I have been doing research on the 8X ever since it came out, and the phone looks gorgeous. Perfect screen size for me, great colors, new OS (being a current Android user), and from what I've heard it is really smooth. However, after reading other threads, I have had trouble deciding whether to go with the 920 or the 8X. The 920 is made by Nokia, the top Windows Phone company, but to me it seems like they overdid the camera to a point where the lowlight pictures look awful. But it is a popular phone. Which one would you pick if you were me, a smartphone junkie who doesn't use camera often, but may need to quickly access it from time to time; a Zune fanatic; and one who stresses comfort, size, and performance as a balance in a phone, to maintain at least two years of life?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
if you love zune you should not that the 8x has only 16gb where the lumia has 32gb. The 8x though will have better sound esp for bass. Also you said about build quality and that is nokias strong point, there phones last and last while every htc I have had just falls apart. Also the 920's plastic is colored all the way through not just painted so if you do scratch it then its not a problem. Also note that you get nokia drive a great sat nav as well as wireless charging and matching headsets speakers etc. Also the screen on the 920 is a long way better it has darker blacks faster refresh rates and is brighter not to mention that it has ultra sensitive touch screen.
The 8x is slimmer though, the 920 is a fat boy. In my world I cant recommend the 8x however, if it had more mem or an sd it would be tight as I think its better looking and a better size. Phone at the mo are getting stupid in this race for bigger screens and higher specs. In a perfect world I would have the 8s with more ram and dual 1.5 but again htc messed it up.
The things I do not like about the Nokia is the plastic backing and its Pureview camera. Do the benefits outweigh these things?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
Dadstar said:
I have been doing research on the 8X ever since it came out, and the phone looks gorgeous. Perfect screen size for me, great colors, new OS (being a current Android user), and from what I've heard it is really smooth. However, after reading other threads, I have had trouble deciding whether to go with the 920 or the 8X. The 920 is made by Nokia, the top Windows Phone company, but to me it seems like they overdid the camera to a point where the lowlight pictures look awful. But it is a popular phone. Which one would you pick if you were me, a smartphone junkie who doesn't use camera often, but may need to quickly access it from time to time; a Zune fanatic; and one who stresses comfort, size, and performance as a balance in a phone, to maintain at least two years of life?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ive used the HTC HD7 since it came out on Tmobile 2 years ago. The only problem Ive had with it is the proximety sensor comming loose. It's got 16gb, but Ive never filled it. I had a ton of games, and stream my music from the cloud. I was excited to hear that tmobile would be carrying the new HTCs! The only thing I wasnt sure, do the 8s and the 8x have micro sd slots? My htc hd7 takes great pictures. The nokia would be a good phone too. Its got a better camera, more memory, and nokia exclusive apps, but probably won't be offered on Tmoble. Either way you go though, HTC or nokia you'll be getting a good solid phone on a nice solid os. WP 7/7.5/7.8 have done everything I needed it to smoothly, quickly, and without freezing, or haveing to reboot.
aclegg2011 said:
Ive used the HTC HD7 since it came out on Tmobile 2 years ago. The only problem Ive had with it is the proximety sensor comming loose. It's got 16gb, but Ive never filled it. I had a ton of games, and stream my music from the cloud. I was excited to hear that tmobile would be carrying the new HTCs! The only thing I wasnt sure, do the 8s and the 8x have micro sd slots? My htc hd7 takes great pictures. The nokia would be a good phone too. Its got a better camera, more memory, and nokia exclusive apps, but probably won't be offered on Tmoble. Either way you go though, HTC or nokia you'll be getting a good solid phone on a nice solid os. WP 7/7.5/7.8 have done everything I needed it to smoothly, quickly, and without freezing, or haveing to reboot.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No they do not come with SD expansion. At least the 8X doesn't. See, I was thinking about streaming music from the cloud, but 1) how much cloud storage do i get and is it free, and 2) does that drain battery? For me now it all pretty much comes down to the screen and general functionality. However, the HTC 8X has that awesome clock tile that the 920 does not have. So I'll see. Still need feedback, though! And I have Verizon, and they are offering both. That's why I'm so conflicted
I think you should try both of them out before you decide. That way, you know yourself which one you would prefer.
Sent from my #Motofail... Further Plans coming soon...
Really considering getting a WP8 device as I feel like a change from Android. iOS is rubbish so lets not even consider that (I already have an Android tab + iPad so won't miss the OS's)
Everywhere I read seems to say get the 920 over the 8x.. my only issue with the 920 is that it looks a bit chunky?
3473 said:
Really considering getting a WP8 device as I feel like a change from Android. iOS is rubbish so lets not even consider that (I already have an Android tab + iPad so won't miss the OS's)
Everywhere I read seems to say get the 920 over the 8x.. my only issue with the 920 is that it looks a bit chunky?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah but you can't deny that it has an awesome camera. Other than that, it has more storage than the 8X, bigger screen, potentially more support. But the 8X looks sleeker.
Sent from my #Motofail... Further Plans coming soon...
tatperson said:
Yeah but you can't deny that it has an awesome camera. Other than that, it has more storage than the 8X, bigger screen, potentially more support. But the 8X looks sleeker.
Sent from my #Motofail... Further Plans coming soon...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True say, though me personally I never use the camera :laugh: The Lumia 920 still looks great though even without the camera, guess I'll just buy whichever device comes out first
at this point, im liking the nokia maps/music/camera :S yeah i'm starting to pick at the software because the hardware on both wins me over
Hardware is very similar between the two. The snapdragon is really good the sound quality from it is decent as well you can read gsmarena HTC One S review and check out the audio review. My sister has it and it sounds better than my One X. The SLCD2 on the One X is easily one of the best displays to date so no issues with the 8X there. The camera is also good and takes some great pictures.
Like the user above me said it will come down to software and I think Nokia edges it slightly especially the free music streaming something I would make use of. The slightly bigger screen also appeals to me and that fact it's a Nokia my last Nokia was the 5800 and have been etching for a good handset from them.
I will try the 920 out, now whether it can tempt me away from Android that's another discussion on its own.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
nikzDHD said:
Hardware is very similar between the two. The snapdragon is really good the sound quality from it is decent as well you can read gsmarena HTC One S review and check out the audio review. My sister has it and it sounds better than my One X. The SLCD2 on the One X is easily one of the best displays to date so no issues with the 8X there. The camera is also good and takes some great pictures.
Like the user above me said it will come down to software and I think Nokia edges it slightly especially the free music streaming something I would make use of. The slightly bigger screen also appeals to me and that fact it's a Nokia my last Nokia was the 5800 and have been etching for a good handset from them.
I will try the 920 out, now whether it can tempt me away from Android that's another discussion on its own.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Free music streaming... Meaning what exactly? Like, music you stored in the cloud?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
Dadstar said:
Free music streaming... Meaning what exactly? Like, music you stored in the cloud?
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
nokia music is kind of like google music, slightly better selection imo for free things
http://www.nokia.com/global/apps/nokia/music/
that said, since google music doesn't have an native app that I know of on WP, nokia music pretty much wins the music race for me on WP. There are 3rd pt apps for it, i just prefer using apps for services made by the service...
I'm in this same boat....after owning a One X and now the GS3, i've learned to really not enjoy the samsung (again). I didn't like my captivate, loved my Inspire 4G. Loved my One X, so-so feelings on the GS3. So for me, Ativ S is out.
To me, the hardware/software is so close that it has basically came down to which will get better developer support down the road. It seems like the 920 is getting the initial praise and most people are looking forward to it, but with WP7, it seems like the HTC phones are the ones getting the ROM's/dev support.
What do you all think? Which will be most popular with the Dev's??
They will be equally popular with world-wide devs.
The nokia one just gets some more exclusive apps, but HTC has apps as well. It now depends on how you plan on using them.
And for every exclusive nokia app there is a free, available to everybody, third party app.
Also if its app sits worth a note that most exclusives get hacked and ported to other devices ie nokia maps etc
The 16GB limit on the 8X is a real disappointment. I don't love the fatboy formfactor of the 920...but can't get by the 16GB limit. I just can't understand why they did the 8S with expandable memory and the 8X has none (yes, I know, unibody ... but my One X has 32GB internal!!!).
lumpaywk said:
Also if its app sits worth a note that most exclusives get hacked and ported to other devices ie nokia maps etc
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes, why i dont object to porting... i do kind of feel like something like nokia maps ported is stealing :S and i can see others wanting it... if i have a chance to just buy the nokia one i will if the maps is what I wanted out of it
mickliq said:
The 16GB limit on the 8X is a real disappointment. I don't love the fatboy formfactor of the 920...but can't get by the 16GB limit. I just can't understand why they did the 8S with expandable memory and the 8X has none (yes, I know, unibody ... but my One X has 32GB internal!!!).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They nay have another version later on. Or maybe they are changing it right now. Who knows.
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
eyeb said:
yes, why i dont object to porting... i do kind of feel like something like nokia maps ported is stealing :S and i can see others wanting it... if i have a chance to just buy the nokia one i will if the maps is what I wanted out of it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the thing, though. I will barely use the Maps app, if at all. That's why those Nokia apps aren't of much concern.
Sent from my SCH-I500 using xda app-developers app
Related
Hey just got HTC Radar..
Really a great phone, simply love WP7 and the hardware...
but was really supriced to se nothing going on in the HTC Radar forum ??
why is that ?
I will be on board when it is released on Wednesday in USA!
Unfortunately because it is new and cannot be interop-unlocked there is not much development ergo activity in this forum. Most peeps dwell on the WP7 General forum.
Hopefully after the US release we will see some more activity.
Hey I had a quick question. Is there a big air-gap between the screen and the glass?
Also does it have an S-LCD or just a regular LCD.
Thanks I want this phone but dont want too much compromise.
azzeh3 said:
Hey I had a quick question. Is there a big air-gap between the screen and the glass?
Also does it have an S-LCD or just a regular LCD.
Thanks I want this phone but dont want too much compromise.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
http://www.phonearena.com/phones/HTC-Radar_id5560
Says S-LCD.
I've had the phone for a couple of weeks already (I'm in Belgium) and I'm coming from the Nexus One (Android).
Must say I'm really impressed, great build quality and WP7 is great, really not much to complain about except things that are to be expected with a system that is still growing like WP7.
And yes, I'm hoping there will be a little more activity development wise when the phone is released in the US, right now there's not much going on for this phone...
I checked the phone out in a store the other day and all I can say is the screen is one of the biggest pluses on this device! It is gorgeous - you will not be disappointed.
I actually prefer the S-LCD that HTC is using to the Super Amoled screens from Samsung or just about any other display (save for the IPS displays Apples uses).
The other thing that stikes me when I hold this phone is how solid and sturdy it feels, but also how light and thin it is. It's really nice!
I do not see any air-gap really. Screen is S-LCD and its quite a masterpiece, sad that it still cannot be produced for bigger screens. Thou be aware, that it is not Super-AMOLED. That means the S-LCD blacks are still not exatly black tho close enough.
pittphan said:
I checked the phone out in a store the other day and all I can say is the screen is one of the biggest pluses on this device! It is gorgeous - you will not be disappointed.
I actually prefer the S-LCD that HTC is using to the Super Amoled screens from Samsung or just about any other display (save for the IPS displays Apples uses).
The other thing that stikes me when I hold this phone is how solid and sturdy it feels, but also how light and thin it is. It's really nice!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
sala91 said:
I do not see any air-gap really. Screen is S-LCD and its quite a masterpiece, sad that it still cannot be produced for bigger screens. Thou be aware, that it is not Super-AMOLED. That means the S-LCD blacks are still not exatly black tho close enough.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks guys Im probably going to pick one up this weekend. Im with T-mobile USA and the only scary thing about getting this is the fact that if the merger goes through I would be screwed form in compatible bands.
im on my 5 day with HTC Radar, and i simply belive that RADAR is one of the BEST phones HTC has produced for a LOOONG time...
The quality is simply amasing and with a good speaker and really good sound when you talk in it...
And it's with WP7 I can not tell how much i love WP7. im coming from ANDROID and IOS ( SGS2, Sensation and iPhone 4) yes the spec on RADAR is not as amasing but I love it and think its better...
For me WP7 is overtaking Android and IOS and im a big ANDROID FAN...
No gyroscope and compass
Sent from my Radar C110e using Board Express
No jailbreak too at 8gb I missed my LG optimus 7
Sent from my Radar C110e using Board Express
s4cr3d said:
No jailbreak too at 8gb I missed my LG optimus 7
Sent from my Radar C110e using Board Express
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know 8gb is less but again it will more than enough for most of the people,since i do not care for music on my phone music
azzeh3 said:
Thanks guys Im probably going to pick one up this weekend. Im with T-mobile USA and the only scary thing about getting this is the fact that if the merger goes through I would be screwed form in compatible bands.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The box says it supports UMTS 1900. I guess T-Mo had the merger in mind when they sourced this phone.
Just got the Radar yesterday. Excited to get into some dev work. My first Windows Phone.
s4cr3d said:
No gyroscope and compass
Sent from my Radar C110e using Board Express
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So without a compass, what does that mean for navigation apps like those for geocaching, they simply won't work?
vikramdhani said:
I know 8gb is less but again it will more than enough for most of the people,since i do not care for music on my phone music
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
with skydrive for photos and videos and zune and spotify for music 8gb is more than enough i would say...i think people get too caught up on the 16gb/32gb thing thinking they need it and in actual fact 90% of users wont.
just my opinion
Has anyone Dev unlocked their device yet?
Sent from my SGH-T989 using xda premium
The cheapest they are on ebay are $350 and up.. that is rediculous for a mid ranged phone. i can get a sensation for cheaper so im probably going to get that. i do miss WP7 though. cant wait till nokia releases the lumia devices
it is the new nokia windows mobile phone
it looks like n9
Tell me your opinion about it
I prefer the nokia n9.
There are plenty of threads about this phone—and it even has it's own sub-forum. Search much?
john9 said:
it is the new nokia windows mobile phone
it looks like n9
Tell me your opinion about it
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No.
It's too small, the display is not flat. It has no FFC and the memory is limited to 16GB. It's also one of the thickest phones around. And it isn't aluminum.
Hands down the most beautiful and elegant wp7 device. I'm typing this from mine
Go for any of the vast array of superior android devices. That is... Unless you get aroused by scrolling through menus, then WP7 is for you.
Sent from my Samsung Infuse
MartyLK said:
No.
It's too small, the display is not flat. It has no FFC and the memory is limited to 16GB. It's also one of the thickest phones around. And it isn't aluminum.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i understand why you and some people would say about the size memory and ffc though for me i think the size is great as with my hd7 i did find my trouser pulled where is was so huge. ffc i dont think will get used anything like the amount ppl complain about it not being there. Mem is fair i would of wanted more but plus sides out weigh this.
HOWEVER not being aluminum is nothing but one of the best things to happen to this phone. Its a single moulded peice of polycarbonate so it will feel stirdier than any metal phone as well as having the advantage of 1. not showing scratches and most important 2 it does not mess up the antenna so your signal will be massivly improved. I do not get how anybody could consider this a bad thing at all but rather the best thing to ever happen to a phone.
slapshot30 said:
Go for any of the vast array of superior android devices. That is... Unless you get aroused by scrolling through menus, then WP7 is for you.
Sent from my Samsung Infuse
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
yes when you can scroll though a grid of icons, yes i see thats so much better whilst watching your battery drain away.
My opinion is this is the best looking phone since the nokia 8850. That with amazing build and one of the best screens on any device makes this a must have. Then add the extra Nokia features plus the great camera not the best no, but up there and at a price point that makes iPhone look even more stupidly overpriced make this a true winner
lumpaywk said:
yes when you can scroll though a grid of icons, yes i see thats so much better whilst watching your battery drain away.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I lol'd.......
But seriously, let's not turn this into yet another WP7 versus Android thread.
That would just be trolling......
Sent From My Fingers To Your Face.....
Its a Yes from me :-D
Sent from my Samsung Galaxy S2
I own Nokia Lumia 800 and HTC Desire HD also.
z33dev33l said:
Hands down the most beautiful and elegant wp7 device. I'm typing this from mine
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How can I get one here in the US, and how do you like it on T-Mobile? What kind of data speeds are you getting?
DoogieDC said:
How can I get one here in the US, and how do you like it on T-Mobile? What kind of data speeds are you getting?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I know it sucks esp as i am scrapping the walls already and i get mine in 2 days (one way or another) but if i lived in the USA i would advise waiting for the new year. I very strongly suspect they will bring a different version of the Lumia 800 with improved specs ie ffc and 32/64gb. I remember reading they said they will be bringing out top spec devices in usa in q1. I also suspect you will get a look in first at the 900/ace/champaign. Its a bit like htc with the hd2 you had to wait but you got the good stuff.
I just feel that unless you can afford to blow the cash for 2 months of use you will kick yourself for jumping in to early. Plus I dont think you get the full data speeds on t-mobile but that i am unsure of.
Sexiest phone with what I consider to be the best mobile OS. Yes yes yes!
Lumia 800 ROM
I just got my Lumia 800 from Telecom Germany, it has modyfied software for Telecom, start logo, special Telecom ringtones etc.
Do anyone know how to get the General Nokia software to the phone... ?
I would really like to "debrand" it.
Klaus Kjelstru
it really is beautiful. amoled looks great at first sight. (on second sight the letters dont look "clean"). its really fast. compared to the titan it seems much snappier when scrolling trough the ui.
however its so tiny.. i cant imagine to use it for long web-browsing sessions.
also.. 16gb non expandable is a joke these days. With 64GB i would have bought it instantly. Being one sexy music player could be a good selling point..
so na i guess i pass on this generation of wp..
This Phone is just gorgeous! Got it yesterday and everyone i showed i to, was impressed about the build quality and about the design, even hardcore iPhone and Apple fans.
The N9 might have more features, but it is really expensive and it was dead before even released. MeeGo is dead, so i don't care about the N9.
francois36boris said:
I prefer the nokia n9.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How can you prefer a smartphone with MeeGo?!
It's the first in the word with that OS that is already dead so it will be the only MeeGo phone ever made...
Windows Phone is far bether than Android and it's balanced with the iOS (only loses in the screen resolution and Multi-core)
Yes
Yes.. Its the best looking phone with an equally gorgeous OS
FDMFigueiredo said:
How can you prefer a smartphone with MeeGo?!
It's the first in the word with that OS that is already dead so it will be the only MeeGo phone ever made...
Windows Phone is far bether than Android and it's balanced with the iOS (only loses in the screen resolution and Multi-core)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
People just say this rubbish because its thein thing to say or like anything that results in a direct diss to Microsoft. It is a worrying trend esp when even with all there faults, and there are many, Microsoft is still the best option for most. At the end of the day it is the end users that miss out and we will all miss out big style if it continues. Even MS cant take this bad attitude towards it for ever and that will lend us to a world dominated by apple clones and/or software made in peoples bedrooms. I love android i love linux but could i live with just them all the time? Not a chance. Like it or not MS is leading the way in the tech world with everything from office 365 to windows 8 to xbox live to exchange to hyperV etc. What would the world be like without then? We geeks would be fine we have linux but what about my mum and my sister etc? what about me trying to administer our network without active directory and group policy? Everyone says MS steals technology yet we keep forgeting they are normally the first to come with it they just get beat down or mess it up but they ae there pushing forward and inovating. Windows phone is just one example along with Windows 8 of how MS is set to change the game for the better if only we let them.
Thank you my friend.
There are two major and two minor issues I have with this phone.
First is Pentile. There are two types of people - those who see it and those who don't. I do, so I was thinking about returning the phone at first. Now I'm sort of living with it, but still black text on white background looks like crap to me.
Second is no equalizer.
The two minor issues are the fact that the USB port is located on top of the device and that it has a lid. This is less annoying than Pentile but still very awkward.
Otherwise it's a great phone.
Hey guys,
I just wanted to get your opinion on which phone I should use. I ordered the Lumia 920 off eBay recently and I heard really good reviews on it. I was planning on giving it to my sister but now I'm kind of convinced to use the Lumia. I love my one x+ but what do you think? Comments and opinions are much appreciated!!!
Sent from my HTC One X+ using Tapatalk 2
Dfballa said:
Hey guys,
I just wanted to get your opinion on which phone I should use. I ordered the Lumia 920 off eBay recently and I heard really good reviews on it. I was planning on giving it to my sister but now I'm kind of convinced to use the Lumia. I love my one x+ but what do you think? Comments and opinions are much appreciated!!!
Sent from my HTC One X+ using Tapatalk 2
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
While I'm sure the Lumia is a very solid phone in terms of hardware, and Windows Phone 8 certainly looks sleek, I feel like the app ecosystem for Windows Phone 8 just isn't mature enough yet. Look at how long it took the Android Market (Play Store, whatever) to get where it is now. If you don't use a whole lot of 3rd party apps and like to rely on whatever's already on the device, then maybe the Lumia 920 is the device for you, but I prefer having the vast selection that Android offers. Past that it all comes down to personal preference; the two operating systems are quite different in terms of design, and I'm sure everyone's got their opinion. Also, I've heard the Lumia 920 is a bit of a hulking beast (quite heavy), so it will be quite a change from the HOX+ which is comparatively light.
Well the only major difference would be the availability of apps. I only ever really use major apps like Twitter, facebook etc. I don't really use any 3rd party apps but I do have some. I really like the Lumias design and look. It just looks like a well made phone. And the weight? Doesnt really affect me much
Sent from my HTC One X+ using Tapatalk 2
Well, it seems to me that you have already made up your mind but you would just like people to validate your choice.
If you like your phone tank-like with a good performing OS that has what you need already, then by all means.
Of course, I personally am too invested in the Google ecosystem to consider using anything else, because the level of integration that Android offers is astounding. I also love the Android OS more than the Windows one, but if you are a part of Microsoft's ecosystem (with Xbox and Outlook and the like), then the 920 is a good bet for you. I wouldn't know where to begin to shift over my cards to a new OS, but syncing everything to my Google account between Android devices is a cinch and pretty brilliant.
The Android system also has such incredible hackability and tweakability (this enormous forum community is a testament to this) compared to where WP8 is standing right now.
The One X+ is a very sleek device itself. Decide what is really important to you in a phone, and good luck with your decision.
I agree that WP8 is much less developed than android and Google in terms of users + tweaks. What I dont like about WP8 is that it doesnt have as much dev support as android.
I'm going to test the Lumia 920 out for a couple days and see which one I like better.
Sent from my HTC One X+ using Tapatalk 2
hi
iam rly confused between those 2 phones
any1 tried them both? tell me ur opinion plz
thanks
I have both. I decided to get the Note 8.0 and stick with the 920 as my daily driver. There are things I love about both wp8 and the samsung note series. This allows me to have both.
If I had to choose, I would still likely choose the 920. Overall it is just a better device IMO. Of course, if apps a a serious requirement for you, android obviously still has more selections. I just find windows phone has the best UI. There was a exclusive Halo app announced today for Windows Phone 8 and RT though.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using xda premium
in my opinion i choise Note 2 . Reason is Android.
naplesbill said:
I have both. I decided to get the Note 8.0 and stick with the 920 as my daily driver. There are things I love about both wp8 and the samsung note series. This allows me to have both.
If I had to choose, I would still likely choose the 920. Overall it is just a better device IMO. Of course, if apps a a serious requirement for you, android obviously still has more selections. I just find windows phone has the best UI. There was a exclusive Halo app announced today for Windows Phone 8 and RT though.
Sent from my GT-N5110 using xda premium
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks for ur answer
can u tell me more about why u say lumia 920 better? is its screen big enough or small?as i will use it for reading e-books and surfingh the internet..is the fnt readable? and writing alot...iam not intensive gamer so it doesnt matter...........thanks in advance
The screen on the Lumia is large enough for me. The Note II screen is obviously larger but I believe the PPI is higher on the Lumia. The Lumia is the best in direct sunlight for sure, if that is a consideration.
I think if reading is your biggest concern, the note II is larger but the Lumia is sharper. Also, obviously the Lumia is more pocket friendly.
There are so many considerations that it is impossible to recommend either 100%. I have no bias toward either Android or WP8. To me, pick the best tool for the job.
Sent from my Lumia 920 using XDA Windows Phone 7 App
I'm not sure I would like to read eBooks on either one of them - I think both screens are too small for that use case but that of course is just my personal opinion. For surfing the internet and reading articles I never had any issues with the screen size of my 920. I prefer the 920 over my Ativ S (basically an SGS3 with WP8) for reading because the PenTile display in the Ativ S makes white backgrounds look grainier/dirtier than the RGB LCD in the 920. Of course the Note 2 has an RGB AMOLED so this might not be an issue there (never did a side by side comparison).
Battery life seems to be better on the Note 2 though - at least in standby.
What are your other requirements? Would you use the stylus on the note for drawings or writing notes? Are you into photography so that the superior camera in the 920 would be of benefit to you? Nokia has true offline navigation capability if you are traveling a lot abroad but Google Maps on the Note II has a better POI database according to many.
While i only have tried Galaxy s3, note 2, and various other "modern" android Devices only for a short time, i prefer the lumia 920.
Androids play store is a bit bigger, but that is no real problem, as wp is coming along nicely.
In daily use, you will notice that android is really lagging, and also that apps is crashing.
This is not something I have experienced with my Lumia 920.
Furthermore, Nokia provides here maps and here drive+.
These programs gives you offline maps and turn by turn navigation for most of the world.
Another advantage with wp8 is skydrive.
The phone uploads all my pictures and videos to skydrive, and on my computer and tablets, which all is running windows 8 and windows rt,
The pictures appear instantly.
marcocea said:
in my opinion i choise Note 2 . Reason is Android.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i choose Lumia 920... reason is Android
I have both as well.
Note2: +: Big screen, sd card, removable battery, tons of software in android, highly customizable interface, rootable and customs roms
-: a bit unwieldy, tough to see in sunlight, looks kind of cheap, no camera button
Lumia 920: +: Premium feel and design, smaller screen if you want that, don't need to mess around with settings much, simpler interface, better camera
-: Limited software, heavy for some, no sd card, no removable battery, camera button, all buttons on right
Do you want it as primarily a phone or as a phablet is the question.
I'm finding the limitations of wp8 becoming increasingly annoying. You may want to consider the galaxy s4 and the htc one which are closer in size to the 920.
rc
You may want to consider the htc
dxdy said:
i choose Lumia 920... reason is Android
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nice one. I agree.
ottoen said:
Nice one. I agree.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I bought my wife the HTC One (M7) and I don't regret it being her 1st Android device...it runs flawless and the display is the best I've ever seen on any device and her being in the medical profession Android's apps in her field made sense. As for me, I don't play games and I am a full-time college student and Windows Phone does exactly what I need it to do and despite it's limitations there isn't a 3rd party or Homebrew app that did a lesser job than the branded apps. We have T-Mobile where our kids live and barely an AT&T signal and where we live right out no T-Mobile whatsoever and Straight Talk (AT&T) HSPA+ in a place I thought we'd never get it, so VoIP is important which is my one pet peeve with WP. Skype gets it done but it just pisses me off that the brain trust at Microsoft failed and betrayed those who grew up with Windows Mobile through the WP7.x upgrade and left us in the cold with only a Start Menu and dead development today. It's easier said than done to buy a new smart phone every year.
Over the last years, I usually have bought 3-4 smartphones each year, one iPhone back in 2009, and after that, several android phones.
My first android phone was the htc desire, a phone with 150 Mb internal memory.
I regret ever buying it. I also had a lg optimus 3d, a phone with several nice features, but it still had that poor operating system called android.
So, eventually I got the Lumia 900, a wp 7-phone. I really got to enjoy wp, so now I have the Lumia 920. This phone is simply the best phone I ever had. I am now waiting for the rumoured Nokia eos.
I am convinced that it will be worth the waiting.
But for now, I am convinced that my 920 will suffice,
And I will without hesitation recommend this phone to anybody who is asking.
ottoen said:
Over the last years, I usually have bought 3-4 smartphones each year, one iPhone back in 2009, and after that, several android phones.
My first android phone was the htc desire, a phone with 150 Mb internal memory.
I regret ever buying it. I also had a lg optimus 3d, a phone with several nice features, but it still had that poor operating system called android.
So, eventually I got the Lumia 900, a wp 7-phone. I really got to enjoy wp, so now I have the Lumia 920. This phone is simply the best phone I ever had. I am now waiting for the rumoured Nokia eos.
I am convinced that it will be worth the waiting.
But for now, I am convinced that my 920 will suffice,
And I will without hesitation recommend this phone to anybody who is asking.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I will suggest Lumia 920, and if display size is not a concern go for iphone it has apps and performance.
Don't go for Android, i have S4 even it lags a lot of times and Random reboots comes free with Android, but i never had any lag in my lumia 920 or iphone 5
WP8 is far better then Android
I've owned a Galaxy SI, SII and SIII (which I still use). I picked up a 920 for testing apps my company is developing on W8, and although initially I enjoyed the 920, it now spends most of its time in my computer bag, while I'm back to using the S3. Why? Severely limited apps, especially in the tools/utilities area, infuriating restrictions on music player apps and supporting utilities, no call blocking apps, etc.
I like to tinker- this phone is not for my kind of consumer. It's great for those who have no desire to customize- smooth as butter and easy to use interface, great camera, competent music player, excellent battery life. But I want more than that- I want, for example, an app with a 4-band parametric EQ, a themed, customized UI, ROM control and a custom kernel to overclock/undervolt/manage memory, wifi tethering, etc...
I have both. Would never replace Note 2 with any phone. I like huge display. Note 2 offers me better readability, easier documents handling, editing and sending. I like the fact that I can customise keyboard (using SwiftKey), widgets, fast access to applications.
Lumia 920 has great navigation. Great camera.
Sent from my GT-N7100 using Tapatalk 2
Note2 is good but android is still buggy
Sent from my RM-821_im_india_443 using Board Express
I have both and chose the 920 for two reasons: email on WP much nicer and I am now bored with flashing custom roms and tweaking launchers, too much time wasted. Android has a way of sucking you into endless process of perfecting your phone (so much so you forget why you need a phone in the first place!)
Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk HD
tangiers said:
I have both and chose the 920 for two reasons: email on WP much nicer and I am now bored with flashing custom roms and tweaking launchers, too much time wasted. Android has a way of sucking you into endless process of perfecting your phone (so much so you forget why you need a phone in the first place!)
Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk HD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I very much agree with you, if you have a lot of spare time or if you just want to kill time and if your phone is everything for you then go for Android, if you want a smartphone that works as a smartphone out of the box go for WP8 or iOS
abokorayem said:
hi
iam rly confused between those 2 phones
any1 tried them both? tell me ur opinion plz
thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
GO for Lumia 920. I recently switched form Galaxy note 2 and i am really enjoying it. All the necessary applications are available in WP8 and most importantly i am impressed with the smoothness and lag free interface of wp8. The lumia 920 is handy and you can use it one hand only , while with note 2 you have to use both hands.
If you ask me , go for lumia 920 !
---------- Post added at 11:00 AM ---------- Previous post was at 10:20 AM ----------
tangiers said:
I have both and chose the 920 for two reasons: email on WP much nicer and I am now bored with flashing custom roms and tweaking launchers, too much time wasted. Android has a way of sucking you into endless process of perfecting your phone (so much so you forget why you need a phone in the first place!)
Sent from my Nexus 10 using Tapatalk HD
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly true. thats the reason i switched from note 2 to lumia 920
Why not have both. I use lumia 920 for day to day activities n note2 for the browsing fun games etc...
Jotted from Note II near you.
Simple question really. I was torn between the note 3 and the one max. I am still debating whether to switch from the max to the note.
I picked the Max because:
1. I am tired of touchwiz
2. I like the extra size, screen, speakers, and build quality.
3. I like HTC
4. I had the note2 and never used the stylus and found most of the added features gimmicks. I never used multi window features. I had it for the screen size.
Why am I questioning the purchase of the Max?
1. Why pay the same price for the Max when I could get the note3 and get all the added features, even if I don't use them, I would at least have the option. ( This really is the biggest reason. I never used the stylus on the note2, but all the new options make me wonder if I would find it more useful.)
2. Camera
3. The reviews online...and I have literally read and watched countless reviews before making the decision.
I don't know if HTC had plans to make added features for future updates, but off this phone becomes a bust, I am worried there won't be much,if any support for it
Sent from my HTC6600LVW using Tapatalk
I agree with all your positive points above. I would also add that I prefer LCD screens to amoled any day of the week. Amoled is too vivid for me. I prefer sharpness and true color. Also IMO the camera is not a negative. It may not have all the megapixels of others and unfortunately no optical image stabilization but for use indoors it is great. I can actually take a picture using the regular settings and not have the pictures come out dark. That is a benefit of the ultrapixel.
In a nutshell all the reviews have to say is how the Max uses the One chipset. They think just because it's not the newest it's not worthwhile. What's strange is these same people didn't blast the Moto X for coming out with such a crappy old chipset...
I will close out with saying now that I have used the stereo forward facing speakers of the Max I cannot stand using a single rear facing speaker phone. Why use android which is built for media consumption (all are 16:9 screens vice 4:3) if you can't hear what you are watching?!?
Jiggity Janx said:
I agree with all your positive points above. I would also add that I prefer LCD screens to amoled any day of the week. Amoled is too vivid for me. I prefer sharpness and true color. Also IMO the camera is not a negative. It may not have all the megapixels of others and unfortunately no optical image stabilization but for use indoors it is great. I can actually take a picture using the regular settings and not have the pictures come out dark. That is a benefit of the ultrapixel.
In a nutshell all the reviews have to say is how the Max uses the One chipset. They think just because it's not the newest it's not worthwhile. What's strange is these same people didn't blast the Moto X for coming out with such a crappy old chipset...
I will close out with saying now that I have used the stereo forward facing speakers of the Max I cannot stand using a single rear facing speaker phone. Why use android which is built for media consumption (all are 16:9 screens vice 4:3) if you can't hear what you are watching?!?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I also Agree with both of you. I choose the Max and specifically waited for it due to the screen size, the Speed(I am not worried about it not being a Snapdragon 800), the Designed and Front Speakers. Having a Fingerprint reader, NFC are great but the MicroSD card in combination of everything else made it my next device. I got it on Verizon EDGE so if something comes along in the next 6 months I have to have I can upgrade again.
Win Win.
I forgot about the sd card. Nice call. It's awesome having that extra space. And HTC did it perfectly by having a back cover that you can remove to get to the card and NOT have to hold the battery in while you do it. (I'm looking at you samsung!)
Since you asked ill be realy honest Ive had almost every phone you can think of and haven't had an HTC phone as my oficial driver since the evo 3d (had the HTC one I'll get in to details in a moment)and since the 3d I hated htc the one sucked completely don't now why they made it so bad had 3 in a month camera broke out of magic,but the one max is the solution. The note 2 was the best thing that have ever happened until now yes the HTC one max as of now is my favorite,now that I have soff it's designe,solid,battery life, screen, sound and camera(not the best but not as horrible as others say) the finger scanner works perfectly (don't now why people just don't know how to use it) I love this phone it haves everything I've always wanted
Ive been battling between these two phones and I hate to say it - but I'm almost positive I'm going with the Note 3.
I've been an HTC fan having owned the original evo for two years and now the ElteVO since launch day.
I was leaning toward the Max as I have been happy with HTC and I thought I preferred LCD to amoled, but I recently got to play with both phones at a sprint store and I was disappointed with the brightness on the Max. Plus I found it kind of boring after owning nothing but HTC for 4 years.
I'm also very disappointed with the support and development for the Max. I love rooting and trying different roms. The evo ElteVO support wasn't even strong enough to satisfy my flashing disease and that phone had alot stronger following than the Max appears to.
My biggest fears going with the note 3 are screen burn as I run full brightness and use my phone alot for work and also the GPS as in the past Samsung GPS haven't been known to be as strong as HTC.
Jack
Sent from my Sense 5 Y4 ElteVO.
Overall, I'm pretty happy with the decision to get this phone. I really wanted the HTC One, just bigger. This phone was just what I was looking for.
The feeling that I should have gotten something with all the features still bugs me, but I am pretty sure that I will be keeping the phone.
I am actually happy with the camera, but still worried there won't be many updates for this phone from HTC if it doesn't end up selling well
Sent from my HTC6600LVW using Tapatalk
spydersilk said:
Overall, I'm pretty happy with the decision to get this phone. I really wanted the HTC One, just bigger. This phone was just what I was looking for.
The feeling that I should have gotten something with all the features still bugs me, but I am pretty sure that I will be keeping the phone.
I am actually happy with the camera, but still worried there won't be many updates for this phone from HTC if it doesn't end up selling well
Sent from my HTC6600LVW using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Updates are coming even sense 6
Sent from my HTC Butterfly s using xda premium
Has anyone ever returned a phone? I want to keep the Max, but I just saw Verizon dropped the price to 199.99. I am within my 14 days and wasn't sure if they will reimburse me so I can keep it, or how that works
Sent from my HTC6600LVW using Tapatalk
Great phone the note 3 is a good phone by all means but who the hell is going to use all those gestures and features BoomSound big screen and expanded memory pull me all the way in. As stated above fingerprint works perfectly just have to know how u use it right great battery life build quality amazing HTC one max is killing the note in my eyes
Sent from my HTC0P3P7 using xda app-developers app
spydersilk said:
Has anyone ever returned a phone? I want to keep the Max, but I just saw Verizon dropped the price to 199.99. I am within my 14 days and wasn't sure if they will reimburse me so I can keep it, or how that works
Sent from my HTC6600LVW using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
They will reimburse you the difference. Make sure u go back and get your $100 back.
Sent from my SCH-I605 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I used to have a few htc phones, but the evo 3d was the last one for me.
I have had 4 Samsung phones in a row, and initially I thought they were the only way to go, but, the plastic builds, the advent of Knox Security, and the fact I never used my S-pen, it was time for a change..
This phone is fantastic for what I do with it; sound blows away any other phone, screen is as clear and crisp as anything every made, and I like the aluminum housing too!
Oh, 32 gigs INTERNAL storage, when coupled with a 64 gig card is great too! Its nice to web surf and not have to stretch everything so you can see it!
No idea why so many reviewers panned this phone; fingerprint scanner works perfectly, and who care about a snapdragon 800.
There is no lag or slow down on this phone, so hopefully more folks will ignore what the stupid reviewers say, because once you try this phone, you will buy it.
I want to say that I agree with all of the positives posted here. I almost bought the note as this was not out the night i was researching and Verizon did not really tell anyone when it was coming. The next day when clicking upgrade it was there in my face. I read reviews and everyone was bashing it because the size was bigger but nothing else really changed. Then the complained about them getting rid of the unibody but then praised it for adding the sd card slot. Thats when I lost all faith in phone reviewers. They must all be secret iDevice lovers. I want to say I love this phone over my S4. It is a bit heavy when talking on it but I really do not use the phone feature much.
get yourself a decent BT headset, and you can leave the phone in your pocket!
plus, if you get the right headset. you can just push the talk button on your headset, and google will come up and ask you who you want to call, and its been 100% accurate for me so far.
Time will tell man. I have note 3 & just got a HTC one max ordered today. Will get next week. Can't wait to try it out
Sent from my N900V Dev Edition
you'll love it, unless you are really attached to the spen on the note...
wase4711 said:
you'll love it, unless you are really attached to the spen on the note...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I mean I dont use everyday. its nice to have occasionally but i think i can live without and i love sense and i love my htc one just wish it was bigger! and i get an sdcard so im happy about that even if it doesnt have the snapdragon 800 at least i have a fingerprint scanner hahaha
you wont notice any lag what so ever, it would have been nice to have the 800, but all that matters is actual performance, NOT specs..
plus, you can take notes with the scribble app, so if you want to, you still can
wase4711 said:
you wont notice any lag what so ever, it would have been nice to have the 800, but all that matters is actual performance, NOT specs..
plus, you can take notes with the scribble app, so if you want to, you still can
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah no pen though built in which is really nice and yeah I had zero lag on my HTC one and if the one max performs that well with a bigger screen and sdcard I'll be one happy camper!
Sent from my N900V Dev Edition
I bought 2 ones for my wife and son, and they both came from note 2's and love the htc one..neither of them used the pen much either, and they both say the one seems even faster than the note 2.
Yeah, the max is just a gigantic one, with larger screen, larger speakers, larger everything! Of course the reviewers don't like that; they think it needs some special phablet features, and that no one will just want a gigantic htc one.
I for one wanted a bigger htc one specifically, so for me, its been fantastic!
hit up Amazon for cases and SP's; Sprint wants an arm and a leg for that stuff, and for what I would have paid for one case at sprint, I got 3 cases, and 8 screen protectors!
Amazon has quite a bit of stuff for the Max already; I am still trying to find a desktop dock for it, and then I will be a happy camper!