[Q] Broken screen: Sell on Ebay or try to get Samsung to repair - AT&T Samsung Galaxy Note I717

I hope somebody can point me in the right direction. I dropped my Note (no case I am an idiot--all due to my vanity) and cracked the screen. I think I have 2 options.
1. Sell on Ebay---how much should I expect to get?
2. Try and get samsung to repair--I heard they will fix it for 200 bucks.---How do I figure out how to do that? Will it matter that I bought it on Ebay used and don't have any original info for it?
thanks

Honestly you will probably spend the same amount either way. ~200 to fix or ~200-250 selling broken and buying newer used one. I think they hold strong still at around ~500
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda app-developers app

http://forum.xda-developers.com/showthread.php?t=1487716 (Option 1- wouldn't recommend)
http://www.amazon.com/Samsung-Displ...20&sr=1-2&keywords=cracked+screen+galaxy+note (Is this what you would need? Sorry, not so great with the hardware stuff always)
http://www.buymytronics.com/Cell-Phone/Samsung/Samsung-Galaxy-Note-SGH-i717
(Option 3- This website can estimate the value of your note with defects although I do not know its reliability, may be nice to troubleshoot)
http://www.sellcell.com/phone/samsung-galaxy-note-sgh-i717/ (the top price listed here is 295, but it does not say what condition the phone is in. I will continue to look for you though. )

Hey mate
In my honest opinion and experiance i'd go the ebay option. Aim around the $300 mark.
As my replacement screen cost me 350 (in australia) also you never know if the drop has
Fractured anything internally.
So id sell it for the 300,fork out the other 200 and get a brand new one with warranty.
Just my 2cents

Yeh I would sell the device. Since the demand is still high. And save up for either another phone or use the money and wait it out ..saying if you had a backup.. And get note 2 ! if and when it does come out.. lol

don't sell on ebay
erick161 said:
Honestly you will probably spend the same amount either way. ~200 to fix or ~200-250 selling broken and buying newer used one. I think they hold strong still at around ~500
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
From personal experience selling a device like this on ebay sucks. First you must post a very detailed description of the device other wise if you get any buyer thats very picky you are going to have a very bad time paying for the shipping to and from the shipper, and then the fees are crazy, between ebay and pay pal you are going to lose like 60$ and then you have to wait for about two or three weeks before you can use the money because scumbag paypal has the buyer protection thing. If i were you i'd look for a shop to try to repair it, if not i really really recommend that you try your luck on craigslist.:good:

gk325 said:
I hope somebody can point me in the right direction. I dropped my Note (no case I am an idiot--all due to my vanity) and cracked the screen. I think I have 2 options.
1. Sell on Ebay---how much should I expect to get?
2. Try and get samsung to repair--I heard they will fix it for 200 bucks.---How do I figure out how to do that? Will it matter that I bought it on Ebay used and don't have any original info for it?
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Here's my opinion. If it's in good condition otherwise, and you really like it (who wouldn't?), I'd definitely have it fixed professionally by Samsung if you can get it done for that $200. You'll have a brand new screen on a phone that can't even be a year old yet (that can be checked by serial number and it does not matter to Samsung if you bought it used) . If you try to sell it (high eBay fees as others have mentioned, and a lot of hassle) and start with another new or used Note, I think you're going to take a much bigger loss than $200. Even for people who carry AT&T insurance, the deductible is $200.
I'd call Samsung support direct to find out if that repair quote is available.

I will buy it off you lol
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using xda app-developers app

kat3k said:
Even for people who carry AT&T insurance, the deductible is $200
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I just broke my screen and decided to use the insurance and for 200 got a new (refurb) phone with 1 yr warranty. I think 200 is a high deductible, but by telling them I lost it I could keep my broken one. Maybe get something back for the old one to soften the cost.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I717 using Tapatalk 2

Broke my glass monday getting in the truck after being out on vacation. They locked my doors over the week (they are never locked) so i had to reach across to unlock the pass door (which i never have to do) and had my phone in my back pocket. I felt it get hooked on the door close knob in the door jam and when i jumped out to throw my **** in the pass side of the truck i pulled it out and almost fell down.
EVERY f%#^ng morning i load all my **** in the pass side and have my phone in my hand while getting in the truck and set it on the rag on the floor...... i am pissed off to no end

Related

Another Best Buy Question

Trying to decide if I want to pre order from best buy or straight through ATT. I wish Amazon Wireless would announce something already!
Anywhoo . . . I don't have any real reason NOT to order from BB apart from the fact that I don't like and have sworn never to shop there again. Long, unrelated story, but so far I've made good to myself on that promise.
If I do order from BB, is there any downside? Am on contract with them in any way, or only through AT&T? Can I still take my phone to ATT for warranty claims or do I have to take it to BB?
Thanks!
You will not be in contract with BB in anyway. For warranty I'm not sure. If you order through ATT it ships out on 02/16 while supplies last. If you order through BB it ships out 02/19 with the official flip case (free) while supplies last.
LiquidArrogance said:
Trying to decide if I want to pre order from best buy or straight through ATT. I wish Amazon Wireless would announce something already!
Anywhoo . . . I don't have any real reason NOT to order from BB apart from the fact that I don't like and have sworn never to shop there again. Long, unrelated story, but so far I've made good to myself on that promise.
If I do order from BB, is there any downside? Am on contract with them in any way, or only through AT&T? Can I still take my phone to ATT for warranty claims or do I have to take it to BB?
Thanks!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Plus you can register your number(s) with Best Buy for their "Phone Freedom" promo and get a $50 gift card per line when you activate the new phone. Can use the card immediately on the phone purchase or on a future purchase. And you can upgrade anytime during 2012.
I registered my number and will use the $50 on the note. Registered my wife's number, who's due for an upgrade in late summer.
Thanks...had no idea it ran all year
mikegehl said:
Plus you can register your number(s) with Best Buy for their "Phone Freedom" promo and get a $50 gift card per line when you activate the new phone. Can use the card immediately on the phone purchase or on a future purchase. And you can upgrade anytime during 2012.
I registered my number and will use the $50 on the note. Registered my wife's number, who's due for an upgrade in late summer.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
Plus keep in mind @ best buy Black Tie protection Plan with no deductibles and buy back program.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
dmbrown81 said:
Plus keep in mind @ best buy Black Tie protection Plan with no deductibles and buy back program.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Keep in mind the BB insurance does not cover lost / stolen and is more expensive than AT&T insurance.
Maroon Mushroom said:
Keep in mind the BB insurance does not cover lost / stolen and is more expensive than AT&T insurance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you buy the Black Tie protection upfront, it's $170 for 2 years (+$30 buyback). That's only $2 more than AT&T at $7 a month.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
00mred00 said:
Thanks...had no idea it ran all year
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It does - but I believe you have to register any and all lines/numbers sometime this week. Nothing to lose - no obligation to actually do the upgrade. But $50 off per phone isn't shabby.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
mikegehl said:
It does - but I believe you have to register any and all lines/numbers sometime this week. Nothing to lose - no obligation to actually do the upgrade. But $50 off per phone isn't shabby.
Sent from my SGH-I897 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hahaha..you don't know me that well yet...I have had 6 phones in the last 6 months lol. I know I will get more.
best buy wins hands down.
not everyone has the luxury of six lines but this is what we do
We have 6 lines on our family plan (5 phones, 1 pc connect {cross upgrade HELLO})...
1.Buy device, purchase buyback, get discount on buyback for purchasing black tie (cancel black tie after 30 days)
2.Sell back Device
3.Use store credit from the buy back to purchase new phone on another line due an upgrade
4.use left over amounts for other toys, or save towards next upgrade.
I always get the newest device
It's worked out pretty well so far. Currently we are out of upgrades until September..but have a few phones that are eligible for buy back should I decide to trade them in towards one device at full price (unlikely)
our next round of upgrades start in September..right about time for the s3
sept, oct, dec, feb, then the following January '13
Oh, and you can't forget price matching...this is a very important part of the process
Maroon Mushroom said:
Keep in mind the BB insurance does not cover lost / stolen and is more expensive than AT&T insurance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lost and stolen for most people isnt an issue, its broken screens. While ours is slightly more expensive if you do the 9.99 a month, there is NO deductible for breaking you phone. The note will be classified as a tier 3 in att's insurance which means its a $200 deductible on top of the $7 a month. That is just ****ing insane lol if you do our outright price for the protection at best buy its $170 for the two years, putting it right under $7 a month. All without a deductible and unlimited claims. And Im not just trying to push our protection because I work there because frankly, you wont be buying from my store so it wont affect me. I just fully support our protection, coming from 3 broken iPhone 4's and most recently a skyrocket.
Side note, I have a concession line with ATT which I cannot get BB protection on and broke the phone. $200 to replace the vivid lol I just cancelled the line and threw the vivid in the trash
imitenotbecrazy said:
Lost and stolen for most people isnt an issue, its broken screens. While ours is slightly more expensive if you do the 9.99 a month, there is NO deductible for breaking you phone. The note will be classified as a tier 3 in att's insurance which means its a $200 deductible on top of the $7 a month. That is just ****ing insane lol if you do our outright price for the protection at best buy its $170 for the two years, putting it right under $7 a month. All without a deductible and unlimited claims. And Im not just trying to push our protection because I work there because frankly, you wont be buying from my store so it wont affect me. I just fully support our protection, coming from 3 broken iPhone 4's and most recently a skyrocket.
Side note, I have a concession line with ATT which I cannot get BB protection on and broke the phone. $200 to replace the vivid lol I just cancelled the line and threw the vivid in the trash
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
If you buy the protection Plan outright and need to service your phone you'll have to subscribe to the 9.99 afterwards or purchase it again.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
dmbrown81 said:
If you buy the protection Plan outright and need to service your phone you'll have to subscribe to the 9.99 afterwards or purchase it again.
Sent from my MB860 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yikes. Idk which best buys you guys are going but theres tons of false info here. Right now, most phones fall into the rapid exchange program. With this, the phone is sent away and a refurbished phone is sent at the same time, making the turn around time about 2-4 business days. This does NOT fulfill your protection plan, meaning it is still active and can still be used again and again with no limit to the amount of claims. If you chose to send your phone as a repair instead of exchange the typical wait time is 14-30 days. If they are unable to repaid your phone in a cost effective manor to them or it exceeds 30 days they will issue you a gift card for the full retail value of the phone so that you can pick out a new one. This WILL fulfill the protection plan. So in a strange, completely misleading way, your initial statement was kind of accurtate. If we give you a $600+ gift card to replace your phone with a different model, yes your $170 protection plan is void. What would you expect?
imitenotbecrazy said:
Yikes. Idk which best buys you guys are going but theres tons of false info here. Right now, most phones fall into the rapid exchange program. With this, the phone is sent away and a refurbished phone is sent at the same time, making the turn around time about 2-4 business days. This does NOT fulfill your protection plan, meaning it is still active and can still be used again and again with no limit to the amount of claims. If you chose to send your phone as a repair instead of exchange the typical wait time is 14-30 days. If they are unable to repaid your phone in a cost effective manor to them or it exceeds 30 days they will issue you a gift card for the full retail value of the phone so that you can pick out a new one. This WILL fulfill the protection plan. So in a strange, completely misleading way, your initial statement was kind of accurtate. If we give you a $600+ gift card to replace your phone with a different model, yes your $170 protection plan is void. What would you expect?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
that is one of the negative sides AND positive sides to the black tie protection plans.
in some cases it just isn't worth the expense (i.e. when the cost of the plan exceeds about the 50% mark, I don't buy it)
it's rare, but in some cases it just isn't logical.
In this case...$300 for the phone plus $170 for the plan...it's a hard choice.
You realistically are looking at $470 vs $600 which isn't much of a difference...unless you utilize the plan towards the end of its life
00mred00 said:
that is one of the negative sides AND positive sides to the black tie protection plans.
in some cases it just isn't worth the expense (i.e. when the cost of the plan exceeds about the 50% mark, I don't buy it)
it's rare, but in some cases it just isn't logical.
In this case...$300 for the phone plus $170 for the plan...it's a hard choice.
You realistically are looking at $470 vs $600 which isn't much of a difference...unless you utilize the plan towards the end of its life
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sorry but that logic doesn't make much sense to me. Buy a phone at 300, break it and pay 650 that equals 950, which is twice the price of the upgrade and coverage for unlimited replacements. I guess its just that I see a lot of customers coming in after multiple broken screen replacements that I don't see the logic of buying other protection or buying outright replacements. To each his own tho I suppose
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
Maroon Mushroom said:
Keep in mind the BB insurance does not cover lost / stolen and is more expensive than AT&T insurance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Consider BB insurance has no deductible. ATT charges a $200 deductible if you phone needs repair.
No you are right...my point being that breakage occurring in the first 6 months to a year the plan makes sense...beyond that it wouldn't .
Its a gamble...otherwise best buy wouldn't offers it haha. The odds are in their favor. Unless of course one pretty much knows they are going to break the phone, or manipulate the program later to get a new device.
Curious question, only because I receive multiple asnswers in store
Does best buy black tie cover cosmetic damage? I have been told yes and have been told no.
Is there a wear and tear clause? I know att has a wear and tear clause and can deny coverage. Reading their fine print I also notice they can deny if its manufacturering related as well.
imitenotbecrazy said:
Sorry but that logic doesn't make much sense to me. Buy a phone at 300, break it and pay 650 that equals 950, which is twice the price of the upgrade and coverage for unlimited replacements. I guess its just that I see a lot of customers coming in after multiple broken screen replacements that I don't see the logic of buying other protection or buying outright replacements. To each his own tho I suppose
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
00mred00 said:
hahaha..you don't know me that well yet...I have had 6 phones in the last 6 months lol. I know I will get more.
best buy wins hands down.
not everyone has the luxury of six lines but this is what we do
We have 6 lines on our family plan (5 phones, 1 pc connect {cross upgrade HELLO})...
1.Buy device, purchase buyback, get discount on buyback for purchasing black tie (cancel black tie after 30 days)
2.Sell back Device
3.Use store credit from the buy back to purchase new phone on another line due an upgrade
4.use left over amounts for other toys, or save towards next upgrade.
I always get the newest device
It's worked out pretty well so far. Currently we are out of upgrades until September..but have a few phones that are eligible for buy back should I decide to trade them in towards one device at full price (unlikely)
our next round of upgrades start in September..right about time for the s3
sept, oct, dec, feb, then the following January '13
Oh, and you can't forget price matching...this is a very important part of the process
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
U can go to att website and upgrade for 299 even if line is not ready till 2013.u still get the cheap peice untill pre orders ends
For whatever reason it does not work for any of our lines. I tried.
mintu123 said:
U can go to att website and upgrade for 299 even if line is not ready till 2013.u still get the cheap peice untill pre orders ends
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
00mred00 said:
No you are right...my point being that breakage occurring in the first 6 months to a year the plan makes sense...beyond that it wouldn't .
Its a gamble...otherwise best buy wouldn't offers it haha. The odds are in their favor. Unless of course one pretty much knows they are going to break the phone, or manipulate the program later to get a new device.
Curious question, only because I receive multiple asnswers in store
Does best buy black tie cover cosmetic damage? I have been told yes and have been told no.
Is there a wear and tear clause? I know att has a wear and tear clause and can deny coverage. Reading their fine print I also notice they can deny if its manufacturering related as well.
Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I727 using XDA App
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
In my store, and I assume in most stores, if a customer wants their phone to be sent out AND they have GSBTP, they are fully entitled to send it out. There is almost no way coverage can be denied, although the plan does specify that submersion and extreme damage (i.e, running it over with a car) is not covered. As long as the customer doesn't explicitly say that was the issue, it is usually fine.
I will say, in two years at BBYM, I have never seen a customer who purchased the protection be denied a phone being sent out. While my store is pretty good at making sure the customer is treated fairly, I can assume that BBYM wouldn't be gaining the market share it is if customers were not being treated properly.
Corvette06 said:
In my store, and I assume in most stores, if a customer wants their phone to be sent out AND they have GSBTP, they are fully entitled to send it out. There is almost no way coverage can be denied, although the plan does specify that submersion and extreme damage (i.e, running it over with a car) is not covered. As long as the customer doesn't explicitly say that was the issue, it is usually fine.
I will say, in two years at BBYM, I have never seen a customer who purchased the protection be denied a phone being sent out. While my store is pretty good at making sure the customer is treated fairly, I can assume that BBYM wouldn't be gaining the market share it is if customers were not being treated properly.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Cool cool. I have not had any claims on mobile purchases. I have run into issues on laptops in the past (worn mouse tracker) where I was told it was wear and tear/ cosmetic and had to physically show them that the tracker no longer worked properly. The same with USB ports.
Thanks for chiming in!

[Q] Best Buy warranty

Question about anyone who has used the best buy "black tie protection plan":
I figured it was worth it, i convinced my parents to get it for their galaxy s2's. its like 3 dollars extra a month, but theres no deductible. compared to the whopping 200 dollars if you use atts insurance.
of course it doesnt cover loss or theft, but the way i figure, i dont use cases, i think phones should be naked if you have insurance, so i will probably break mine more than i would lose it and still on the off chance that i do lose it, im only saving a couple hundred dollars, becuase att would still be charging me 200 dollars.
The process seems to be; Break your phone with any accidental damage from handling, water damage (it says spills i think, but the guy in the store seemed to think it meant submersion, does it?) If it stops working.... bring it into best buy, they give you a loner android phone, (im ok using a loner for a couple days as long as its android phone) and then i think they send yours back and then get your new/refurbished one.
Is this a smart move or should i just cancel it and use at&t's?
also, will they know i rooted?
I dont know about the rooting but this plan worked for me and my Streak. I broke the screen after having it for a year and they replaced no questions asked and it was flashed so I say go for it.
Do you have the Black Tie protection? Is was $10/month for my Note but I paid $180 (I think) upfront for 2 years of coverage. It was tough, but I just know this phone will break. I went through 3 screens on my Streak
mottyengel said:
Question about anyone who has used the best buy "black tie protection plan":
I figured it was worth it, i convinced my parents to get it for their galaxy s2's. its like 3 dollars extra a month, but theres no deductible. compared to the whopping 200 dollars if you use atts insurance.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
diomed said:
Do you have the Black Tie protection? Is was $10/month for my Note but I paid $180 (I think) upfront for 2 years of coverage. It was tough, but I just know this phone will break. I went through 3 screens on my Streak
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah you're right, it's $10 a month or $170 up front. The guy told me they send you a replacement phone that is made up of parts from returned defective phones. So they are just like new.
It may sound like a plug because I work for best buy mobile but I personally think their plan is awesome.
I have used it a good amount of times on my smart phones and have never had any issues. I also see a lot of customers having good experiences with it. Sure you will find some people that the system didnt work for because they really messed up their phones but thatll happen with anything.
About the loaner phones, I wouldnt count on them having a loaner android. I just know from my store and the stores around that its a refurbed iphone 3g that we give out and we usually dont have any in. This means the customer has to buy a POS prepaid to get through the couple days till the new one comes in. Just figured I would give you a heads up.

[Q] Phone Warranty

So it looks like we will get our new EVOs this week. I have been trying to decide what warranty would be best to protect this new phone in the event of a drop or some other human educed fail. I have narrowed the list down to the following two and was wondering if anyone has any experience with these warranties:
Zagg Safe. Reasonable price and covers rooted phones (which I plan to do with my new EVO):
Squaretrade. Recommended to me by a friend.
ride4mud said:
So it looks like we will get our new EVOs this week. I have been trying to decide what warranty would be best to protect this new phone in the event of a drop or some other human educed fail. I have narrowed the list down to the following two and was wondering if anyone has any experience with these warranties:
Zagg Safe. Reasonable price and covers rooted phones (which I plan to do with my new EVO):
Squaretrade. Recommended to me by a friend.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have about 12 squaretrade warranties, but have never had to turn in a claim yet. If you do decide on them, make sure you use a 30% off coupon. I get an email from them every Tuesday with a code attached for 30% off.
I personally am going to just stick with the Sprint warranty on this phone. The monthly price sucks, but I have had to bring in phones multiple times in the past for repairs, and have never had to pay a deductible. So it has its advantages. But when you don't use it, it does feel like a HUGE waste of money. If I had $600 in my pocket, I might would just skip the warranty altogether, but unfortunately for me I don't. Paying a monthly fee, then deductible if needed is much easier for me to do.
I'm considering trying Ensquared.
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA
Warranty? Or insurance?
Sent from my PC36100 using XDA
I'm going with ZaggSafe, but I have no past experience with them.
Decided to go with Zagg. Seems like a good deal and they cover rooted phones. Time will tell when I actually need to us it.
Captain_Throwback said:
I'm going with ZaggSafe, but I have no past experience with them.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Zagg is just lending it's name. They outsource their claims to another company called warrantech, I think, and they have horrible reviews. If you check the BBB website they have over 450 negative claims.
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
jpratt0310 said:
Zagg is just lending it's name. They outsource their claims to another company called warrantech, I think, and they have horrible reviews. If you check the BBB website they have over 450 negative claims.
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well we will have to see what happens to see with the whole Zagg thing. You know people are more likely to leave negative feedback than positive feedback, so you never really know. If it turns out to be no good, shame Zagg will have their name ruined.
I bought my phone at BestBuy, bought 2 yrs for 160. That is equal to less than 7 dollars a month, no deductible. The only thing not covered is lost phones and I always have my phone on me. No questions asked, they take the phone and in 2-3 days I have a brand-new looking refurbished phone. I've never had a problem with the refurbished quality. Apperently they always replace all of the outside parts to make it look like new. I've gotten several refurbished through Sprint and they are always dents, scratches, etc.
Yea I get what you're saying. check out ensquared, too. I went to the website and they cover theft and loss and have a higher claims limit.
Sent from my PC36100 using xda premium
Best buy will not replace a phone in 2-3 days. Unless they have changed their policy in the last year, it takes a minimum of 2 weeks to send a phone out and get it back repaired the first time. After that, they will escalate your phone to overnight delivery, supposedly. To get a new phone, yours must be sent out 3 times and returned unrepaired. On the 4th time, they evaluate if a new phone is deemed necessary.
I know, I went through it last year and it took 6 weeks to get a replacement phone. That's 6 weeks without a phone and sprint wouldn't compensate me because best buy was the culprit. Did best buy compensate me? Ha. No.
Oh, and the "loaner phone" is only loaned after you give them a $150 deposit.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium

Lifetime Phone Warranty

Why not just pay $9.99 to get Best Buy Black Tie Protection?
No deductible.
Unlimited claims.
Free loaner phone if yours has to be special ordered.
Covers all physical damage except full water submersion.
Cancel any time free.
Those are the exact words I was told when buying my phone.
I got Black Tie.
Persuade me to cancel it so I can save money.
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
newfireorange said:
Why not just pay $9.99 to get Best Buy Black Tie Protection?
No deductible.
Unlimited claims.
Free loaner phone if yours has to be special ordered.
Covers all physical damage except full water submersion.
Cancel any time free.
Those are the exact words I was told when buying my phone.
I got Black Tie.
Persuade me to cancel it so I can save money.
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Number one reason is the wait to get your phone back can be a week or two weeks sometimes a month the program is good but I can't go that long without my phone
Ask sprint about their options I think if you are just worried about cracked screens and stuff you can get protection through them for.that at like 4 bucks a month. If I am wrong someone interject. Reason I say 4 is I don't think the tep has raised yet and if u lock it in now it won't raise till you resign...
I do not have Black Tie but I heard that its pretty awful. At times they do not honor replacements.
Google it for more info.
I have Black Tie, but I gotta tell you: the whole "free loaner phone if yours has to be special ordered"? Count on rocking a crappy old Android or a BlackBerry for a little bit if your phone can't be initially just fixed....
Here's the rub: yours IS gonna have to be special ordered, if you need a replacement, no matter if your Best Buy has 500 new EVOs in stock: they won't let you have one of theirs. For me, for the times I had to use it, I waited about 2 weeks the first time (because it was "backordered", even though my Best Buy had plenty), and about 3 days the second.
Of course, you also are also DEFINITELY getting a refurb, count on that 100%.
*I still use it, like I said, but the guy at Best Buy won't tell you all these little "details", which, I think, is a bit shady.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
I waited a month for a broken charger port on my OG Evo. Seemed like an eternity. Got it back and found that while they fixed the port, they blew out the light on the menu button (looked like it was missing a tooth) . Wasn't going to wait again with a beat up small lender phone.
Gave me a scratched and dented LG Optimus. Big ole scratch on the screen.
Sent from my Galaxy Nexus using XDA
Lol at the people that don't like brick and mortar stores its that that is hurting the economy why buy it somewhere and pay a little extra and take a little extra time n pay tax when u can order it online for cheaper ans not pay tax. However I heard awhile back they where or are trying to put laws in place for sales tax on online items.
newfireorange said:
Why not just pay $9.99 to get Best Buy Black Tie Protection?
No deductible.
Unlimited claims.
Free loaner phone if yours has to be special ordered.
Covers all physical damage except full water submersion.
Cancel any time free.
Those are the exact words I was told when buying my phone.
I got Black Tie.
Persuade me to cancel it so I can save money.
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I actually just dropped sprints insurance and am going to straight up buy the black tie insurance for $170 for the 2 year protection. How sprint is Jacking up the price on everything you would be paying $264 for 2 years not including the $150-$200 deductible. Hell if I can save $100-$250 with BB with a refurbished phone and wait 2 weeks its worth it.
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
ZAGG has insurance as well. I think its 100$ for 2yrs and covers everything with a 100$ deductible. Might wanna look into that.
James
best buy also doesnt cover lost or stolen tho if you use mobile defense or sprint locator those arent a huge issue..
ckoadiyn Lol at the people that don't like brick and mortar stores its that that is hurting the economy why buy it somewhere and pay a little extra and take a little extra time n pay tax when u can order it online for cheaper ans not pay tax. However I heard awhile back they where or are trying to put laws in place for sales tax on online items.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes cause buying online is different then buying in brick and mortar... the store actually makes more of a profit from online sales then store. and i paid taxes when i ordered from sprint tyvm.. the only thing being loss on online sales is taxes to the state but as someone who works in retail i can also tell you all the people using food stamps arent helping much either.. lord forbid they dont get their tax free soda chips and fat cakes
grrmisfit said:
best buy also doesnt cover lost or stolen tho if you use mobile defense or sprint locator those arent a huge issue..
yes cause buying online is different then buying in brick and mortar... the store actually makes more of a profit from online sales then store. and i paid taxes when i ordered from sprint tyvm.. the only thing being loss on online sales is taxes to the state but as someone who works in retail i can also tell you all the people using food stamps arent helping much either.. lord forbid they dont get their tax free soda chips and fat cakes
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Lol that is probably true but I always get the impression most shop amazon etc n I know it is just state taxes but still. I don't have a problem with food stamps for those that use it correctly however many people don't use it correctly
ckoadiyn said:
Lol that is probably true but I always get the impression most shop amazon etc n I know it is just state taxes but still. I don't have a problem with food stamps for those that use it correctly however many people don't use it correctly
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i use online cause its a convenience . i work over nights so i can shop while everything is closed and its usually cheaper cause they save on labor and other things a brick and mortar has to pay.. walk into a kmart.. have their website loaded and check prices, you will see that a lot of their stuff is more expensive in stores then online and they will not price match
grrmisfit said:
i use online cause its a convenience . i work over nights so i can shop while everything is closed and its usually cheaper cause they save on labor and other things a brick and mortar has to pay.. walk into a kmart.. have their website loaded and check prices, you will see that a lot of their stuff is more expensive in stores then online and they will not price match
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah and is rather pay extra to know that American people have a job even if it is a store and 5 extra dollars that's all im trying to say we have to many people to be cutting jobs and companies can pick up and leave over seas. Btw I agree 3rd sucks I work 12-8 am and it is hard a lot of.the time
But all and all price wise. BB is the cheapest if you don't mind waiting a couple days for a replacement refurbished phone and the fact they don't cover loss or theft. Anyone object?
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
xbmoyx said:
But all and all price wise. BB is the cheapest if you don't mind waiting a couple days for a replacement refurbished phone and the fact they don't cover loss or theft. Anyone object?
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope however I am interested in zagg..
I use http://www.squaretrade.com - $119 for two years protection after tax and 10% discount (coupon code TENFTEN).
You still pay a $99 deductible, and no coverage for theft or loss....but it has great reviews which is comforting. And at about $5/month...much better deal.
Sent from my Evo4GLTE
I had the black tie protection and I'll tell you why it isn't so hot.
First, doesn't cover lost or stolen phones.
Second, loaner phones require a $150 deposit.
Third, when I used the insurance to fix a broken charging port, I sent the phone in on Jan 2nd. The phone came back unrepaired 3 times. I finally got a replacement phone the second week of February. Believe me, I would have gladly gave a hundred dollars for a replacement from sprint.
Learned my lesson on best buy protection.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
ckoadiyn said:
Ask sprint about their options I think if you are just worried about cracked screens and stuff you can get protection through them for.that at like 4 bucks a month. If I am wrong someone interject. Reason I say 4 is I don't think the tep has raised yet and if u lock it in now it won't raise till you resign...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The 4$ is still the same for service and repairs. However the replacement part of the TEP has gone up i believe.
And no the TEP will be raised for everyone but only in September if you sign up for TEP before july 17th.
stumblebum said:
I use http://www.squaretrade.com - $119 for two years protection after tax and 10% discount (coupon code TENFTEN).
You still pay a $99 deductible, and no coverage for theft or loss....but it has great reviews which is comforting. And at about $5/month...much better deal.
Sent from my Evo4GLTE
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Do you get a brand new phone? Do they cover loss/theft?
Sent from my PG86100 using xda premium
newfireorange said:
Why not just pay $9.99 to get Best Buy Black Tie Protection?
No deductible.
Unlimited claims.
Free loaner phone if yours has to be special ordered.
Covers all physical damage except full water submersion.
Cancel any time free.
Those are the exact words I was told when buying my phone.
I got Black Tie.
Persuade me to cancel it so I can save money.
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ckoadiyn said:
Number one reason is the wait to get your phone back can be a week or two weeks sometimes a month the program is good but I can't go that long without my phone
Ask sprint about their options I think if you are just worried about cracked screens and stuff you can get protection through them for.that at like 4 bucks a month. If I am wrong someone interject. Reason I say 4 is I don't think the tep has raised yet and if u lock it in now it won't raise till you resign...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I work for Best Buy and am very familiar with the GSBTP plans (Geek Squad Black Tie Protection). What I am about to say is my own opinion and not that of Best Buy's.
That being said, I am going to give you an unbiased opinion on this because I see both sides to what you guys are saying. I bought my phone outright from BBY 2 days ago. Did I buy GSBTP? No, here is why: I like the lost or stolen option from Asurion/Sprint and I never had to use it until 2 weeks ago when someone stole my EVO 3D from my store. I tried remote locating it and all that crap and it didn't help. Paid the deductible through Asurion (should have been $100 but they told me $50) and got a replacement the next day.
As far as what GSBTP offers, yeah, it's not bad. But there are some things that need clarified in what has been said in this thread. The replacements now are all "Rapid Exchange", as in, you come into BBY and we fill out all the paperwork to get you a new phone. What happens is that the system then generates and order for a refurbished phone to be shipped that day while we send yours back to them at the same time. This means that you will get a new phone within 3 business days, not too bad.
However, the loaner phones are pretty crappy, as mentioned. But stores are suppose to charge you $50 for the loaner phone that gets returned back to you after you return it. They don't all do that, but they are supposed to, so keep that in mind that YMMV.
Everything else in the OP is right. BBY won't deny a claim unless you fully submerged it, nor would they even know that unless you told them. There is a girl at my store that literally drops and shatters her iPhone screen atleast 2 times a month and it's been happening for over a year now, never had an issue. Also, with GSPTB, you are entitled to a 1-time battery replacement on your phone as well which is awesome, but unfortunately doesn't apply to phones without removable batteries.
Hopefully this clarified things for you guys and gave you an idea of both sides to the GSBTP story
@-viperboy-
Thank you for the clarification.
~ I'm a fungi

[Q] Insurance on Phones? Really??

this was mentioned in another thread... just didnt want to hijack the thread so i post it in a new one...
It will void your HTC "factory" warranty but if u have sprint tep then you can use the unroot and relock methods posted in the threads and you should be able to return them to sprint for repairs and such
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So, i never gave any insurances for phones a big thought... if you think, that I had plenty phones, and none of them got so damaged, lost, thrown in the water... that I was worried about insurance...
I mean you pay depending where about 10$ per month (2 years 240$) so if you just in case can get your phone replaced and pay another 100$ deductable... so in the end i pay 340$ to be sure I could have a replacment phone... now in other words...if i say the phone is worth 600$ that would mean that every 2nd person would need to replace there phone so it makes sense for a consumer to buy this... really every 2nd person? still it seems to be popular in these forums...
I mean yeah i had a display break from one of my phone some time back went to the store ordered a new display 100$ done... here i would have still overpaid 200$ so I don't quite get it... but I do have an open mind to be convinced
My example is absolutely simplified... and they offer repair services as well... I understand, but still...
Am i just talking good care of my stuff? so that i dont worry about this so much ? just wondering...
I think of it like this do I have in pocket over 500 to replace my phone nope. So ten bucks a month is easier when I do need replacmet and pay 100. Second is piece of mind, I did a few replacements and fixes which is good. In the end sprint and insurance wins. The thing that bugs me was a few years back the amount of fraud going on and that's why it gets more expensive when it comes to insurance.
Sent from my EVO using XDA
This is a good example why I don't have sprints TEP. It's a big rip off. I personally like using best buy black tie protection. I paid $170 for 2 years it doesn't have a deductible it is cheaper than sprints TEP.
Sent from my EVO using XDA
I personally think it's a waste of money. If I drop my phone on the sidewalk or in the toilet, I'll suck it up and get a cheap phone off Craigslist until I can save up for a replacement. I'd rather that than spend that much money a month on insurance. Besides, don't you all put a few bucks into an emergency fund every month anyway?
People say just be careful with your phone and you won't need insurance and if you can't do that then get ibsurance. Sure that's a good point, but there's no way I can watch out for it every day nor do I want to pile up money for insurance so small investments for quality cases and screen shields do that job for me for much less than paying insurance a month, so now I only have to worry about it for exceptionally dangerous days (camping, swimming, etc) which is easy if you remind yourself how important your phone is and how crazy it'll be without it. Living like this, I've never broken a phone.
But that's just me. I like someone else's idea, instead of investing your money in insurance where you never get it back, put it aside as a "phone" funds for yourself at the same rate this way you can keep your own money if you don't use it. You'll be paying more for the replacement, but if you generally don't break phones you'll be saving more money than you spend if you don't break it the next time (easier said than done, but I did say "if you generally don't break phones")
Basically, insurance is for people who either:
1) want to throw away money
or
2) break phones often (2+ times within one 2-year agreement)
Personally I don't think insurance is a bad idea but I do think sprints TEP structure is a total ripoff. Looking at a few EVO LTE on Ebay they're already going for under retail and I've seen a few open box sell for $450. I could only imagine what our phones would sell for in a couple of months. These phones will be so affordable soon rendering TEP a total ripoff if one had to pay a $200 deductible.
Sent from my EVO using XDA
forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=26638575&postcount=92
Please consider searching before starting new threads. This topic has had at least 3 threads dedicated to it, and the above link details under what circumstances a person should consider insuring their phone.
Sent from my EVO LTE using Tapatalk 2
If you don't want insurance then don't take it . Simplified answer.
Peace of mind coupled with not having to pay $500-$600 at once for a replacement.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
PaulHBK said:
Peace of mind coupled with not having to pay $500-$600 at once for a replacement.
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
As mentioned, you'd be getting ripped off to pay that much for a replacement now that Ebay is stocked up and people are looking ahead to the SGS3.
But, hey, at least we're not being forced by anybody to carry phone insurance. Yet.
SilverZero said:
As mentioned, you'd be getting ripped off to pay that much for a replacement now that Ebay is stocked up and people are looking ahead to the SGS3.
But, hey, at least we're not being forced by anybody to carry phone insurance. Yet.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
What are you talking about?! EVO LTEs are not going for low on eBay. They are auctioning for no less than $500 and "buy it now" options mostly around $600 and ABOVE. Don't spew "information" that doesn't truly benifit your point...
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
PaulHBK said:
What are you talking about?! EVO LTEs are not going for low on eBay. They are auctioning for no less than $500 and "buy it now" options mostly around $600 and ABOVE. Don't spew "information" that doesn't truly benifit your point...
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The one with "buy it now" are just sitting there without any one buying them. And I've seen a few auctioning off for $450-$475. I will post links when I get to my laptop
Sent from my EVO using XDA
Mathman85 said:
forum.xda-developers.com/showpost.php?p=26638575&postcount=92
Please consider searching before starting new threads. This topic has had at least 3 threads dedicated to it, and the above link details under what circumstances a person should consider insuring their phone.
Sent from my EVO LTE using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well I actually did do a search and had a couple entries.... But nothing big really..... Might have not look long enough
Sent from my EVO using Tapatalk 2
PaulHBK said:
What are you talking about?! EVO LTEs are not going for low on eBay. They are auctioning for no less than $500 and "buy it now" options mostly around $600 and ABOVE. Don't spew "information" that doesn't truly benifit your point...
Sent from my EVO using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No less then $500?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090309202...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090304509...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090166495...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
I think the bottom line here is if you want phone insurance, get phone insurance. If you don't, then you don't. It's that simple. However, I kinda find it interesting that a lot of people say hey I don't need phone insurance but are the same people that get insurance on electronics. I know it's much cheaper and there's no deductible but if you are gonna be a stickler then be one 100% of the time. Insurance is there for those that wanna be proactive and have a peace of mind at the end of the day. Think of how much money we throw away paying car, home and renters insurance without ever putting in a claim? I know all these things are mandatory but honestly we waste thousands upon thousands upon thousands for those things. However, it's the peace of mind knowing that if you smash your car up, your home gets burglarized or catches fire, you'll be covered and so will your valuables( if you pay that extra $200 a year or more for that). If these things didn't carry mandatory weight, would we have car or home insurance? It's the same question to ask yourself when looking to purchase phone insurance( minus the mandatory part). I carry the TEP insurance because it protects me against EVERYTHING! I know there is a deductible but it works for me. I've heard horror stories about BBs Black Tie Protection. Yeah there is no deductible but what you have to go through to get your phone fixed is not worth the $94 you'll save vs the Sprint plan and in the end you end up getting a refurbished phone anyways. That's like saying I'll go to Joe Schmoe to get my car fixed because he is cheaper than the dealership but end up getting your car back with more problems than you started out with. I just say go with what you like. In the same breath, you can't ridicule or belittle someone for being proactive imho.
My old Palm Centro, Palm Pre, and Evo Shift...
Centro had worn out button panel, and then someone stepped on it a bit and the button panel broke on the corner.... free repair in 1 day
Palm Pre died and stopped turning on... Free new or "like new" replacement 2 business days
Second Palm Pre died and stopped turning on... Free new or "like new" replacement 2 business days
Evo Shift died and stopped turning on... Free new or "like new" replacement 2 business days
Second Evo Shift died and stopped turning on... Free new or "like new" replacement 2 business days
So this is why I keep my Sprint TEP
Never paid a dime aside from the monthly fee
shook187 said:
No less then $500?
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090309202...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090304509...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
http://www.ebay.com/itm/18090166495...AX:IT&_trksid=p3984.m1438.l2649#ht_500wt_1182
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ok. Still close to $500 on those though. And I'd still rather not have to pay $470 at once though...
Sent from my LTEvo using XDA Premium
PaulHBK said:
Ok. Still close to $500 on those though. And I'd still rather not have to pay $470 at once though...
Sent from my LTEvo using XDA Premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
$470 now $370 next month $270 the following month. Eventually the phone will level off around $225-$300. At that point making sprint deductible of $200 a total ripoff. I guess TEP is a good investment within the first 4 months of a phones released.
Sent from my EVO using XDA
Well lets put it this way I've had phones since they first came out. Remember that BIG Motorola ! Also one of the first car phones. I've never had insurance or had a need for it. Same with screen protectors. Each to his own.
Sprint tep has gotten me out of soo many o**** moments that I will continue to pay for it and is probably one of the main reasons I have stuck it out with sprint. No other carrier has "repair" centers like sprint does
Sent from my GT-I9300 using xda premium

Categories

Resources