[Q] Questions About Adobe Flash on the Player - Samsung Galaxy Player 4.0, 5.0

I'm planning on getting a Galaxy Player 5.0 soon (though I'm hoping to get one for Christmas), it just looks like the perfect device for all my needs, not to mention it outstrips my second gen iPod Touch in every category and beyond.
One thing I'm really looking forward to is Adobe Flash, which I know Gingerbread and this device support, but I still have a few questions for people who actually own it. I've watched a lot of reviews, but none of them have really focused on or demonstrated the capability. Here are my questions:
1) What version of Flash does this device run?
2) How well/smoothly does it run? Say I wanted to watch a video on a site like Megavideo, how well would it work?
3) I know there are alternate browsers to the default one, does Flash work with any of them?
Thanks in advance for any answers, I really appreciate it!

darksky72 said:
I'm planning on getting a Galaxy Player 5.0 soon (though I'm hoping to get one for Christmas), it just looks like the perfect device for all my needs, not to mention it outstrips my second gen iPod Touch in every category and beyond.
One thing I'm really looking forward to is Adobe Flash, which I know Gingerbread and this device support, but I still have a few questions for people who actually own it. I've watched a lot of reviews, but none of them have really focused on or demonstrated the capability. Here are my questions:
1) What version of Flash does this device run?
2) How well/smoothly does it run? Say I wanted to watch a video on a site like Megavideo, how well would it work?
3) I know there are alternate browsers to the default one, does Flash work with any of them?
Thanks in advance for any answers, I really appreciate it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
Re. 1) I currently have 11.1.111.5, from the Android Market on my SGP5. Also, Adobe AIR 3.1.0.488 (also from Market).
Re. 2) I watch streamed Flash videos from various websites. It mostly seems to work ok. The websites I use typically don't host the videos themselves, so I'm not always 100% of the actual streamer, but typically, it'd be like Tudou, etc. Some of them behave strangely within different browsers (esp. placement of the Flash frame).
Re. 3) I've used Flash with default browser, Dolphin Mini, Xscope, and Opera. Firefox doesn't support Flash yet, I think (not sure why). I think that I also tried a couple of other browsers. Xscope use to be my favorite, but several months ago, I started having problems with Flash and Xscope (window would go black when the Xscope menu was visible), so I've mostly been using Dolphin Mini and Opera with Flash lately. Both perform about the same, Flash-wise.
Jim

jimcpl said:
Hi,
Re. 1) I currently have 11.1.111.5, from the Android Market on my SGP5. Also, Adobe AIR 3.1.0.488 (also from Market).
Re. 2) I watch streamed Flash videos from various websites. It mostly seems to work ok. The websites I use typically don't host the videos themselves, so I'm not always 100% of the actual streamer, but typically, it'd be like Tudou, etc. Some of them behave strangely within different browsers (esp. placement of the Flash frame).
Re. 3) I've used Flash with default browser, Dolphin Mini, Xscope, and Opera. Firefox doesn't support Flash yet, I think (not sure why). I think that I also tried a couple of other browsers. Xscope use to be my favorite, but several months ago, I started having problems with Flash and Xscope (window would go black when the Xscope menu was visible), so I've mostly been using Dolphin Mini and Opera with Flash lately. Both perform about the same, Flash-wise.
Jim
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks a ton, that was pretty much what I was looking for!
I'm still wondering about the Flash performance though, you mentioned strange behavior in window placement, but I'm more curious about whether or not it's possible to watch a video without framerate issues, artifacts, etc.
EDIT: Also, you said that Opera and Dolphin Mini perform similarly, but how do they compare to the default browser?

darksky72 said:
Thanks a ton, that was pretty much what I was looking for!
I'm still wondering about the Flash performance though, you mentioned strange behavior in window placement, but I'm more curious about whether or not it's possible to watch a video without framerate issues, artifacts, etc.
EDIT: Also, you said that Opera and Dolphin Mini perform similarly, but how do they compare to the default browser?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi,
There was, I think, an earlier 11.x version of Flash that I had problems with "tearing", and I had to fallback to 10.x, but that was on my Gtablet. I haven't seen that problem with the 11.x on the SGP5.
Mostly when I see problems with pauses, I've concluded that they weren't with Flash itself, but because of loads on the websites themselves, at least on the ones that I use (mostly streaming Kdrama site). I can't prove that, but it's because if I get on at different times or days, it'll be fine.
I haven't used the default browser much (actually not at all), so I can't give you info on that. Sorry.
Jim

Alright, thanks for clarifying
Anyone else have anything to say about Flash performance and whether or not that same performance differs between the default and other browsers?

The flash on my Player run quite well. It's so much better than iPod

Related

Are there any *STABLE* YouTube-capable browsers??

The standard PIE on DCD's 2.10 ROM (or any stock ROM, for that matter) is horrendously unstable. The 'download' constantly stalls out when doing speed tests and other sites load formatted in ways that make everything unreadable.
Opera Mini (Beta 4v2) is the absolute opposite. 2.2Mbps+ on all speed tests, stable downloads, 110% flawless page formatting... it just can't play videos. Is there any middle ground available? I'd take a slightly less 'Opera' browser, as long as it was stable and played videos. Is there anything like this?
install HTC Streaming Media and/or Flash Video Bundle and youtube will work
gcincotta said:
install HTC Streaming Media and/or Flash Video Bundle and youtube will work
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
On Opera? I can play YouTube videos when I run PIE, but it's still so slow and choppy. Not the videos themselves, but any site I go to on PIE.
which opera you use? Because I use opera mini but cannot play you tune video.
I'm actually really happy with TCPMP (core media player) and the flashvideobundle plugin. youtube videos launch almost immediately and stream perfectly.
Not sure if it works with opera mini, but it works with PIE. Also, make sure your "view" settings on PIE are not set to "column". I found that "desktop" allows screen formating most like PC, but some sites do work well on "fit to screen"
mike-y said:
I'm actually really happy with TCPMP (core media player) and the flashvideobundle plugin. youtube videos launch almost immediately and stream perfectly.
Not sure if it works with opera mini, but it works with PIE. Also, make sure your "view" settings on PIE are not set to "column". I found that "desktop" allows screen formating most like PC, but some sites do work well on "fit to screen"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How can I make my ppc show me youtube's videos??
U could also try the program Vtap, works great for me on my mogul, and its free. I like it better than using PIE and TCPMP although they are both good solutions.
killerkhatiby009 said:
U could also try the program Vtap, works great for me on my mogul, and its free. I like it better than using PIE and TCPMP although they are both good solutions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I need a player which play all my files, not only what it can find on the net...
skyfire is a new player that is said will play youtube as if you're working on a computer, but its still on beta version and its still not out yet but skyfire is sending some to testers... so its ur chance to try to get one
We are all stuck waiting for Skyfire for full browsing on a cell.
Vtap is Broken
I keep getting a Green Screen anytime I try to watch a video? Anyone have any idea whats going on??? Thanks.
sovrce said:
The standard PIE on DCD's 2.10 ROM (or any stock ROM, for that matter) is horrendously unstable. The 'download' constantly stalls out when doing speed tests and other sites load formatted in ways that make everything unreadable.
Opera Mini (Beta 4v2) is the absolute opposite. 2.2Mbps+ on all speed tests, stable downloads, 110% flawless page formatting... it just can't play videos. Is there any middle ground available? I'd take a slightly less 'Opera' browser, as long as it was stable and played videos. Is there anything like this?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When will you people learn...
You can't test your speed on Opera Mini! I promise you, you are NOT getting 2.2Mpbs+ speeds on your phone consistently.
Opera Mini is not a real web browser. The way it works is when you click on a web page, Opera downloads the page to its servers first. Then, it takes a look at the page, and takes a picture of it, taking note of where all the links appear. It then sends this "image" + link information to your phone which displays in the opera mini browser. This method is so much faster than a regular browser because your phone doesn't have to download all the information and doesn't have to do any of the processing to render the page. (This also, by the way, introduces all sorts of security questions because this is being rendered on someone else's computer before it comes to you. In other words, don't use opera mini to do your banking)
when you do a speed test, you're not seeing the speed of your phone's connection. You're seeing the speed in which Opera's server is connected to the internet, and then seeing that result as a picture sent to your phone!
In fact, the opera mini experience is the same on a high-end PDA phone as it is on a simple little nokia from 5 years ago (speed of the phone is irrelevant, its just viewing images).
Case and point- browsing on an GSM nokia 6230 using EDGE (non-3G) is not noticeably slower than browsing on a Mogul with EVDO Rev A, and both reported over 2MBps in speed tests (EDGE averages around 100kbps).
Basically, this system is ideal for web browsing like the desktop. However, it can't do any pages that require client-side processing, since your phone is not doing any of the processing. For example, pages with real-time interaction, javascript games, and especially flash animation and/or video (such as youtube) would not work under this model.
There ARE browsers that are capable of this, such as NetFront and the upcoming SkyFire, but you will most likely end up with the same laggy experience as IE because you are back to using the phone's CPU to process and render the data.
Bottom Line: What you are asking for is not out there because the concepts are worlds apart (opera mini + flash video). Using TCPMP and the flash video bundle work flawlessy for me, might want to check out the latest versions of that.
Generally, I've found that there is not perfect browser for everything (yet). I use Opera mini for regular browsing of large pages, Picsel for secure pages (such as sprint.com account information), IE for mobile-access pages (such as the mobile accuweather) and for flash video using the bundle. I used to use NetFront for pages with flash and java interaction, but I actually found it too slow and clunky for regular use. The tcpmp video bundle works much better, so I removed NetFront.
Good luck, I hope this helped someone understand the situation better!
::End of rant::
Look... IE is the only thing you can find atm that is close to being full featured. The problem is on some of these roms it just plain does not have the memory to operate. NexVisions is one of them. Open just about any page and is 1mg of ram left. Other then IE you are forced to mix it up with other browsers until Skiyfire comes out.
So has anyone tested the Skyfire beta?
mike-y said:
I'm actually really happy with TCPMP (core media player) and the flashvideobundle plugin. youtube videos launch almost immediately and stream perfectly.
Not sure if it works with opera mini, but it works with PIE. Also, make sure your "view" settings on PIE are not set to "column". I found that "desktop" allows screen formating most like PC, but some sites do work well on "fit to screen"
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
how are you getting this to work? i have tcpmp and the FlashVideoBundle.cab but youtube videos try to open in WMP, which gives an "unknown error" error
if i force it to open in tcpmp it says the rtsp protocal is not supported
using opera mobile reporting as a desktop browser youtube doesnt even open, it just crashes the browser, i cant get PIE to report itself as anything other than PIE (so it always goes to youtube mobile)
maskedlion said:
So has anyone tested the Skyfire beta?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have it. It shows a lot of promise but it's still early (version # is .5). Video is pretty choppy even over WiFi. It's one of the things they're trying to polish before release.
Make sure you are using TCPMP version 0.72RC1, and make sure you don't have any other flash plugins installed except the flashvideobundle.
I have both installed to my device memory (not memory card).
that's it really. I can go to youtube.com in PIE, tap on a video, and a little menu pops up asking if you want to play or save the video. just tap "play" and the video starts playing within a couple of seconds, and its very smooth.

Mini Dolphin or Dolphin HD

which one do you prefer???
to me mini dolphin loads quicker than HD.
I prefer Mini, HD just seemed to bloated and slow for me. I didn't really need all those plug ins. Though I've actually switched to Miren Browser myself, seems a little faster than Dolphin.
opera browser is a lot smoother and quicker in my opinion
speoples20 said:
I prefer Mini, HD just seemed to bloated and slow for me. I didn't really need all those plug ins. Though I've actually switched to Miren Browser myself, seems a little faster than Dolphin.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Firefox used to be my favorite.
but now i switch to Dolphin HD, more fun and customizable.
If comes to only Dolphin.
Then i prefer HD with powerful add-ons and fast loading.
I still use the Stock browser for most. Firefox was my undisputed reigning champion of my internet browsing. But Bolt Browser comes out swinging pretty hard. Esp for being a Alpha build. It's almost to nice.
I've also pretty much just used the stock browser for the most part. I'm curious though...haven't tried many of these 3rd party browsers, i.e. Dolphine, Opera...mostly just because I haven't seen a need to. The stock one works well IMO, but if the alternatives are even better then why not...? What are the major benefits of these other browsers? Different features and faster page loading?
sunsean said:
I've also pretty much just used the stock browser for the most part. I'm curious though...haven't tried many of these 3rd party browsers, i.e. Dolphine, Opera...mostly just because I haven't seen a need to. The stock one works well IMO, but if the alternatives are even better then why not...? What are the major benefits of these other browsers? Different features and faster page loading?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Opera Mini and Dolphin mini lack alot of features, like flash for example. But they are blazing fast. Firefox is really quick and has 1:1 desktop syncing. Bookmarks, passwords, user names EVERYTHING is 1:1. But it only supports flash lite. I cannot speak for Dolphin HD or the other one that was mentioned i've never used them. Skyfire is quick and has a-lot of plug ins.

[Q] Chrome Browser ?

How do u get the plug in necessary to view certain pages with the chrome browser..also i cannot view videos on certain sites in addition any "featured " links in google when clicked shows errors.. sorry im a chrome noob any help is appreciated..
Edit: websites show puzzle piece and says no plug in available to display this content
Because it is in a beta version, it lacks certain features and functionality. As of right now, there is no flash support. Later, they will most likely add this feature, but if you need flash now, you will need to use a different browser. My personal favorite at the moment is Boat Browser which is free on the market.
I have no issue going to youtube and playing videos via chrome.
I have also played my own websites flash slideshow via chrome without issue.
flyingwolf said:
I have no issue going to youtube and playing videos via chrome.
I have also played my own websites flash slideshow via chrome without issue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
this + i have played a couple flash games on chrome on my prime. of course it was slow and not meant for touch input, but it DID work
Flash does not work for me and I believe it is not supported by Chrome. Surprised anyone has gotten it to work.

Flash/Streaming Video Problems

Hi all,
I was wondering if anyone is having this problem. I have a Samsung Galaxy SII 4G, love this phone. However I have some issues when it comes to flash and streaming video stuff. I can seem to watch youtube videos just fine but trying to go to other sites that have flash or streaming videos, it just doesn't play at all. Also some sites with flash will only show up with a green arrow in the area where there's supposed to be a video. I have downloaded Adobe flash and Flash AIR. Have tried multiple browsers with all having the same problems. Is there a fix to this? Please help.
P.S. I know this isn't the right forum for this but I am also having this problem on my Viewsonic G-Tablet.
Thanks,
Afrowookie
Are you using the stock browser?
Try boat browser. Flash works great with it! You can also try updating flash in the market.
Sent from my SPH-D710 using Tapatalk
I have the most updated adobe flash. I have used the stock browser, firefox, dolphin and now opera. Opera seems to work the best for me, but like I said youtube videos work, but on other sites the videos don't even load, and the only way to watch some of them is by downloading them first and then viewing afterwards. I will try boat though, thanks for the reply.
afrowookie said:
I have the most updated adobe flash. I have used the stock browser, firefox, dolphin and now opera. Opera seems to work the best for me, but like I said youtube videos work, but on other sites the videos don't even load, and the only way to watch some of them is by downloading them first and then viewing afterwards. I will try boat though, thanks for the reply.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Like I said, try boat browser. Under the Settings > Set User Agent - To desktop. Should work with almost all videos.
ive installed ROBOFORM browser for it... it works perfect ...

[Q] Variable Speed YouTube Playback?

Ok. I just got through searching the forums and the net and came up empty handed so I am going to guess that this is not possible right now. But just in case I'm wrong, I thought I would post my question here where the experts live. Here's the question:
Q. Shy of downloading the video and playing it back with a different application, is there any way to change the playback speed of a YouTube or embedded video upon first launch in Android?
I have explored the html5 route and no Android browser I found can do this.
I also explored some different applications claiming to offer this but none were actually able to change the video playback speed without first downloading the video.
I have something like this for my PC now. It would be very nice for my GN3.
Thanks.
jamesmuir said:
Ok. I just got through searching the forums and the net and came up empty handed so I am going to guess that this is not possible right now. But just in case I'm wrong, I thought I would post my question here where the experts live. Here's the question:
Q. Shy of downloading the video and playing it back with a different application, is there any way to change the playback speed of a YouTube or embedded video upon first launch in Android?
I have explored the html5 route and no Android browser I found can do this.
I also explored some different applications claiming to offer this but none were actually able to change the video playback speed without first downloading the video.
I have something like this for my PC now. It would be very nice for my GN3.
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I really want to know this too. Surely a solution exists now?
The latest Firefox for Android supports variable speed playback on pluralsight.com. Nothing else I tried would.

Categories

Resources