[Q&A] [DEV-only][WIP] ALSA BCM21553 Audio libs built from source - BroadcomCM - Galaxy Ace S5830i Q&A, Help & Troubleshooting

Q&A for [DEV-only][WIP] ALSA BCM21553 Audio libs built from source - BroadcomCM
Some developers prefer that questions remain separate from their main development thread to help keep things organized. Placing your question within this thread will increase its chances of being answered by a member of the community or by the developer.
Before posting, please use the forum search and read through the discussion thread for [DEV-only][WIP] ALSA BCM21553 Audio libs built from source - BroadcomCM. If you can't find an answer, post it here, being sure to give as much information as possible (firmware version, steps to reproduce, logcat if available) so that you can get help.
Thanks for understanding and for helping to keep XDA neat and tidy!

---

Same Kernel but Cm 7 vs cm 9 have opposite Audio bug. Help?
Hi guys, just recently moved from Glass kernel modding and realized that my old Galaxy Y s5360 needed a fix. Ace and Y share same chipset so I'm writing to the most knowledgeable thread.
I see that you guys have got the BT a2dp working. I flashed bieltv rc4 kernel + cm 9.2 rc 5 and my bluetooth a2dp audio was fine but no mic / speaker working with normal phone call. Although phone music plays fine.
Also noticed that the ported ics rom from cm made phone slow + gms / vending didn't recognize device. So i decided to revert back to gingerbread using same kernel with customized hyperion 2015 rom.
With this the phone and all other audio fine + faster using gingerbread but the Bluetooth audio didn't work even after successful pairing with beats pill (thus worked before using cm 9.2).
So basically
cm 9 based ics rom works bt audio but not phone call.
Vs
CM 7 based gingerbread works phone and play service but not Bluetooth.
I understand that broad com stopped support and many devs moved to Alcatel-Lucent based libs and merged them.
Currently the rom I'm using is great except the bt audio. Which you guys have fixed in cm 9.
So my question is since both are running off biel last kernel, it would be possible to rewrite some of the cfg and libs on my current os to get it fully working (on gingerbread).
There are lots of threads and many git repo shared by all devs so basically I'm unclear which one had the right combo of libs.
I hope you can take few mins tui reply me back. I'm not a very active forum user but I am an experienced modder working for Google Glass QA Testing team, so hopefully if you can just show me the way i will be able to fix the rest without bothering you.
Thanks in advance
RK
@AUGmedix
nvsetup said:
I've created this thread to join developers into the final audio fix for android 2.3.7. Although the prupose of this thread is to fix Audio on Android 4.0.4 we first need audio drivers source.
On all our based Android 2.3.7 ROMs we fixed audio using some AOSP Alcatel .so files (to remove Samsung lib dependency) and some Samsung .so libraries too, this is the whole list:
Our device uses ALSA audio system, which is also used on stock ROM. This is related to software more than hardware, although we are not planning at the momnt to "change" this audio way. To activate ALSA audio some changes need to be done on kernel, that samsung provide to us on their kernel sources. Mostly we need to enable ALSA on device .config file:
Code:
CONFIG_BRCM_SOUND_ALSA=y
CONFIG_BRCM_SOUND_ATHENA_ALSA=y
That's not an issue as prebuilt alsa libs work, so new libs should work too. Ramdisk needs some edit too, as ALSA audio system is stored on dev/snd, and this is well defined too on our ramdisk, ueventd.rc
Code:
/dev/snd/* 0660 system audio
We realised after that that actually CyanogenMod 7.2 Sources include ALSA lib sources, what we didn't know if those sources could work with our devices. This sources build the following libs, as releated to its Android.mk files:
We can found inside /android_hardware_alsa_sound/tree/gb-release-7.2"]hardware/sound_alsa the following sources to build
libaudio
libaudioflinguer
hw/alsa.default
hw/acoustics.default
On
libasound
And apart from that, some other audio libs such as libaudiopolicy are built inside framework/base repository, but they doesn't make any conflict. Other libs are included on Android source files.
To enable the build of those libs, using ALSA software instead af "Android default (not sure about that)". I've enabled on Boardconfig.mk the following configs:
Code:
# Audio
BOARD_USES_GENERIC_AUDIO := false
BOARD_USES_ALSA_AUDIO := true
BOARD_PREBUILT_LIBAUDIO := false # even not writted.
BUILD_WITH_ALSA_UTILS := true
This configs enable the building of those libs on their Android.mk files.
Also, I've added on device_cooperve.mk the following lines to build those hw modules releated to audio:
Code:
# Audio
PRODUCT_PACKAGES += \
alsa.default \
acoustics.default
After the build finished, and fixed some errors, AUDIO WAS WORKING, but not as expected. There were issues on Audio Routing:
Headphones are detected through system, but audio is not reproduced on headphones (speakers does)
When you make a call, sometimes you can't and phone freezes, or when you hangout the call, phone freezes.
Everything else apart from that seems to be working, even microphone, although this bugs are pretty weird, I took a look to logcat.
Code:
[COLOR="Gray"]D/AndroidRuntime( 1419): CheckJNI is OFF
I/ ( 1420): ServiceManager: 0xad50[/COLOR]
[COLOR="Red"]E/ALSALib ( 1420): external/alsa-lib/src/control/control.c:882:(snd_ctl_open_noupdate) Invalid CTL AndroidOut[/COLOR]
W/AudioHardwareALSA( 1420): Unable to attach mixer to device AndroidOut: No such file or directory
[COLOR="Red"]E/ALSALib ( 1420): external/alsa-lib/src/control/control.c:882:(snd_ctl_open_noupdate) Invalid CTL AndroidIn[/COLOR]
W/AudioHardwareALSA( 1420): Unable to attach mixer to device AndroidIn: No such file or directory
D/AudioHardwareALSA( 1420): openOutputStream called for devices: 0x00000002
D/ALSAModule( 1420): open called for devices 00000002 in mode 0...
I/ALSAModule( 1420): Initialized ALSA PLAYBACK device AndroidPlayback_Speaker_normal
I/AudioHardwareALSA( 1420): buffer size (bytes) to AF = 16384
D/AudioFlinger( 1420): setParameters(): io 1, keyvalue routing=2, tid 1593, calling tid 1420
I/AudioFlinger( 1420): AudioFlinger's thread 0x1d978 ready to run
D/ALSAModule( 1420): route called for devices 00000002 in mode 0...
I managed to fix those errors (E/) by moddifying asound.conf, found on system/etc, adding this lines on the top and deleting old ones:
Code:
ctl.AndroidOut {
type hw
card 0 # Can replace with drivers name from /proc/asound/cards
}
ctl.AndroidIn {
type hw
card 0
}
Now logcat shows this at the moment
Code:
[COLOR="Gray"]D/AndroidRuntime( 1425): CheckJNI is OFF
I/ ( 1426): ServiceManager: 0xad50[/COLOR]
D/AudioHardwareALSA( 1426): openOutputStream called for devices: 0x00000002
D/ALSAModule( 1426): open called for devices 00000002 in mode 0...
I/ALSAModule( 1426): Initialized ALSA PLAYBACK device AndroidPlayback_Speaker_normal
I/AudioHardwareALSA( 1426): buffer size (bytes) to AF = 16384
D/AudioFlinger( 1426): setParameters(): io 1, keyvalue routing=2, tid 1604, calling tid 1426
I/AudioFlinger( 1426): AudioFlinger's thread 0x1d960 ready to run
D/ALSAModule( 1426): route called for devices 00000002 in mode 0...
Actually that's the actual logcat, using headphones, and sound goes through speakers:
Code:
D/dalvikvm( 1926): GC_EXTERNAL_ALLOC freed 324K, 49% free 3317K/6471K, external 571K/579K, paused 58ms
V/HeadsetObserver( 1607): Headset UEVENT: {SUBSYSTEM=switch, SWITCH_STATE=2, DEVPATH=/devices/virtual/switch/h2w, SEQNUM=1335, ACTION=change, SWITCH_NAME=h2w}
W/Vold ( 1415): Ignoring unknown switch 'h2w'
V/HeadsetObserver( 1607): Intent.ACTION_HEADSET_PLUG: state: 1 name: h2w mic: 0
I/HeadsetService( 1907): Headset plugged: true
I/Effect-DRC( 2115): Compression factor set to: 1.000000
I/Effect-BassBoost( 2115): New strength: 0
D/SurfaceFlinger( 1607): Layer[1c62e0] [2] non-RGB565 reloads
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting band 2 to 0
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting band 2 to 1
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting band 2 to 2
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting band 2 to 3
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting band 2 to 4
I/Effect-Equalizer( 2115): Setting loudness correction reference to 100.000000 dB
D/AudioFlinger( 2115): setParameters(): io 1, keyvalue routing=8, tid 2117, calling tid 2115
D/ALSAModule( 2115): route called for devices 00000008 in mode 0...
D/ALSAModule( 2115): open called for devices 00000008 in mode 0...
I/ALSAModule( 2115): Initialized ALSA PLAYBACK device AndroidPlayback
D/dalvikvm( 1926): GC_EXTERNAL_ALLOC freed 323K, 49% free 3327K/6471K, external 571K/579K, paused 44ms
We must take a look if that is kernel relevant or not, as we really need this libs to work, to then start working on CyanogenMod 9.1 / Android 4.0.4 audio. Any suggestions are welcomed, although if they are from newbie or developer, don't want this thread to be spammed as others
Click to expand...
Click to collapse