I am going to ask you to do a test and see what kind of results you're getting.
The issue is that the HTC One is receiving a MMS picture at a much lower resolution then what is being sent. I have been on the phone with T-Mobile and HTC all day yesterday and today and the answer that I got from HTC basically was either deal with getting a compressed picture on this phone or get a different phone.
It is not a T-Mobile issue because I can send the same picture to my wifes phone (Nexus 4) or anyone elses phone and they are getting the same resolution as what is sent out.
The test I'm going to ask you is to simply send a picture message to yourself and take note of the out coming size and the incoming size when viewed in your text app.
For example, in my stock messaging app:
I sent out a picture at size of 783kb @ a resolution of 1520x2688
I recieved the picture back at a size of 166kb @ 434x767.
This was a picture taken vertical and a horizontal one will having varying numbers.
The point is to see whether the HTC one is receiving back a much smaller and compressed picture. Keep in mind, other phones are getting the same size resolution than what is being sent out. I'd appreciate any input so I can hopefully get someone with HTC involved in fixing the issue.
Or if my phone is the only doing that, it would be good to know as well...
No test needed. The One compresses pictures when sent over MMS. If you want to send uncompressed you will need to use a 3rd party messaging app.
Well i sent myself an 800kb picture and received a 290kb so I guess yea it's reduced . I think using facebook messenger or Kik whatsapp won't compress your pics so much so yea .
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
blackangst said:
No test needed. The One compresses pictures when sent over MMS. If you want to send uncompressed you will need to use a 3rd party messaging app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
Handcent, Chomp SMS, and Go SMS all provide similar results. The point is, it shouldn't be compressing the resolution like it is and that is something HTC will have to fix. I realize it compresses them when sending them. All phones do that.
It should not be compressing them again when it receives the same picture just for fun when no other phone does that.
Edit: The picture size and resolution that I posted in the original post are the stats of the compressed picture that the sms program sent, not the original size as viewed in the gallery.
urmystlkal said:
Sent from my HTC One using xda app-developers app
Handcent, Chomp SMS, and Go SMS all provide similar results. The point is, it shouldn't be compressing the resolution like it is and that is something HTC will have to fix. I realize it compresses them when sending them. All phones do that.
It should not be compressing them again when it receives the same picture just for fun when no other phone does that.
Edit: The picture size and resolution that I posted in the original post are the stats of the compressed picture that the sms program sent, not the original size as viewed in the gallery.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Maximum message size is listed at 1 Mb, could this be the problem?
stevedebi said:
Maximum message size is listed at 1 Mb, could this be the problem?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
no
I don't know what to do about this. I've had the problem since day one.
urmystlkal said:
I am going to ask you to do a test and see what kind of results you're getting.
The issue is that the HTC One is receiving a MMS picture at a much lower resolution then what is being sent. I have been on the phone with T-Mobile and HTC all day yesterday and today and the answer that I got from HTC basically was either deal with getting a compressed picture on this phone or get a different phone.
It is not a T-Mobile issue because I can send the same picture to my wifes phone (Nexus 4) or anyone elses phone and they are getting the same resolution as what is sent out.
The test I'm going to ask you is to simply send a picture message to yourself and take note of the out coming size and the incoming size when viewed in your text app.
For example, in my stock messaging app:
I sent out a picture at size of 783kb @ a resolution of 1520x2688
I recieved the picture back at a size of 166kb @ 434x767.
This was a picture taken vertical and a horizontal one will having varying numbers.
The point is to see whether the HTC one is receiving back a much smaller and compressed picture. Keep in mind, other phones are getting the same size resolution than what is being sent out. I'd appreciate any input so I can hopefully get someone with HTC involved in fixing the issue.
Or if my phone is the only doing that, it would be good to know as well...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I send a picture to me with 259KB resolution 1909 x 1080 and receive a 413KB resolution 1023 x 579
Related
I've seen a few people ask about how to increase the MMS file size limit so I figured I'd post up this easy way to do it.
Download GoSMS from the market if you don't already have it installed
(I've attached Screenshots for you to follow along)
Go to Settings, click the "Advanced" tab, scroll down and click "MMS settings"
Click on "Maximum MMS size"
Set to desired file size limit.
Then press back button
Check the box to "Preserve image resolution"
And BAM, your done. Easy Peasy.
Even though I have no 4g here in Phoenix AZ, I usually have it set to 2M. It usually takes a little longer to send on 3G but I can confirm that it does in fact send.
MoPhoACTV Initiative
Yeah check with the person who receives it how big of a file he gets if ever gonna get that massage unlikely so. What you send is not what you get even when send to yourself try it.
Sent from my MB855
dito33 said:
Yeah check with the person who receives it how big of a file he gets if ever gonna get that massage unlikely so. What you send is not what you get even when send to yourself try it.
Sent from my MB855
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have, and when I click on the image I sent myself or my girlfriends phone, it is not grainy and the pictures are nice and big, not almost thumbnail like.
MoPhoACTV Initiative
My point is if you click on details info size would not be the same as they were sent
Sent from my MB855
This is good, but trust me. A few years back, people were walking around the office taking video and sending inter-office e-mail. One I liked and tried to send via MMS to family. No good. I then took like 10 second video to send, same thing, no good as it was too big.
Take 15 hour video and attach to e-mail! Then send to:
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected]
(whatever, you get my point!) but it does the same thing! The only thing bad with Sprint is, you do not have use of your phone while transmitting! My "15 hour video" comment was a joke (and you would be stupid to try it) I did like 2 minutes of HD and it tied up my phone for like 10 minutes or so? WiFi would likely be better?
Well that's a good point but when comes to sending an email attachment just use regular email and every smart phone is tight to email account anyway and accomplish is the same, the struggle is how to send mms and either the phone or provider on either site compresses the attachment.
Sent from my MB855
Oh, and one last thing to remember, people that are on data plans! (My mother and my AT&T peoples with iPhones!)
Hey Guys.
I've been looking at how to do this for ages but...GoSMS is all well and good but, I like the stock SMS app...Its a little more...lets say, less "permisiony"...
But how can one do this change with the stick SMS app?? Is there an XML file you can edit?
Thanks.
Did you ever get any resolution to this? I'm on a Samsung Galaxy S4 Google edition and definitely want to stick to the stock messaging app, but outgoing photos attached via SMS from the camera are compressed to garbage. They're tiny and horrifically artifacted... it's killing me.
-Shane
Lambetts said:
Hey Guys.
I've been looking at how to do this for ages but...GoSMS is all well and good but, I like the stock SMS app...Its a little more...lets say, less "permisiony"...
But how can one do this change with the stick SMS app?? Is there an XML file you can edit?
Thanks.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
shanesaccount said:
Did you ever get any resolution to this? I'm on a Samsung Galaxy S4 Google edition and definitely want to stick to the stock messaging app, but outgoing photos attached via SMS from the camera are compressed to garbage. They're tiny and horrifically artifacted... it's killing me.
-Shane
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No fix for this then? i just sent a text on my one plus and its 90kb, danggg
I just tried this on my VZW S4 and it seems to work for sure at 2mb. HOWEVER, when attaching pix it does not give any means to pick "gallery" so that I can pick images to attach from their files, instead, taking you straight to what appears identical to the factory installed "picture" app where all images are shotgunned onto a single HUGE page. Can this be fixed?
Other than that, I love the app as it does give a better detailed report with each post time and DATE stamped as well as a little green check to indicated received. The stock messaging doesn't do that and also will not allow you to request a read receipt without getting the same audible notice that you get when receiving a message.
Is this customizable or is this an MMS standard. Every time I send a picture I've taken by MMS to my wife's iphone it's tiny. I'll take a cute picture of my daughter and my wife wants me to send it to her. The phone dumbs it down to some thumbnail size and she ends up with a low res pic. Seems like the pictures she texts me from her iPhone look better.
Video quality is also atrocious. I watched a short video on her phone that I texted her and it was unwatchable. I'm not expecting HD quality but surely it could get better than 160x120 or whatever that pitiful resolution is.
blackwaterstout said:
Is this customizable or is this an MMS standard. Every time I send a picture I've taken by MMS to my wife's iphone it's tiny. I'll take a cute picture of my daughter and my wife wants me to send it to her. The phone dumbs it down to some thumbnail size and she ends up with a low res pic. Seems like the pictures she texts me from her iPhone look better.
Video quality is also atrocious. I watched a short video on her phone that I texted her and it was unwatchable. I'm not expecting HD quality but surely it could get better than 160x120 or whatever that pitiful resolution is.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
MMS images get compressed by default on stock (bugged me too), but developers have overcome this in custom ROMs. I can confirm that Viper4G doesn't do this.
MeanROM increases the limit from 1Mb to 5Mb for MMS as well.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
CBRRider said:
MeanROM increases the limit from 1Mb to 5Mb for MMS as well.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
so does all the other roms
Thanks. I was hoping there was an adjustable setting somewhere I hadn't found. Really not interested in rooting my phone at this point.
The stock HTC mms app is shrinks the photo res for some reason.
Use a 3rd party program to send mms. I use Handcent SMS. Mms works better.
This bothers me as well it's just annoying. Like op said doesn't need to be HD quality but a thumbnail is just ridiculous. Anyway to adjust on stock rom without using 3rd party app?
Sim-X said:
This bothers me as well it's just annoying. Like op said doesn't need to be HD quality but a thumbnail is just ridiculous. Anyway to adjust on stock rom without using 3rd party app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I don't believe so...I looked everywhere prior to rooting and couldn't find anything.
Sent from my EVO LTE
I use go sms for sending and receiving mms.
Sent from my EVO LTE
It wouldn't be as bad if it actually adhered to the 1MB size, but it squashes it down to about 15-50kb instead. Setting it to 5MB I now get a notification that the recipient may not receive it due to the file size. This usually only happens when sending MMS to a carrier other than Sprint.
BTSchnarfy said:
It wouldn't be as bad if it actually adhered to the 1MB size, but it squashes it down to about 15-50kb instead. Setting it to 5MB I now get a notification that the recipient may not receive it due to the file size. This usually only happens when sending MMS to a carrier other than Sprint.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah, that's a good point...no point in sending an hq image if they can't receive it.
Sent from my EVO LTE
Another option is using Dropbox. You can either have Dropbox upload all of your photos/videos automatically or you can manually upload one photo at time. Then simply send a link from your Dropbox and you get Zero compression! Works great with videos too. :good:
You can always just email them if you don't want to root or use a separate app for texting pictures. That's what I use to do before I rooted my phone.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
So I always thought other peoples phones just sent a picture at a smaller resolution but last night my buddy and I recieved the same picture at the same time from someone and his was at a much higher resolution. He was using the stock SMS program and I was using Handcent. I uninstalled Handcent and had the person resend the picture so I would get it via the stock program and the picture came at a higher resolution, but not as great as the other persons. I was using my T-Mobile HTC One and he was using a Verizon HTC One X.
I was thinking it was maybe a T-Mobile thing limiting the MMS size, but today I sent a picture to both my wife and myself to compare. Hers is the Nexus 4 and I have the HTC One.
The original size of the picture being sent (after being compressed by the texting app is 235KB and 1909x1080.
My wife received that picture at 235KB @ 1909x1080 and I received the picture at 405KB 1023x579.
Does anyone have an explanation for why it's coming in like that and a fix for it? This was on the stock texting program on the phones.
Also FWIW, when Handcent is installed and I send from the stock app to myself and Handcent recieves the picture, it comes in at 188KB @ 639x362. I'm no longer a Handcent user. None of the other SMS apps did this.
urmystlkal said:
So I always thought other peoples phones just sent a picture at a smaller resolution but last night my buddy and I recieved the same picture at the same time from someone and his was at a much higher resolution. He was using the stock SMS program and I was using Handcent. I uninstalled Handcent and had the person resend the picture so I would get it via the stock program and the picture came at a higher resolution, but not as great as the other persons. I was using my T-Mobile HTC One and he was using a Verizon HTC One X.
I was thinking it was maybe a T-Mobile thing limiting the MMS size, but today I sent a picture to both my wife and myself to compare. Hers is the Nexus 4 and I have the HTC One.
The original size of the picture being sent (after being compressed by the texting app is 235KB and 1909x1080.
My wife received that picture at 235KB @ 1909x1080 and I received the picture at 405KB 1023x579.
Does anyone have an explanation for why it's coming in like that and a fix for it? This was on the stock texting program on the phones.
Also FWIW, when Handcent is installed and I send from the stock app to myself and Handcent recieves the picture, it comes in at 188KB @ 639x362. I'm no longer a Handcent user. None of the other SMS apps did this.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I can only think of it being a setting that is limiting the size of the file. Maybe try another SMS app and see if you can change the size of the file you get. Most of the time there is settings that let you limit sizes for data reasons.
Prod1702 said:
I can only think of it being a setting that is limiting the size of the file. Maybe try another SMS app and see if you can change the size of the file you get. Most of the time there is settings that let you limit sizes for data reasons.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've tried stock, handcent, go sms, and chomp sms and had similiar results. I see you have the Nexus 4 and HTC One as well. Is it possible to test yourself and see if you get the same results?
urmystlkal said:
I've tried stock, handcent, go sms, and chomp sms and had similiar results. I see you have the Nexus 4 and HTC One as well. Is it possible to test yourself and see if you get the same results?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am waiting for HTC to ship me my phone. I did a trade in program with T-Mo as a Rep i was able to trade in my N4 for a full repalcement with a HTC One should be here later this week. If you are unlocked and have a custom recovery maybe try a nanodroid and install a different rom and see how that is. You can always go back with the backup. I don't really use MMS.
Prod1702 said:
I am waiting for HTC to ship me my phone. I did a trade in program with T-Mo as a Rep i was able to trade in my N4 for a full repalcement with a HTC One should be here later this week. If you are unlocked and have a custom recovery maybe try a nanodroid and install a different rom and see how that is. You can always go back with the backup. I don't really use MMS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh okay, nice! I haven't rooted yet so I'm still on the stock rom. Wonder what the deal is
HTC is letting current t-mo RSA's as well as sprint, and at&t to trade in there high end phone for free HTC one. It is only for RSA's.
Sent from my Nexus 4 using Tapatalk 2
Maybe this. Happened to me on my One X when getting pics from an iPhone 4.
http://forums.androidcentral.com/htc-one-x/203150-mms-messages-very-small.html
I called HTC yesterday about it. The guy was able to duplicate and said he play with it and see what he came up w/ and should call me back today. There's no reason that this phone should be getting a picture at 435x767 resolution when other phones are getting it at 1088x1920. That's unacceptable.
SmiLey497 said:
Maybe this. Happened to me on my One X when getting pics from an iPhone 4.
http://forums.androidcentral.com/htc-one-x/203150-mms-messages-very-small.html
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey I'm trying to install the apk and it asks if I would like to replace the system app, I say okay and hit install, then it says app not installed, an existing package by the same name with a conflicting signature is already installed.
So then with a file manager with root access, i tried copy and pasting the MMS.apk into the system/app folder and it will not paste. Any advice?
urmystlkal said:
Hey I'm trying to install the apk and it asks if I would like to replace the system app, I say okay and hit install, then it says app not installed, an existing package by the same name with a conflicting signature is already installed.
So then with a file manager with root access, i tried copy and pasting the MMS.apk into the system/app folder and it will not paste. Any advice?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock /system is not r/w you need to flash a kernel that allows r/w to system. I wouldn't recommend trying to replace the stock messaging app with MMS.apk, might cause undesired results.
Possible to extract default.xml from SYSTEM/CUSTOMIZE/MNS and upload so I can take a look at it?
HTC One
PM'd it to you.
So it seems on a vertical picture,the One will receive is 434x767 resolution and on a horizontal picture it's 1023x579. Keep in mind the compressed picture that the messaging app sent out was 1520x2688 and 2688x1520 respectably. I've seen these numbers multiple times.
It boggles my mind how this is their high end phone and other phones are able to recieve the high resolution pictures via text and this one can not and HTC's answer to me was "basically going to have to deal with it or get another phone". That was an unacceptable answer for me.
My 2688x1520 gets recieved at 1909x1080 and I received a verticle one at it's original size. Only thing I noticed was that the verticle image size was under 1mb originally, therefor requiring no compression. T-mobile sets it's mms limit a 1000k so Im assuming size recieved depends on amount of compression required.
HTC One
fmedrano1977 said:
My 2688x1520 gets recieved at 1909x1080 and I received a verticle one at it's original size. Only thing I noticed was that the verticle image size was under 1mb originally, therefor requiring no compression. T-mobile sets it's mms limit a 1000k so Im assuming size recieved depends on amount of compression required.
HTC One
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm glad to hear that, at least it shows it's possible. I can't get anywhere close to that obviously. All the pictures are under 1000k, I'm not sure what the problem is. Was this with the stock messaging app or a different one?
urmystlkal said:
I'm glad to hear that, at least it shows it's possible. I can't get anywhere close to that obviously. All the pictures are under 1000k, I'm not sure what the problem is. Was this with the stock messaging app or a different one?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Stock, by the way I'm running the ARHD 7.1 ROM using a default.XML file inside SYSTEM\CUSTOMIZE\MNS from Energy's T-Mobile One S ROM.
Sent from my Nexus 7
I've had the same problem day one with this phone. I don't get it. Pictures come in way smaller than they should it's so annoying. This is is especially true when receiving screenshots. I'll attach some examples.
Sent from my HTC One using xda premium
Aaand this is why I use gmail. I've had several phones with that problem
Sent from my HTC One using xda premium
I would like to know how to send a full sized MMS on sprint's network. Even if I install a rom that can send up to 5M, I notice the receiver always gets something along the lines of 200kb. I have tried both GoSMS and Handcent to send pictures, and neither work even when put at full size in options. So far the only way I've acheived this is to use Handcent's personal network, upload the picture there, then send someone the link to which they download from. Now this is rather inconvenient, as some of my friends don't have smartphones yet, so it's hard for them to view the file. I''d also prefer to not email pictures, as it's just very slow and difficult. Can anyone explain how to fix this? Thank you
I guess nobody knows...
Try this work around I posted elsewhere and it's helped a few people......
Add a random pic to the message (it will probably be a small file like you say), then add the picture you actually want to send (should be way bigger according to message size number, ie: goes from 200kb to 1375kb etc). Now long press on the first pic and remove it.....you SHOULD be left with the second pic and the size should be the original size of the pic 1375-200=1175kb.
Let me know if that works.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
onefasttreopro said:
Try this work around I posted elsewhere and it's helped a few people......
Add a random pic to the message (it will probably be a small file like you say), then add the picture you actually want to send (should be way bigger according to message size number, ie: goes from 200kb to 1375kb etc). Now long press on the first pic and remove it.....you SHOULD be left with the second pic and the size should be the original size of the pic 1375-200=1175kb.
Let me know if that works.
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hmm it didn't work... Also, cm10.1 doesnt allow me to attatch more than one picture for some reason. I can either send, remove, or replace
Ooooh, yea cm10 I'm not familiar with. I'm sorry, I'm on sense 5 atm...that workaround works for sense 4+.....in sense 5 the pics send full size off the bat with no issues...
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
All the AOSP roms seem to play funny with mms. I couldn't find a solution and tried quite a few things. Sense Rom was my solution.
I'd like to know if anyone else gets a text about the receiver having a size limit and your mms not going through?
southernstyle said:
All the AOSP roms seem to play funny with mms. I couldn't find a solution and tried quite a few things. Sense Rom was my solution.
I'd like to know if anyone else gets a text about the receiver having a size limit and your mms not going through?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Nope, never heard of such a thing.. at least from my end
I've received those notifications but only if sending a MMS to someone with a different carrier that sprint
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
eazy401 said:
I've received those notifications but only if sending a MMS to someone with a different carrier that sprint
Sent from my EVO using xda app-developers app
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is that what it is? I guess that makes sense. Most people I know are on Verizon.
Hello all...my question is if anyone knows of a mod available to boost the maximum size of MMS or change the amount that photos are compressed? I have many friends who notice my pictures look like garbage when I send it to them via MMS. Especially when zooming in on the photo. I have compared side by side and it's not the 4 MP camera, it's definitely the compression. I checked in my settings and i have the maximum size available selected.
I am running skyfall ROM by iBastid, s-off, rooted with elemental 0.18 sense kernel.
Thanks All for any suggestions on how to get some better MMS quality!
I don't have an answer for you in regards to the stock messaging app but all I can recommend to you is to use Google Hangouts for MMS.
Sent from my HTC One_M8 using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
I tried using the hangouts app is well and I had no success with it as far as changing the compression of pictures.
Sent from my HTC One_M8
Discovered the world of XPOSED today and the Sense 6 toolbox has a mod to increase MMS size up to 1000k, problem solved!
TheEmpyre said:
Discovered the world of XPOSED today and the Sense 6 toolbox has a mod to increase MMS size up to 1000k, problem solved!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FYI, this doesn't solve your problem. It just raises the max size, but the Messaging app still compresses down to ridiculous amounts. You might have noticed, before you even adjusted your max size, it wasn't even sending 300k, it compresses down to like 70k.
I still get stuff like 90k/1000k in most cases. It is garbage. Only way I can see right now is to use a different messaging app, but I would prefer to use the stock app.
tekkneke said:
FYI, this doesn't solve your problem. It just raises the max size, but the Messaging app still compresses down to ridiculous amounts. You might have noticed, before you even adjusted your max size, it wasn't even sending 300k, it compresses down to like 70k.
I still get stuff like 90k/1000k in most cases. It is garbage. Only way I can see right now is to use a different messaging app, but I would prefer to use the stock app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah I noticed the same thing, still garbage. I just never posted back. I am able to get some pictures to post with 800k but most are like 80 or 90. Haven't found any good solution at all
Sent from my HTC One_M8
TheEmpyre said:
Yeah I noticed the same thing, still garbage. I just never posted back. I am able to get some pictures to post with 800k but most are like 80 or 90. Haven't found any good solution at all
Sent from my HTC One_M8
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I put in a feature request on the sense toolbox page. Maybe they can figure it out.
I am beyond irritated with this same issue. It's not Tmobile that's compressing ititit's the phone. If you attached a pic that is less than 1000K (ex. 900K),it doesn't compress. But if youuuse a pic over 1000K, it compresses the heck out of it to like 150K. HTC needs to provide a fix for this!