I have a Z Force on preorder, but I would really prefer a Moto Z. Looking at the Moto Mod functionality, it's pretty clear that neither phone will work well with a cover.
So my question is this: can I get close to the Z Force's durability with a high quality screen protector on the Moto Z, and if not, would it at least bring me to a level where a normal user could feel comfortable without a case?
I'm normally very careful with my phones, but once every year or so, a real drop does occur. Shattered my Galaxy S6 screen a week ago with the Samsung minimal case. Went for almost a year and a half with my nude first gen Moto X before cracking my first screen ever (on carpet!!!)
Thanks!
Nillkin has already 0.2mm 2.5D tempered glass screen protector for Motorola Moto Z, it's called H+ Pro.
http://nillkin.org/smartphones-acce...o-z-accessories/nillkin-motorola-moto-z-h-pro
---------- Post added at 02:17 PM ---------- Previous post was at 02:17 PM ----------
Nillkin has already 0.2mm 2.5D tempered glass screen protector for Motorola Moto Z, it's called H+ Pro.
http://nillkin.org/smartphones-acce...o-z-accessories/nillkin-motorola-moto-z-h-pro
A screen protector will not protect your screen from cracking in a significant fall. Only a case will do that.
I would actually physically compare phones before making a decision. I ended up picking up the Z Force. The phone still feels very thin and light to me. I think the regular Z is too thin. I really did not like the way it felt in my hand. As an added plus with the Z Force you end up with a significantly better battery, better camera, faster charging, and the shattershield screen.
Related
I'm probably not going to get alot of fans for this one due to the price but I can vouch for the quality of the Bodyguarz Pure tempered glass screen protector. I had one of these on my iPhone for over a year and it never lost its oleophobic coating, got one scratch or chipped.
I decided to go the cheap route on my G3 and purchased an i-Blason off Amazon. I installed it today was really disappointed. It chipped on the corner very easily and it was already a fingerprint magnet out of the box although it said it had multiple coatings. I pulled it off and headed down to the AT&T store and grabbed a Bodyguardz. Its $35 just like the Zagg or Spigen. It has a lifetime warranty. I have owned the Spigen and Zagg on other family members phones and each has their pros and cons. The Spigen is very nice but can be spotty on customer service. I have also had issues with all of the Spigens seating solidly around the edges. They always seem to have spots the adhesive is not good. The Zagg (on a Galaxy S4) seems to be good but lost its coating quickly as well. The Bodyguardz has the best oleo coating hands down. Its drawbacks are thickness (.4mm) and edges are not rounded. Still I can easily over look these things as the oleo coating is my #1 priority. Another thing I like is the Pure has a cutout for the earpiece which most of the cheaper ones do not protect the edge of the screen around the earpiece.
Anyway, for those heading into the AT&T store tomorrow check these out.
UPDATE: Many are experiencing touch sensitivity issues and have returned this shield. I also had the same issues.
I was a fan of the bodyguardz glass screen protector I had for my old note 2. I was sad when I couldn't find one from them for my g2.
Do they have ones for the g3 listed on their site?
Not sure if they are listed on the site. I just went in and picked one up at the store. If you are Premier, I would think they can be ordered though.
Do u find the accuracy and sensitivity are less with this protector? It seems that way to me. U are absolutely right about the oleophobic coating though. And marks that do appear, disappear on their own through coming in contact with fabric from my pocket
xxxda13 said:
Do u find the accuracy and sensitivity are less with this protector? It seems that way to me. U are absolutely right about the oleophobic coating though. And marks that do appear, disappear on their own through coming in contact with fabric from my pocket
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I took mine off. It definitely affected the screens sensitivity. I got sick of tapping the same icon 5 times before it would register. I wasted 35 dollars. I'm awaiting my nillkin screen protector. It's thinner and hopefully doesn't affect screen responsiveness. The oleophobic coating is great though.
Sent from my LG-F400K using XDA Premium 4 mobile app
There's a discussion at Android Central about this as well. I'm going to take mine off and return it.
http://forums.androidcentral.com/lg-g3/411487-touch-screen-issues.html#post3769538
---------- Post added at 09:25 AM ---------- Previous post was at 09:23 AM ----------
dee32181 said:
I'm awaiting my nillkin screen protector. It's thinner and hopefully doesn't affect screen responsiveness.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I recommend Nillkin as well. I've had it on my last couple of phones and it amazing quality for the price. They make great products.
For $6.74, seriously.
http://www.ebay.com/itm/231283226493
Sorry I didn't come back to this thread and edit my original post. I also returned mine over this past weekend. I did love the coating but I too experienced some sensitivity issues. I didn't even read about them but got fed up and got my money back.
I decided to go with the iCarez off Amazon.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KGSW734/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
At $8.95 it is unbelievable. It has rounded edges and is almost an exact clone of the Zagg that costs $40. Even the installation method is exactly the same. It is thinner at .33mm and I haven;t noticed any touch sensitivity issues at all.
awtryau89 said:
Sorry I didn't come back to this thread and edit my original post. I also returned mine over this past weekend. I did love the coating but I too experienced some sensitivity issues. I didn't even read about them but got fed up and got my money back.
I decided to go with the iCarez off Amazon.
http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KGSW734/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
At $8.95 it is unbelievable. It has rounded edges and is almost an exact clone of the Zagg that costs $40. Even the installation method is exactly the same. It is thinner at .33mm and I haven;t noticed any touch sensitivity issues at all.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is this a full screen or case friendly?
android_4life said:
Is this a full screen or case friendly?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Its full screen but does not have the cutout for the earpiece, its just the cutaway. If you can, go to a Best Buy Store and ask to see a Zagg. Usually someone in their mobile dept will have one on their G3 or S5. That will give you an idea of the quality, thickness, etc. It is exactly the same. I'm guessing same plant in china makes them and Zagg just overcharges.
awtryau89 said:
Its full screen but does not have the cutout for the earpiece, its just the cutaway. If you can, go to a Best Buy Store and ask to see a Zagg. Usually someone in their mobile dept will have one on their G3 or S5. That will give you an idea of the quality, thickness, etc. It is exactly the same. I'm guessing same plant in china makes them and Zagg just overcharges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Best buy carries the Zagg?
---------- Post added at 06:14 PM ---------- Previous post was at 06:07 PM ----------
awtryau89 said:
Its full screen but does not have the cutout for the earpiece, its just the cutaway. If you can, go to a Best Buy Store and ask to see a Zagg. Usually someone in their mobile dept will have one on their G3 or S5. That will give you an idea of the quality, thickness, etc. It is exactly the same. I'm guessing same plant in china makes them and Zagg just overcharges.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Is the screen look really smooth with no air bubbles?
Im looking for a tempered glass screen protector which tapers (or just going) around the screen at the edges.
I ordered one from ebay, but the top of the screen is not defended because the cut part. From the other hand, this is not going around at the edges...
With over 55 Million S7 devices sold - Why is it that No Company has produced a proper fitting Tempered Glass screen protector?? Spigen - Bodyguardz... Not one of them has..
https://www.google.ca/amp/m.gsmaren...sales_hit_55_million_milestone-news-24813.php
My Rant out of Frustration!
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk
same here. I got some online and when they arrived they are ridiculous small. looks stupid.
So I got one that actually covers the whole front of the phone. Works good.
Try Clearplex if available where you live.
No company has made one which properly fits because the phone's screen is a horribly complex shape to make a glass screen protector for. They'd have to make the protectors individually and curve them perfectly to fit the screen. Then the protector would be very expensive, and installation would require a much greater degree of accuracy. Look at all of the different protectors out there which have the same problems. Many of those companies have done their best with the material they buy from a glass supplier. They either go too close to the edge and know it'll lift, or stick with the flat surface only and know it' won't offer full coverage. This phone is probably a huge headache for them.
I've done what thundastruck has and stayed away from glass with my S7. It sucks, but I want good screen coverage and case compatibility. You can't get that with glass on the S7.
LouZiffer said:
No company has made one which properly fits because the phone's screen is a horribly complex shape to make a glass screen protector for. They'd have to make the protectors individually and curve them perfectly to fit the screen. Then the protector would be very expensive, and installation would require a much greater degree of accuracy. Look at all of the different protectors out there which have the same problems. Many of those companies have done their best with the material they buy from a glass supplier. They either go too close to the edge and know it'll lift, or stick with the flat surface only and know it' won't offer full coverage. This phone is probably a huge headache for them.
I've done what thundastruck has and stayed away from glass with my S7. It sucks, but I want good screen coverage and case compatibility. You can't get that with glass on the S7.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well Bodyguardz has decided to make a Tempered Glass Screen protector for the S8 that actually fits the curves - But I spoke to Bodyguardz and they DON'T have any plans to manufacture the ARC for the S7.....
https://www.bodyguardz.com/samsung/samsung-galaxy-s8-screen-protectors-tempered-glass.html
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk
shaggyskunk said:
Well Bodyguardz has decided to make a Tempered Glass Screen protector for the S8 that actually fits the curves - But I spoke to Bodyguardz and they DON'T have any plans to manufacture the ARC for the S7.....
https://www.bodyguardz.com/samsung/samsung-galaxy-s8-screen-protectors-tempered-glass.html
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's the thing: The S8 was made with curved sides, but they aren't nearly as difficult to make a protector for as the subtly tapered sides/corners/top/bottom that the S7 has. Manufacturers can better handle curves that run the entire length of the sides. Even so, when looking at screen protector reviews for the S8 I see folks are having a tough time with breakage and case compatibility. Flat screens are where glass protectors do best, as they can be cut from bulk sheets, need little to no additional processing, and installation is much easier.
Has anyone tried Bodyguardz's screen protector or contact case?
shaggyskunk said:
Well Bodyguardz has decided to make a Tempered Glass Screen protector for the S8 that actually fits the curves
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
All S8 protectors are pretty much crap, just like they were for the S6 and S7. There's only one that works properly is the Whitestone Dome, but it's been out of stock pretty consistantly since it came out.
entropism said:
All S8 protectors are pretty much crap, just like they were for the S6 and S7. There's only one that works properly is the Whitestone Dome, but it's been out of stock pretty consistantly since it came out.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried the Bodyguardz ARC?
Sent from my SM-G930W8 using Tapatalk
I have not, others have. Like I said, the ONLY one that works properly is the Whitestone Dome. The. Only. One.
---------- Post added at 05:24 PM ---------- Previous post was at 05:04 PM ----------
Here's how you can tell: Watch the BodyGuardz install video. See where he says "Run your finger along the edges to smooth the small bead of adhesive"? Yeah, that means there's no adhesive over the screen, and it's the same POS overpriced crap everyone else is selling.
Hello guys, just got a moto Z and I'm really loving it, but wanted to know how tough is it. I never really liked to use cases or screen protectors and never broke any screen like that, but the moto Z looks so thin and fragile that I'm kinda afraid to use it without a case and in a single drop crack the screen.
I came from a zenfone 3 max and Xperia t2 ultra, can I expect the same durability with the Z?
Thanks a lot
A plastic phone would be able to handle impact. A tight metal unibody phone will have a cracked screen when it falls. And if you buy a flagship phone(not a mid-range one), you should buy a tempered glass screen protector and a basic silicone case(look on Aliexpress, the Carbon fiber one is good and not too big/thick).
I, for example, bought 2 tempered glass protectors for 4$, the rugged case for 6$, 2 Dbrand skins( Dragon and Carbon fiber) for the back for 20$, Nillkin Ultra Thin for 5$ and Nillkin Frosted Shield for 5$ as well.
When I'm home, the phone is butt-naked(the skin on the back adds a lot of grip thanks to the texture). When I go out, I choose a case I feel like putting on that day.
You can do whatever you like but if you want a phone that will survive drops without a case, get a CAT smartphone, a cheap-feeling plastic smartphome phone or a NOKIA "dumbphone".
But to precisely answer: my Z fell from chest height and hit the metal chair leg(which is parallel to the floor). Not a single mark was left.
Check this out for durability:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kZOfYo4JDIw
I don't how you use it, but plain Moto Z (no mods, skins, bumper ,etc..) is a bit challenging to get a good grip on, so you might be looking at more drops ...
Thanks guys, I guess i'll just get a skin for a better grip. Again, thanks a lot
Hi. I am searching for Honor 8X Screen Protector . I have found some on amazon.in but their review are too bad. So if you are using please preferred me in your reply
I own this one https://www.ebay.fr/itm/2-2x-Honor-...e=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p2060353.m2749.l2649 for a week and the result is very great with a mat finish :good:
I have used ibywind glass protector for other phones and they were good. Anyone have tried ibywind for Huawei Honor 8X?
crazynitro66 said:
I own this one https://www.ebay.fr/itm/2-2x-Honor-...e=STRK:MEBIDX:IT&_trksid=p2060353.m2749.l2649 for a week and the result is very great with a mat finish :good:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Sounds interesting, I might give it a try. Does it fit fully the screen? Also, could you tell me if it plastic or tempered glass?
I had previously ordered on amazon the "widamin 2pack" which claims to be designed for 8X and receive a 'Amazon choice' award but doesn't fit the screen! Too small. What a disappointment.
---------- Post added at 01:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 PM ----------
As said in another post, the 8X screen is surprisingly fragile... Mine never felt or anything, but I notice quite a number of micro scratches (not visible when screen is lighted, but still, it is worrying!). Defintely need good screen protector.
Using GadgetShieldz Screen Protector no issues or colour effects its completely fine for me.
Ulfrik said:
Sounds interesting, I might give it a try. Does it fit fully the screen? Also, could you tell me if it plastic or tempered glass?
I had previously ordered on amazon the "widamin 2pack" which claims to be designed for 8X and receive a 'Amazon choice' award but doesn't fit the screen! Too small. What a disappointment.
---------- Post added at 01:01 PM ---------- Previous post was at 12:59 PM ----------
As said in another post, the 8X screen is surprisingly fragile... Mine never felt or anything, but I notice quite a number of micro scratches (not visible when screen is lighted, but still, it is worrying!). Defintely need good screen protector.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes it covers the full screen, apart of the curved edges of the screen (like the original screen protector). It is a plastic protector
One of my friend using Gadgetshieldz screen protector, He was totally satisfied with the screen protector and No issues was found till now.
https://amzn.to/2FRe9KW
OMOTON Full cover black. The same that in previous post but full screen and black.
Perfect for me. Covers full screen with rounded edges, oleophobic protection and very good tactile response.
Regards,
This, not covering the edges, but very nice screen view and protection.
€ 1,16 31%de DESCUENTO | Anti-Luz Azul de cristal templado para Huawei P20 10 Lite Pro Plus Nove 3 3e 3i Honor 20 10 9 Lite 8X película protectora de la pantalla
https://s.click.aliexpress.com/e/TIpysfA
Recently purchased these: https://www.amazon.co.uk/gp/product/B07GQP38TC but disappointed by size. Too small all way around by 1.5mm so encroaches in to screen area ;o(
Can anyone recommend a protector that fits accurately?
Nillkin Tempered Glass for honor 8X
Just noticed that my 2 months old P30 screen has a lot of scratches, some of which are pretty bad. Considering that my 2+ years old Nexus 5X didn't have a single scratch on it when I compared it earlier tonight, I'm highly disappointed at how fragile the P30 screen is. I'll have to look at a screen protector to limit the damage.
So do yourself a favor, even if like me you never used screen protectors with your previous phones, it's pretty much essential with this phone. I'm a bit pissed off right now that such an expensive phone is already quite visibly damaged so early despite me being rather careful with how I carry my phones.
That's why there is a screen protector on the P30 out of the box. Atleast for the one i got aswell as a friends one.
The cheapo screen protector that is pre-installed in the box scratches really easy and fast... But it's a screen protector
You sure the screen is scratched and not the pre-installed protector which you might not notice yet?
dipje said:
The cheapo screen protector that is pre-installed in the box scratches really easy and fast... But it's a screen protector
You sure the screen is scratched and not the pre-installed protector which you might not notice yet?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i took mine off, keep it pocket with keys coins ect. not a scratch on it lol. i cant stand screen protectors, first thing i do on any phone is take it off
u are right though, i knew at least of few people who mistakenly thought their screen was cracked for a long time not knowing it was their screen protector lol. one woman at work went to upgrade after it was "cracked" for a year, and the person in cell store took the protector off and she was stunned lol
No, it was definitely the screen - I removed the original screen protector as these are more intended for shipping protection than real day-to-day usage protection.
I bought a TPU screen protector from Amazon (https://www.amazon.ca/gp/product/B07N2R48T3/ ), and installed it a few days ago. In addition to protecting the screen, and it's also nearly invisible, I'd say it hid the fast majority of the visible scratches. There's just an area of the phone that has wider damage that still be seen when under the correct angle/lighting, the other scratches are no longer visible under the TPU protector.
This being the first time I ever used a screen protector, I'd say my installation isn't perfect (there are 3 or 4 small bubbles that won't go away, but they are all on the outside, and only one is over a visible part of the screen). But the final result looks much better than before, so I'd say that even on an already damaged screen, these TPU protectors are a good way to hide the damage.
Think I also figured out how it got damaged - this new jacket has a small metal press button at the top of the inner pocket. It's roundish and shouldn't normally damage a decently protected screen (like my former Nexus 5X), but the P30 fragile screen really didn't like it...
Do yourself a favour and get a case that covers the whole phone. I've had my p30 lite for a few days and the back is already shattered! Can't believe it!!!
Vloud1988 said:
Do yourself a favour and get a case that covers the whole phone. I've had my p30 lite for a few days and the back is already shattered! Can't believe it!!!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I find these too bulky, they ruin the look and feel, and they often interfere with the use of gesture-based navigation. I prefer a low-level bumper like posted in this thread (that Aliexpress one is working great for me so far) combined with a discrete TPU screen protector.
The screen protector came with a bumper case BTW, which they recommend using for the couple of days following the installation of the screen protector. I will return to my previous bumper case afterward, but I'd say if someone doesn't already have one, the one included with the screen protector is good enough (unless you drop your phones a lot). It's just not as discrete looking as the Aliexpress one.
Anyone has a yellowish tint on bottom of the screen? It's noticeable on white background.
Why are you asking this everywhere, in every thread?
why the f*** you ever remove original protector,they are perfectly applied and with no scratches after many months of use ?!
---------- Post added at 11:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:18 AM ----------
brusko1972 said:
Anyone has a yellowish tint on bottom of the screen? It's noticeable on white background.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ofc not
kuceens007 said:
why the f*** you ever remove original protector,they are perfectly applied and with no scratches after many months of use ?!
---------- Post added at 11:19 AM ---------- Previous post was at 11:18 AM ----------
ofc not
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Because only peasants use those low quality original screen protectors. High borns use glass screen protectors only. /s
RMerlin said:
Just noticed that my 2 months old P30 screen has a lot of scratches, some of which are pretty bad. Considering that my 2+ years old Nexus 5X didn't have a single scratch on it when I compared it earlier tonight, I'm highly disappointed at how fragile the P30 screen is. I'll have to look at a screen protector to limit the damage.
So do yourself a favor, even if like me you never used screen protectors with your previous phones, it's pretty much essential with this phone. I'm a bit pissed off right now that such an expensive phone is already quite visibly damaged so early despite me being rather careful with how I carry my phones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This is not a fault of the P30 - the side-effect of more shatter-proof glass is that it is slightly softer and more prone to scratches. This is well-known with other devices too (remember when Galaxy Note owners were moaning about this?)
With the P30 and it's completely flat display there is no excuse for not using a glass screen protector if you want to avoid scratches. Personally I thought the factory screen protector was fine, and it lasted me a good month before I even bothered installing the glass screen protector I bought on day one.
RMerlin said:
Just noticed that my 2 months old P30 screen has a lot of scratches, some of which are pretty bad. Considering that my 2+ years old Nexus 5X didn't have a single scratch on it when I compared it earlier tonight, I'm highly disappointed at how fragile the P30 screen is. I'll have to look at a screen protector to limit the damage.
So do yourself a favor, even if like me you never used screen protectors with your previous phones, it's pretty much essential with this phone. I'm a bit pissed off right now that such an expensive phone is already quite visibly damaged so early despite me being rather careful with how I carry my phones.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
My wife laughs at me but I never took off the plastic cover that came with the phone -- the one you're supposed to peel off when you first open the box with your brand new phone. It's still on there like 8 months later and has only developed one small bubble at the top left. I love knowing I have a perfectly pristine screen just under that plastic. The fingerprint scanner works fine as well.