going to try out one of the tpu cases from amazon.com for a non work alternative and we'll see how that goes.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The otterbox is a lil bulky, and the commuter is good too.
---------- Post added at 07:50 PM ---------- Previous post was at 07:31 PM ----------
wagonattack said:
might have to step up and get me a TPU case, that thing is sexay!
has anyone found a carbon look case yet? i'd be much much more interested in form than function if one is found!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check Amazon for a carbon case.
Check this Carbon Fiber Case Out, CLICK HERE (http://www.amazon.com/Sprint-Motoro...SU12/ref=sr_1_3?ie=UTF8&qid=1318549681&sr=8-3)
I like the look of that case but the power button is a little tough to press so if I do get one I think I want one with something that goes over the power button.
I currently have Ghost Armour, It's more of a scratch resistance film, not a protective cover. I do not like anything that adds bulk personally. With that said, in the last 5 years, I have owned a AT&T Tilt, AT&T Fuze, Sprint Evo 4G, and now Photon. I dropped the Fuze once. I treat my phones like a 2 month old baby!. I have special mouse pads at work, living room, bed room, ect. To be honest, I have sold ALL of my phones for more that I paid for them in the first place! David
Seidio Active + holster. loving it!
Sent from my MB855 using XDA App
Buddy of mine preordered the ballistic case and was wondering when it was gona be shipped. He called ballistic and they cant give em a definite answer. If you go to there website the ballistic hc is gone
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
I preordered and received it today.
Sent from my EVO 3D, on XDA app.
the hc version is unavailable cuz they prob havent made it yet. however the sg version is available and shipping
I pre ordered mine and got it today too.
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
this guy got his
http://tiny.cc/2wvi1
I also received mine yesterday. It is a great case so far. I just don't want to take off my Zagg shield cause of the protection and also the hassle but the case has a screen protector built in so I left it on and the screen just has a funny sticky look to it but this is due to a preference of me not wanting to take my screen protector off.
Any pics?
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
bmoreboy02 said:
Any pics?
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i just saw some pics of it on the link somebody else provided... gotta say im not to impressed with the build design for it... looks like they kinda rushed it. i used to use the hc ballistic for my og evo and that was an amazing case, this one not so much lol
I purchased the Ballistic Hard Case and for my large hands it fits very nicely. My review of the Ballistic Hard Shell Case...
The thing I like most about this case that I did not like about the Defender is that the defender I could not click on keys or buttons at the edge of the screen without some trial and effort. The Ballistic is a bit bulkier due to it's design it does not effect my pressing buttons or typing at all I can actually see the 2-3 centimeters of the black edges around the screen meaning I can now play my games without killing myself to hit the buttons or use the keyboard without effort to press keys like o and p when I was in non-landscape mode. The kickstand does feel flimsy and appears it will pop off but treat it carefully and it should be ok. And last but not least the plastic protective screen covers the entire front of the phone unlike the Defender which had a gap that lint and dusts always seemed to find it's way into. I give it a 3.5 star more if the kickstand was of a heavier quality. What matters is the touching of the screen freedom of movement which the Defender SEVERELY lacked but this one does not.
htcEVO9 from someone that has used a Ballistic Case how much does this one differ? I am really curious as the only other case I have seen is the Defender.
molitar said:
I purchased the Ballistic Hard Case and for my large hands it fits very nicely. My review of the Ballistic Hard Shell Case...
The thing I like most about this case that I did not like about the Defender is that the defender I could not click on keys or buttons at the edge of the screen without some trial and effort. The Ballistic is a bit bulkier due to it's design it does not effect my pressing buttons or typing at all I can actually see the 2-3 centimeters of the black edges around the screen meaning I can now play my games without killing myself to hit the buttons or use the keyboard without effort to press keys like o and p when I was in non-landscape mode. The kickstand does feel flimsy and appears it will pop off but treat it carefully and it should be ok. And last but not least the plastic protective screen covers the entire front of the phone unlike the Defender which had a gap that lint and dusts always seemed to find it's way into. I give it a 3.5 star more if the kickstand was of a heavier quality. What matters is the touching of the screen freedom of movement which the Defender SEVERELY lacked but this one does not.
htcEVO9 from someone that has used a Ballistic Case how much does this one differ? I am really curious as the only other case I have seen is the Defender.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i do not have the hc ballistic case for the 3d, but when i had it for the og evo i loved it, superior build quality and like u said the buttons were very easy to push which made it a huge plus. the kick stand was incredibly flimsy that and the silicon piece that was used to cover the headphone jack never really sat in place properly, those being the only 2 real drawbacks of the case. compared to the otterbox defender i would choose ballistic over otter any day, ive seen ppl drop otter boxes about 3-4 feet and the phone still gets damaged, whereas i have dropped mine over 10 ft and thrown it just to prove how superior the ballistic is the otter.
as for the ballistic 3d from what i have seen the interior case deff looks like it is designed to protect the phone, but i cant say the same for the silicon skin, build quality deff looks like its lacking, looks poorly done is what im getting at. but if you can get over the physical appearances then i am sure that the case is still much better than an otterbox.
There on ebay for $34 maybe ill give it a shot. Ill keep my defender just incase. Only problem is ive dealt with otterbox and ballistics customer service before and otterbox service is 100 times better then ballistics
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
bmoreboy02 said:
There on ebay for $34 maybe ill give it a shot. Ill keep my defender just incase. Only problem is ive dealt with otterbox and ballistics customer service before and otterbox service is 100 times better then ballistics
Sent from my PG86100 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that may be so, but with an otterbox i found myself calling into their customer services numerous times to complain about the silicon skin stretching whereas with the ballistic case i never had to call it once lol
I love my Evo LTE, it is an awesome phone! When I bought it though I received the horrible news that TEP from Sprint had gone up as well as the Asurion Deductible. Normally I don't like cases because I like to keep my phone sleek but with this in mind I had to buy one. I opted for the OtterBox Commuter (I bought on Amazon for a little over $20 shipped). So I thought I'd hit you guys up with a review just in case anybody is on the fence about what case to get.
Overall:
I liked the tight fit, the good amount of protection without the bulk, and the fact that the kickstand is perfectly accesible and usable in both directions Plus it's relatively cheap. Check attached images. I had no problems with any of the cutouts for microphone or the back camera. Also the charging port and headphone jack coverings worked fairly well. They were a bit bothersome, mainly the headphone jack, depending on the size of the plug but overall they're pretty good.
Fit:
I must say this case has a TIGHT fit on my phone! It is not loose anywhere and the silicone is actually pretty tight on there unlike other two layer cases I've tried. It is tight enough that no dust has gotten underneath it to the case which I hate when cases do that! Also all the buttons are unaffected by the case and I like the feel they have with it on. Oh and the kickstand can still be used both ways, port up or down!
Size:
The case hasn't added much bulk at all. I still think this phone is pretty thin with the case on. I took a picture next to an Evo 3d with no case on just for size comparison and as you can see, this case adds little to no bulk.
Protection:
I feel my phone is pretty well protected. I already got past the 1st scary fall yesterday when I dropped it running down some stairs :/ but my phone was not harmed at all, neither was my case. Obviously it's not meant to be a hardcore heavy duty run over with a car case (as rumored with some Ballistics) but it's a good balance between protection and keep it thin.
Screen Protector:
I personally don't like screen protectors too much. It seems unnecessary for this phone with Gorilla Glass but it's still a nice gesture for it to be included. I installed it for demonstration purposes since many people with screen protectors had problems with proximity sensor. The protector included in the case had the cutout for the proximity sensor which was definitely a plus. I also noticed it's a pretty hard screen protector and feels almost like bare glass, but I still don't plan on keeping it for long lol
The Bad:
The only bad thing I've found so far is that the silicone is a little bit of a dust magnet. It hasn't gotten too serious to where it bothers me but it's just something to note.
cor4twenty said:
The Bad:
The only bad thing I've found so far is that the silicone is a little bit of a dust magnet. It hasn't gotten too serious to where it bothers me but it's just something to note.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is what I hate about silicone. Also, it ends up making it difficult to pull out of your pocket because of how sticky/tacky it is. Thanks for the review.
timtlm said:
This is what I hate about silicone. Also, it ends up making it difficult to pull out of your pocket because of how sticky/tacky it is. Thanks for the review.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Definately true on most silicone cases but since only the corners are exposed
Silicone its not too bad
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
Great review buddy. I get the lint all around the edge of the screen's silicone also. Anyone have any good cleaning tips for getting lint and dust off the silicone parts?
Sent from my LTEvo
Gibson.Dubs said:
Great review buddy. I get the lint all around the edge of the screen's silicone also. Anyone have any good cleaning tips for getting lint and dust off the silicone parts?
Sent from my LTEvo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well thanks friend. I just put a little water in my hands and clean it that way. Or spit if you want to do it the survivor man's way haha
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
I dont normally like to put cases on phones either but this phone...i dont know I had the overwhelming urge to put a case on it. Now i was going to go wit ha normal regular hard shell case off of ebay for 5 bucks but..no.. not this time. I got the otterbox commuter aswell. Truth be told I was worried about the silicone not fitting perfectly but to my surprise it fits damn well. Plus the case feels good in the hand. I actually like how the phone feels with the case on. i did put the screen protector on because look at it this way. $600 phone with ''gorilla glass''..... youre really not going to do anything to protect it? Gorilla glass is scratch resistant not scratch proof. My opinion is youve gotta have a few screws loose if youre not going to put a screen protector on the phone.
over all great case, feels good, doesnt add bulk.
The defender however...makes the phone huge
I rocked my OG for two years with every rugged case u could think of and never worried about the phone. The last month I had the phone I had it naked as all of my cases were breaking on me. I loved how great the Evo felt naked and how easy it was to slip it into my pocket. Anywho, I ended up dropping it and shattering the screen. I bought the new Evo and slapped the Commuter on it before leaving BB. I thought the Defender was way too big for pocket use (I'm over the belt clip thing). It maintains the sleekness of the OG Evo, so, I love it! The included screen protector is pretty good too surprisingly. Not a single complaint from me!
Yeah I have actually kept this case on and been loving it. The case adds a really nice feel to my phone and I honestly like the look it gives my phone. I have yet to try the defender but when I do ill do a write up on it as well
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
I love the review. I'm actually about to switch from the defender to the commuter case. Getting tired of the extra bulk and the rubber on the defenders seem to tear rather quickly. I had the same tearing prob when I had a defender on my e3d. Had the e3d defender replaced twice. So again thanks for the review picking up a commuter case tomorrow.
Bought the same case as soon as I got my phone, beat case hands down still nice and thin the dust magnet I agree but its protective and not heavy ! It was cheap too off amazon. The port cover is clever
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
Yeah im still using my original one and even after many falls it looks New and my phone is perfect,.no.scratches.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
I had the Defender on my phone from day one. I just ordered this one. It looks a little slimmer and will fit my pocket better. Thanks for the review.
i so wish this case came with a belt clip!!
i got one these they nice:good:
evo401 said:
i so wish this case came with a belt clip!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can buy the seidio belt clip. The phone fits great with the case on.
Edit:
http://www.seidioonline.com/htc-evo-4g-lte-spring-clip-holster-p/hlhtjetas.htm
Sent from my HTC Evo LTE powered by Meanrom
This case is awesome!
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
mexiking713 said:
You can buy the seidio belt clip. The phone fits great with the case on.
Edit:
http://www.seidioonline.com/htc-evo-4g-lte-spring-clip-holster-p/hlhtjetas.htm
Sent from my HTC Evo LTE powered by Meanrom
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I was wondering if that would fit ..I just wish otterbox would make one too
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
I have the defender case and the rubber over the charging port keeps breaking off. Does that happen with the commuter case?
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
Yeah spot on review I feel the same way about my commuter case. I had the defender for my OG EVO but I like the feel and look of the commuter on my LTE so much better
cor4twenty said:
I love my Evo LTE, it is an awesome phone! When I bought it though I received the horrible news that TEP from Sprint had gone up as well as the Asurion Deductible. Normally I don't like cases because I like to keep my phone sleek but with this in mind I had to buy one. I opted for the OtterBox Commuter (I bought on Amazon for a little over $20 shipped). So I thought I'd hit you guys up with a review just in case anybody is on the fence about what case to get.
Overall:
I liked the tight fit, the good amount of protection without the bulk, and the fact that the kickstand is perfectly accesible and usable in both directions Plus it's relatively cheap. Check attached images. I had no problems with any of the cutouts for microphone or the back camera. Also the charging port and headphone jack coverings worked fairly well. They were a bit bothersome, mainly the headphone jack, depending on the size of the plug but overall they're pretty good.
Fit:
I must say this case has a TIGHT fit on my phone! It is not loose anywhere and the silicone is actually pretty tight on there unlike other two layer cases I've tried. It is tight enough that no dust has gotten underneath it to the case which I hate when cases do that! Also all the buttons are unaffected by the case and I like the feel they have with it on. Oh and the kickstand can still be used both ways, port up or down!
Size:
The case hasn't added much bulk at all. I still think this phone is pretty thin with the case on. I took a picture next to an Evo 3d with no case on just for size comparison and as you can see, this case adds little to no bulk.
Protection:
I feel my phone is pretty well protected. I already got past the 1st scary fall yesterday when I dropped it running down some stairs :/ but my phone was not harmed at all, neither was my case. Obviously it's not meant to be a hardcore heavy duty run over with a car case (as rumored with some Ballistics) but it's a good balance between protection and keep it thin.
Screen Protector:
I personally don't like screen protectors too much. It seems unnecessary for this phone with Gorilla Glass but it's still a nice gesture for it to be included. I installed it for demonstration purposes since many people with screen protectors had problems with proximity sensor. The protector included in the case had the cutout for the proximity sensor which was definitely a plus. I also noticed it's a pretty hard screen protector and feels almost like bare glass, but I still don't plan on keeping it for long lol
The Bad:
The only bad thing I've found so far is that the silicone is a little bit of a dust magnet. It hasn't gotten too serious to where it bothers me but it's just something to note.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
After 2 weeks with mine I have to say I love this case. It's thin very protective and it looks good. Very satisfied with it.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app