ProtonAOSP
Android 11 ROM
ProtonAOSP is a minimal Android fork (custom ROM) focused on UI/UX and performance, with a touch of privacy.
Usage with my Proton Kernel is recommended to get the most out of your phone. The ROM does not include Proton Kernel, so you will need to flash it yourself. The ROM will still work with other kernels, but you will not get the benefits of Proton Kernel.
Screenshots
Screenshots of the latest version
Installation
This ROM is currently distributed as factory images, similar to stock. Flash it the same way you would flash stock factory images. Don't forget to wipe all data using "fastboot -w" before booting the ROM.
Firmware is included, so there is no specific requirement for which version of the stock ROM you are coming from.
You can also use the quick & easy web installer, which allows you to install and update the ROM from any computer or phone without using the command line. The installer works entirely within your web browser and completes in as little as 4 minutes, depending on the speed of your internet connection. Consider using the web installer instead of installing manually.
More detailed installation instructions and guides
Features
List of current features, with accompanying screenshots and explanations
Downloads
Downloads and changelogs for all versions
Builds with and without minimal Google services (gapps) included are provided for convenience.
Using the quick and easy web installer is recommended unless you have a specific reason to download and install the ROM manually.
Support
If you have questions or concerns, please read the Frequently Asked Questions before asking. It saves time for everyone involved, especially you, and allows us to provide higher-quality answers for all users.
Website with comprehensive documentation
Join the Telegram group for support and extras
Please consider donating to support development if you found this helpful: recurring donation to keep the project alive in the long term or buy me a coffee
Kernel source code
ROM source code
Thank you very much for posting this. I'll definitely be checking it out. Your Proton kernel is quite good already. Interested to see how the ROM functions too.
Really appreciate you building and sharing this for us!
I saw in the P5 thread that it may be possible to get call screening to work if the dialer gets systemized. It's a feature that has really come in handy for me so just want to confirm it will get call screening working.
To confirm, I just need to put GoogleDialer.apk into product/priv-app?
Alternatively, could I just use something like Titanium backup to make it a system app?
TIA
GoldElocks said:
Really appreciate you building and sharing this for us!
I saw in the P5 thread that it may be possible to get call screening to work if the dialer gets systemized. It's a feature that has really come in handy for me so just want to confirm it will get call screening working.
To confirm, I just need to put GoogleDialer.apk into product/priv-app?
Alternatively, could I just use something like Titanium backup to make it a system app?
TIA
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check out the magisk module systemizer, it's pretty good. I think you're right about all that.
Says microg support. So is does that mean microg is included? Or are standard "gapps" included?
letrain02 said:
Says microg support. So is does that mean microg is included? Or are standard "gapps" included?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
microG is supported on the non-gapps build, not included. The gapps build includes full gapps.
Thank you for awesome rom, big plus for microg support. Will flash as soon as my Bramble arrives.
did flash all. now google logo, then a fire with beaker on screen.
edit: nevermind...guess that was the loading screen. took a few minutes. didn't seem like a "loading screen"
I am new to ADB AS my old phone used TWRP. Do I need to unlock the bootloader? Is it recommented to Start Form stock ROM, because I am currently on LineageOS? It is MicroG ready, does it mean that install MicroG via F-Droid, or do I install it like it is drscribed there at the Installation instructions?
Estebanium said:
I am new to ADB AS my old phone used TWRP. Do I need to unlock the bootloader? Is it recommented to Start Form stock ROM, because I am currently on LineageOS? It is MicroG ready, does it mean that install MicroG via F-Droid, or do I install it like it is drscribed there at the Installation instructions?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You do need to unlock the bootloader. Switching from LineageOS should work, but you will need to wipe data as always.
microG should be installed from F-Droid after installing the ROM.
kdrag0n said:
You do need to unlock the bootloader. Switching from LineageOS should work, but you will need to wipe data as always.
microG should be installed from F-Droid after installing the ROM.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you very much. I flashed it and it rebooted directly to the OS. Afterwards I installed your Kernel. The OS feels fast, but in comparison to Lineage for the same Phone, it feels slower. If you swipe for the action center, it is very slow and laggy. If you swipe for task manager and swipe through the recent apps, it lags. Are there any similar experiences?
Estebanium said:
Thank you very much. I flashed it and it rebooted directly to the OS. Afterwards I installed your Kernel. The OS feels fast, but in comparison to Lineage for the same Phone, it feels slower. If you swipe for the action center, it is very slow and laggy. If you swipe for task manager and swipe through the recent apps, it lags. Are there any similar experiences?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The lag in those specific locations is caused by the frosted glass blur effect. Disable it in developer options if you want to trade it off for performance instead. The blur performance problems should be addressed in future versions.
kdrag0n said:
The lag in those specific locations is caused by the frosted glass blur effect. Disable it in developer options if you want to trade it off for performance instead. The blur performance problems should be addressed in future versions.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for your reply. I am looking forward to a new release. For now I stick to LOS. Could you tell me the procedure for updating your ROM? Is it possible to dirty flash the update, so I don't need to backup my data externally?
GoldElocks said:
To confirm, I just need to put GoogleDialer.apk into product/priv-app?
Alternatively, could I just use something like Titanium backup to make it a system app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ocwa said:
Check out the magisk module systemizer, it's pretty good. I think you're right about all that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I tried to use Magisk Systemizer and Titanium Backup to move this into a system app, but there's not enough free space in what I'm assuming is the system partition (Titanium Backup just labels it the "System ROM").
I tried to uninstall some of the system apps using Titanium Backup and SD Maid Pro but both failed to be able to remove any "expendable" system apps.
Estebanium said:
Thank you for your reply. I am looking forward to a new release. For now I stick to LOS. Could you tell me the procedure for updating your ROM? Is it possible to dirty flash the update, so I don't need to backup my data externally?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, you can dirty flash updates to my ROM. Clean flashes are only necessary when switching from another ROM.
OptoChip said:
I tried to use Magisk Systemizer and Titanium Backup to move this into a system app, but there's not enough free space in what I'm assuming is the system partition (Titanium Backup just labels it the "System ROM").
I tried to uninstall some of the system apps using Titanium Backup and SD Maid Pro but both failed to be able to remove any "expendable" system apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
With dynamic partitions, the system partition is perfectly sized to hold exactly the amount of data the ROM has in it, so there will always be no free space. You need to use Magisk to systemize apps.
kdrag0n said:
With dynamic partitions, the system partition is perfectly sized to hold exactly the amount of data the ROM has in it, so there will always be no free space. You need to use Magisk to systemize apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Dynamically sized partitions explains the "no free space" (and it makes total sense to layout the system partition this way). I was trying to use Magisk Systemize, took me revisiting it to realize that I didn't have Busybox installed. Installing the Magisk BusyBox module enabled me to Systemize the Phone app. Many thanks!
kdrag0n said:
Yes, you can dirty flash updates to my ROM. Clean flashes are only necessary when switching from another ROM.
With dynamic partitions, the system partition is perfectly sized to hold exactly the amount of data the ROM has in it, so there will always be no free space. You need to use Magisk to systemize apps.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hello kdrag0n, I am thinking about switching phone service from Verizon to Google FI and I would like to root a Pixel 4a or an Pixel 4a.(5G). Can anyone tell me if this Rom has the Hotspot wifi tethering option included in the Rom? Thank You
wilspeak said:
Hello kdrag0n, I am thinking about switching phone service from Verizon to Google FI and I would like to root a Pixel 4a or an Pixel 4a.(5G). Can anyone tell me if this Rom has the Hotspot wifi tethering option included in the Rom? Thank You
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. The hotspot option comes with it from what I have tried.
J-I-N-X said:
Yes. The hotspot option comes with it from what I have tried.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank You for your time
I cant manage to root this rom with proton kernel even on stock cant root pixel4a 5g any guide or help apriciated....
Related
IntroductionMost Android devices come with bloatware in some form or another. At best, nearly all of those apps do nothing but take up precious space. At worst, they get in your way of working productively and efficiently. Wouldn't it be nice if getting rid of those apps was just a matter of uninstalling them?
Problem is, there is no easy way to completely rid yourself of bloat—unless you have a rooted device, in which case, completely jettisoning that bloatware is actually possible. But even if you don't have a rooted device, all is not lost. I want to introduce you to some tools that will help you rid yourself of that bloatware—or hide it from sight on un-rooted devices.
Before I introduce you to the apps, I have to remind you to always have a full backup of your device and to use caution when deleting apps. Do not delete critical system apps—otherwise you'll wind up with a non-functioning phone. End standardized warning.
I am going to share Bloatware Removal Script especially designed for Android Marshmallow. You can use this script after flashing Custom ROMs on your device. This script will remove main apps like CM File Manager, Launcher3, CMHome, AOSP Browser, AOSP Gallery, AOSP Camera etc. I have also made a flashable zip of Extra Apps that will install Es File Manager, Gallery Extra by Cyanogen, AudioFX by Cyanogen, ScreenCast by Cyanogen, Google Now Launcher etc. on your system partition.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Disclaimer
Flash this at your own risk. I am not responsible for any damaged or bricked devices.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Advantages of Removing Bloatwares
Free up System
Get rid of non-usable apps
Better RAM Management
List of Apps That the script will remove from Your Device
system/app/Apollo
system/app/BasicDreams
system/app/Browser
system/app/Camera2
system/app/Calendar
system/app/CellBroadcastReceiver
system/app/CMFileManager
system/app/CMHome
system/app/CMWallpapers
system/app/DashClock
system/app/DSPManager
system/app/Eleven
system/app/Email
system/app/Exchange2
system/app/FileManager
system/app/Galaxy4
system/app/Gallery2
system/app/HoloSpiralWallpaper
system/app/LiveWallpapers
system/app/MagicSmokeWallpapers
system/app/Music
system/app/NoiseField
system/app/PhaseBeam
system/app/PhotoPhase
system/app/PhotoTable
system/app/VideoEditor
system/app/VisualizationWallpapers
system/app/VoicePlus
system/app/WhisperPush
system/priv-app/Launcher3
system/priv-app/MusicFX
system/priv-app/AudioFX
system/priv-app/PicoTts
system/priv-app/talkback
Extra Apps[Flashable via Custom Recovery] includes[Optional] you can directly install these apps normally by unzipping the "Extra_Apps.zip"
Google Chrome
Google Camera
Google Now Launcher
Google DeskClock
Google Play Music
Gallery Next by Cyanogen New
AudioFX by Cyanogen New
Audio Recorder by Sony Communication
ScreenCast
Es File Explorer
Installation Procedure
Flash Custom ROM
Flash G-APPs
Reboot Your Device
Go to Custom Recovery
Flash "Bloatware_Removal_Script_For_MM.zip"
Flash "Extra_Apps.zip" [Optional]
Wipe Cache and Dalvik Cache
Reboot and Enjoy!
Download Section-> Bloatware Removal Script: Download from here
-> Extra Apps [Optional]: Download from here
Tested on: Karbonn Sparkle V with OCT_OS_MM ROM
Credits: Google, Sprout4 Developers and @jajb
Press Thanks If I Helped You
meprakash_pyc said:
...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hey, thanks for sharing :good:
I noticed this script shares 98% of the code from the one from this thread (download). If you used this (or any other) script as a base, it'd be nice if you'd give credit. This is no accusation by all means, just noticed the similarity.
P1nGu1n_ said:
Hey, thanks for sharing :good:
I noticed this script shares 98% of the code from the one from this thread (download). If you used this (or any other) script as a base, it'd be nice if you'd give credit. This is no accusation by all means, just noticed the similarity.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
done
Can i use it for lollypop (Flyme OS)
For convenience, latest MicroG & Open GApps enabled MTCB/MTCC firmware, in a suitable thread.
Updated on July 3, 2018:
(reason in post #636)
MicroG in post #396, and here:
Mod Edit :- Links Removed
Mod Edit :- Links Removed
Open GApps in post #416, and here:
Mod Edit :- Links Removed
Mod Edit :- Links Removed
They are interchangeable, same partitioning, I would switch between them with a wipe all in recovery. I'd also say equally fast.
I currently use the Open GApps version, recommendable, since it does not require special settings or workarounds, as being 100% Google compatible. It also performs a one time nice Google setup of the unit, beginning with language, account, and so on.
Note to all using this firmware for the first time: since it is differently partitioned from what you had before, you must also perform a wipe all in recovery, ideally just before the first startup (to avoid wasting time), or at any time now.
WARNING: MicroG Core and LP don't work well: contacts are not seen from apps like Hangouts, Google/Voice Search, while True Contacts needs local loading of profile & contacts - from vcards on the internal SD. Therefore I strongly recommend the Open GApps version!
Note also that with the MicroG version, the gms core app must be configured, and Hangouts' service called NetworkConnectionCheckingService must be disabled, for Hangouts to work:
Code:
pm disable com.google.android.talk/com.google.android.apps.hangouts.service.NetworkConnectionCheckingService
TomTom GO storage support is explained in post #45.
TT GO spoofing is in post #392.
Poweramp's early start&restart is also supported by default.
Phone calls via a BT connected phone could be dialed by (always) selecting the MTC Service(aka Headunit), as the preferred dialer.
MTC Sound direct sound control is readily supported, if the associated hardware mod is also done.
Automatic screen brightness control based on location&time is also implemented by default.
Blank logo kernels are in post #600 (get them while they last).
Developer Mode in post #332.
Firmware is also rooted and xposed.
To those who make outlandish claims about this firmware: they are either trolls or firmware is not for them. However firmware supports all rk3188 MTCB or MTCC units. Make your own judgement, and don't get scared away.
===
BTW, be careful, don't ruin this thread of mine, because I won't open another ever again...
===
Here's another one: in principle, unless an unlikely bug is reported, I don't reply in this thread to users who are not listed as saying thank you to this post.
===
Mod Edit :- Content Removed
Thanks @dsa8310 .. your rooms are great .. I installed microg rom yesterday . Works great . Will try the new one soon. The only question I have is the performance of both roms similar coz I have 1GB Ram
dsa8310 said:
For convenience, latest MicroG & Open GApps enabled MTCB/MTCC firmware, in a suitable thread.
MicroG in post #396.
Open GApps in post #416.
They are interchangeable, same partitioning, I would switch between them with a wipe all in recovery.
I currently use the Open GApps version, recommendable, since it does not require special settings or workarounds.
===
BTW, be careful, don't ruin this thread of mine, because I won't open another ever again...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi @dsa8310, is it possible to find what version of your firmware that I have installed in my radio. I think I updated yesterday, but not sure if it the recent one that you posted yesterday.
Maybe a tall tell signature or something to look for.
Again, thanks for your work on the firmware. And I hope this section works out for you.
Wayne
The Open GApps firmware has DPI 240 (as the original) while MicroG has DPI 210 and it appears shifted slightly to the left on 800x480 screens, at least.
It's a detail that could be easily adjusted (parameter ro.sf.lcd_density in file /system/build.prop).
The MicroG specific (gms) app is also present in its corresponding flavor lineup, plus the extra xposed module (for fake signature).
Other than that I don't keep track of versions - it's only the last one that matters.
As usualI I ll be putting the ROMs on the fileserver for everyone.
Where is the donate button ?
Thank you very much for your hard work
I am running right now DSA Rom 5.1.1 with MicroG and its awesome.....
So fast and stable, highly recommended.
Should I switch to open gapps ? I am very happy with MicroG, is it worth it ?
Best regards
dsa8310 said:
The Open GApps firmware has DPI 240 (as the original) while MicroG has DPI 210 and it appears shifted slightly to the left on 800x480 screens, at least.
It's a detail that could be easily adjusted (parameter ro.sf.lcd_density in file /system/build.prop).
The MicroG specific (gms) app is also present in its corresponding flavor lineup, plus the extra xposed module (for fake signature).
Other than that I don't keep track of versions - it's only the last one that matters.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the 6/28 one.. MicroG I guess. Getting Gapps..
Thanks bud.
Like to donate as well..
EagleSoldier said:
Where is the donate button ?
Thank you very much for your hard work
I am running right now DSA Rom 5.1.1 with MicroG and its awesome.....
So fast and stable, highly recommended.
Should I switch to open gapps ? I am very happy with MicroG, is it worth it ?
Best regards
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I now use the (pico) Open GApps enabled version. I like it because I don't have to configure things and it is 100% Google compatible. I dislike it because of Google ads' undisturbed presence, unlike the MicroG version that avoids them, partially, at least for my set of apps.
There might be observable differences in their footprint size (necessary RAM) and load of system (background tasks). I can't say for sure, since I have a 2GB RAM (upgraded) unit. Furthermore, I run the same set of apps most of time: Poweramp and TomTom GO which have the same heavy requirements (TT mainly).
Perhaps 1GB units should use MicroG while 2GB ones could afford the Open GApps version.
A technical comparison between versions could be done, in a terminal (termux), with commands like "free -m" (free memory) and "uptime" (busybox uptime) (for load average); "busybox ps", too, if implemented.
But, ultimately, it's a matter of feeling: if you feel that one version is more responsive, feel free to use it.
(switching back and forth is facilitated by the same partitioning, though going through a wipe all in recovery seems necessary)
I've got a 1gb joying radio. I can confirm that system boot is much faster than Malaysk 4.4.4, BUT apps like Pandora and Google maps take ages to load and sometimes even freeze. So I'll go back to KitKat.
ankerede said:
I've got a 1gb joying radio. I can confirm that system boot is much faster than Malaysk 4.4.4, BUT apps like Pandora and Google maps take ages to load and sometimes even freeze. So I'll go back to KitKat.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried both MicroG and Open GApps? If yes, was it any difference for you?
The system is tuned for TomTom GO, for example, if you make a folder called tomtom/com.tomtom.gplay.navapp/foobar on any of your external storage (the GPS card, usually) then big maps will stay externally. While TT GO, the "free" version (v1.16.1_Build_2077, if I recall correctly), lays around the internet...
(making the folder above will help even if TT is not installed, because the system will stop looking for it, in a loop)
dsa8310 said:
Have you tried both MicroG and Open GApps? If yes, was it any difference for you?
The system is tuned for TomTom GO, for example, if you make a folder called tomtom/com.tomtom.gplay.navapp/foobar on any of your external storage (the GPS card, usually) then big maps will stay externally. While TT GO, the "free" version (v1.16.1_Build_2077, if I recall correctly), lays around the internet...
(making the folder above will help even if TT is not installed, because the system will stop looking for it, in a loop)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
So far I I only used your latest micro G. I thought it might be quicker , because of less Google apps
ankerede said:
So far I I only used your latest micro G. I thought it might be quicker , because of less Google apps
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Well, if you expect all your apps to be supported, try the Open GApps version. It's the pico flavor, minimal setup for Google support.
(make a wipe all from recovery, just before first reboot)
dsa8310 said:
For convenience, latest MicroG & Open GApps enabled MTCB/MTCC firmware, in a suitable thread.
MicroG in post #396, and here:
mxupdateKLD1024x600LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part2.rar
mxupdateKLD1024x600LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part1.rar
mxupdateKLD800x480LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part2.rar
mxupdateKLD800x480LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part1.rar
Open GApps in post #416, and here:
oxupdateKLD1024x600LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part2.rar
oxupdateKLD1024x600LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part1.rar
oxupdateKLD800x480LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part2.rar
oxupdateKLD800x480LP5.1.1.rk3188.MTCB-C.December.part1.rar
They are interchangeable, same partitioning, I would switch between them with a wipe all in recovery. I'd also say equally fast.
I currently use the Open GApps version, recommendable, since it does not require special settings or workarounds, as being 100% Google compatible.
===
BTW, be careful, don't ruin this thread of mine, because I won't open another ever again...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Are these versions different from what you posted on the other thread? You said on the other thread to wipe before installing the GApps version.
If I can switch between them without a full wipe, I'll give some feedback on which one is faster on 1GB.
elyl said:
Are these versions different from what you posted on the other thread? You said on the other thread to wipe before installing the GApps version.
If I can switch between them without a full wipe, I'll give some feedback on which one is faster on 1GB.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, they are not.
It's possible, but then uninstall by hand three apps: com.google.android.gsf, org.microg.gms.droidguard, FakeGapps1.1, and then reboot.
Hi dsa,
i'm on your latest microg version of your firmware with the playstore. But when i open the playstore and try to connect i get this error: [RH-01]
any idea?
problem iam facing now i cant play music while using google maps, any help?
dsa8310 said:
Well, if you expect all your apps to be supported, try the Open GApps version. It's the pico flavor, minimal setup for Google support.
(make a wipe all from recovery, just before first reboot)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I give it a + for GApps. Still works nice with Google Play and able to use what you paid for with no issues.
Finally got more play time with the latest and I like it.. Using 1G, no upgrade memory at all..
Still need to add a few more apps.. but good to go..
Thanks @dsa8310
Yes, the MicroG version is not 100% compatible, and also needs some extra configurations (described in the other thread, see the mentioned posts - in the OP of this thread - and subsequent ones).
While the Open GApps version is fully supported, and equally fast, no drawbacks at all.
The speed is determined by the mix of apps run on the HU, in any case.
I would suggest that you check out the Open GApps version - make a wipe all (from recovery) just before the first start, and you will enjoy a nice one time Google setup of the unit, commencing with language, account, and so on.
And once you go black you'll never go back!
dsa8310 said:
Yes, the MicroG version is not 100% compatible, and also needs some extra configurations (described in the other thread, see the mentioned posts - in the OP of this thread - and subsequent ones).
While the Open GApps version is fully supported, and equally fast, no drawbacks at all.
The speed is determined by the mix of apps run on the HU, in any case.
I would suggest that you check out the Open GApps version - make a wipe all (from recovery) just before the first start, and you will enjoy a nice one time Google setup of the unit, commencing with language, account, and so on.
And once you go black you'll never go back!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Exactly what I did. A setup that I have never seen before had to be done. Great Job.
It's Open GApps' merit, not mine. Once the setup is done, everything else falls into place.
Long story short, this is a zip to debloat your S8 and probably other Samsung devices. Please modify it to suit your firmware. *As long as your rom is from Samsung, regardless of nougat or oreo, most of the package names should be the same thus this zip should still remove quite a lot of them by default, you will need some minor edits to match your rom perfectly though.
The attached zip is what I'm currently using, there's something that I had commented out because I use that feature and never tried disabling it. Please feel free to experiment with it and modify the script as per your need. However, do pay close attention to some of the lines as activating them will cause your phone fail to boot.
If you had any error or knowledge about what certain file does, please provide feedback so that we can improve this script. The ultimate goal is to know what we can stripe off from TouchWiz ROM until close AOSP state without breaking features that we use, that includes .apk files, files of any format and even related lines in build.prop.
Also, for anyone who wishes to use this script in any way, please feel free to do so. No need to inform or give credit.
Since I do not backup my file before testing, I'm using Github to do this for me. The most updated version will be on Github.
For more information please visit Github.
Credit
SoLdieR9312 for his OREO BETA6 Debloat zip as template.
foobar66 for his debloat shell script as a reference.
Google as well as several posts in XDA Developers forum
Hall of fame
1. Debloating Samsung Experience Service might lead to Samsung Account FC / bootloop. By: Saibot.XI
After this zip your phone will be left with:
Stock Samsung Audio (Adapt sound, SoudAlive, etc)
Stock Samsung AOD
Stock Samsung Calculator
Stock Samsung Calendar
Stock Samsung Camera & all plugin
Stock Samsung Clock
Stock Samsung Contacts
Stock Samsung Device maintenance w/ McAfee removed
Stock Samsung Gallery & related editor
Stock Samsung Game Launcher & services
Stock Samsung Live wallpaper picker
Stock Samsung Messages
Stock Samsung Music
Stock Samsung Phone
Stock Samsung Smart capture (Screenshot w/ crop, drawing features)
Stock Samsung Launcher
Stock Samsung Video Player
Samsung Desktop Smart Switch support .apk file
Google play etc among some preloads
And some files that IDK what they do/what will happen after removal
Over hundred of apk files will be removed.
Theme center and Samsung account will also be removed, if you want to use theme, please comment them out before flashing.
They can be removed after you applied your theme and will stick after reboot. This is what I did too.
How do i add themestore and remove it after applying theme? Also, flash in twrp?
Got it working nvm. Awesome work!
I'm on AQGL and used Flashfire but the script doesn't seem to work. I updated the script to reflect the boot device as /dev/block/platform/soc/1da4000.ufshc/by-name/system but that didn't work either. Any other hints or suggestions?
TIA.
kleen3r said:
I'm on AQGL and used Flashfire but the script doesn't seem to work. I updated the script to reflect the boot device as /dev/block/platform/soc/1da4000.ufshc/by-name/system but that didn't work either. Any other hints or suggestions?
TIA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
used the updated script from github and works perfectly!
is this working on 955N or 950N variant?
Very good ! VERY SMOOTH AND FAST!
Box3D said:
is this working on 955N or 950N variant?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I do expect people here to experiment with it, as I said in Github this is not (completely) noob-friendly.
You can cross check the script with your ROM, majority of the Samsung preloaded app will be the same, the difference usually is carrier apps. Maybe I shouldn't mention that I'm using AQL5.
XDA developer yeah, not XDA noobs.
kleen3r said:
I'm on AQGL and used Flashfire but the script doesn't seem to work. I updated the script to reflect the boot device as /dev/block/platform/soc/1da4000.ufshc/by-name/system but that didn't work either. Any other hints or suggestions?
TIA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I've no idea what is flashfire, sorry about that.
ImbaWind said:
I've no idea what is flashfire, sorry about that.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's an app that flashes zip files similar to TWRP. I have the snapdragon 955u variant so cant use twrp since the bootloader is locked. I do have root though.
kleen3r said:
It's an app that flashes zip files similar to TWRP. I have the snapdragon 955u variant so cant use twrp since the bootloader is locked. I do have root though.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I see, good to know. Im using an exynos version so cant really figure that out.
You can even delete folder/file one by one by using terminal/root explorer according to my updater-script, that shouldn't make much of a difference.
Will this work on oreo zra5? Actually tried flashing this but it didnt remove anything at all
I personally use the Package Disabler because I'm not that worried about space but the script helped me extremely on what to disable. Very helpful. (also on aql5 btw)
dr460nf1r3 said:
Will this work on oreo zra5? Actually tried flashing this but it didnt remove anything at all
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's weird, it should be able to delete what nougat and oreo have in common and there's quite a few.
porkslapchop90 said:
I personally use the Package Disabler because I'm not that worried about space but the script helped me extremely on what to disable. Very helpful. (also on aql5 btw)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
System space is quite useless, but it makes people like me feel better when useless stuff is actually gotten rid of.
Plus it is able to remove files, that's beyond the ability of package disabler.
Work on 7.0 aql5? Renovate 7.5
Hey after flashing this tool i have problem : screen write is ereased and when i want to use root file to open system/app my device suddenly reboot what could be the problem?
Nathan5900 said:
Work on 7.0 aql5? Renovate 7.5
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Im using stock aql5, how do you define 'work' tho?
EDIT: This zip basically removes stuff, so if your ROM contains the stuff that match the updater-script, it gets removed. Nothing magic happening here.
torhect said:
Hey after flashing this tool i have problem : screen write is ereased and when i want to use root file to open system/app my device suddenly reboot what could be the problem?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This script doesn't remove the function that allows you to draw on your screenshot cause I'm using that too, one of the actually handy feature added by Samsung...
The reboot part, I'm not sure. Somehow when I try to add back apks directly to system via explorer, my /data partition gets corrupted with
Code:
persist.security.tlc.otp structure needs cleaning
in TWRP, only format data fixes this, and this happened to me twice so I'd recommend you to flash them in instead using the rescue zip template I provided in Github.
The script is really good, I just read it line by line but since I see some issues reported for some people I prefer to try it out later
Edit: i was thinking on replace all Samsung needed apps with Google ones like phone and dialer, anyone knows a port from those?
SpacesungGalaxy J727P
(J727PVPU3ARC2)Disclaimer:
I am not responsible for what you do with your device. If you decide to flash this software then you are accepting any risks involved. Including, but not limited to; bricking your device, missing alarms, missing calls, loss of your job, repossession of your car, and maybe even spilt milk.
About:
This is very much a personal project that I felt others would appreciate. I enjoy retro gaming very much, and as some of you may know, emulation is very CPU intensive. Hence the reason for making Spacesung. My goal was a stock rom that was lag free, debloated, and buttery smooth for gaming. I believe I have achieved this, and so, I give this to the you, to enjoy, use, modify, and share at your discretion.
Features
•Deodexed
•Debloated- I have removed all unnecessary Samsung, Google, and Amazon apps.
•Removed all Amazon symlinks. (Libs are next.)
•Deknoxed- Note: Some leftovers may be present. If you find any please let me know.
•Rooted- SuperSu is included.
•Up to 10gb+ of internal storage is available. This number will change depending on what you install afterwards, and what you have already stored on your internal SD.
Instructions:
1. Download the ROM from here.
2. Download GoogleKeyboard. You will need this after installation because the Samsung keyboard has been removed.
3. Make sure both files are on your internal, or external storage. Either is fine.
4. Reboot to recovery and wipe, data, system, cache, & dalvik cache.
5. Install Spacesung.
6. Reboot and wait. SuperSU will cause it to boot loop once. This is just root sinking it's teeth into the system. Don't interrupt it. After the aforementioned loop, it'll take about ~5-8min to start up. This only applies to the very first boot. Afterwards it only takes ~10 seconds to startup.
7. Skip all the setup steps that require typing. This can be done after you install GoogleKeyboard.
8. Enjoy!
Special notes:
*Google play, and Google services are still installed. You can disable both if you want to. You must disable it as a device administrator under the security options first, or it will be grayed out.
*Syncing will not work, since it has also been removed.
*Device encryption and secure storage shouldn't work either.
*Chrome is still installed. It can also disabled. There is no way to remove it yet, as the 7.0 framework uses it for webview. I'm still searching for a workaround to save more space.
*Anything not listed, should be working perfectly. If something is broken, let me know. And please remember, that anything already listed is not a bug, it is intentional. If you have any issues with 3rd party apps, I will try to help you, though I make no promises.
New!: Spacesung Oreo Debloat ScriptNotes:
1. Flash in recovery after the first boot.
2. Wipe dalvik cache ONLY! (Oreo cleans up data from removed apps automagically after rebooting.)
3. Profit!
*If you want to modify what's removed, simply open the updater-script with a text editor (preferably Notepad++) and add or remove the # sign. All apps in the stock Oreo system are listed in alphabetical order. This script should be safe to flash as is. Touchwiz, Theme store, Google play, and Samsung keyboard, are not removed by default. No files will be added to your OS either.
Ex.
delete_recursive("/system/app/AmazonMP3"); ← This would be deleted. #delete_recursive("/system/app/AmazonMP3"); ← This would be ignored.
*As always, anything that I make is free to use for other projects, public or personal, without my permission. No need to ask me, just do it! Credit is always appreciated, though not required.
J727P
Spaceminer said:
SpacesungGalaxy J727P
(J727PVPU3ARC2)Disclaimer:
I am not responsible for what you do with your device. If you decide to flash this software then you are accepting any risks involved. Including, but not limited to; bricking your device, missing alarms, missing calls, loss of your job, repossession of your car, and maybe even spilt milk.
About:
This is very much a personal project that I felt others would appreciate. I enjoy retro gaming very much, and as some of you may know, emulation is very CPU intensive. Hence the reason for making Spacesung. My goal was a stock rom that was lag free, debloated, and buttery smooth for gaming. I believe I have achieved this, and so, I give this to the you, to enjoy, use, modify, and share at your discretion.
Features
•Deodexed
•Debloated- I have removed all unnecessary Samsung, Google, and Amazon apps.
•Removed all Amazon symlinks. (Libs are next.)
•Deknoxed- Note: Some leftovers may be present. If you find any please let me know.
•Rooted- SuperSu is included.
•Up to 10gb+ of internal storage is available. This number will change depending on what you install afterwards, and what you have already stored on your internal SD.
Instructions:
1. Download the ROM from here.
2. Download GoogleKeyboard. You will need this after installation because the Samsung keyboard has been removed.
3. Make sure both files are on your internal, or external storage. Either is fine.
4. Reboot to recovery and wipe, data, system, cache, & dalvik cache.
5. Install Spacesung.
6. Reboot and wait. SuperSU will cause it to boot loop once. This is just root sinking it's teeth into the system. Don't interrupt it. After the aforementioned loop, it'll take about ~5-8min to start up. This only applies to the very first boot. Afterwards it only takes ~10 seconds to startup.
7. Skip all the setup steps that require typing. This can be done after you install GoogleKeyboard.
8. Enjoy!
Special notes:
*Google play, and Google services are still installed. You can disable both if you want to. You must disable it as a device administrator under the security options first, or it will be grayed out.
*Syncing will not work, since it has also been removed.
*Device encryption and secure storage shouldn't work either.
*Chrome is still installed. It can also disabled. There is no way to remove it yet, as the 7.0 framework uses it for webview. I'm still searching for a workaround to save more space.
*Anything not listed, should be working perfectly. If something is broken, let me know. And please remember, that anything already listed is not a bug, it is intentional. If you have any issues with 3rd party apps, I will try to help you, though I make no promises.
*As always, anything that I make is free to use for other projects, public or personal, without my permission. No need to ask me, just do it! Credit is always appreciated, though not required.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
One question did you add any kernel tweaks to your build ? An why can't I find any system tweaks ? Sorry two Questions !!
peter couniaz said:
One question did you add any kernel tweaks to your build ? An why can't I find any system tweaks ? Sorry two Questions !!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
There are no kernel tweaks. I have been trying to build a custom kernel from source for this, however, ubuntu/virtualbox are not playing nice with my hardware. (Ubuntu stops using my CPU completely after ~10min.) This is just a very bare bones stock Rom, with Trebuchet as a launcher. There are no special system tweaks added to it. Regarding that topic, I am working on tethering, it has been very difficult though. Samsung's smali files are a huge mess to work with. I can get the "you are not subscribed to this service" notification to stop, but tethering still won't start. Are you missing any options that would normally be available on stock? If so, I would definitely like to fix that ASAP.
J727P
Spaceminer said:
There are no kernel tweaks. I have been trying to build a custom kernel from source for this, however, ubuntu/virtualbox are not playing nice with my hardware. (Ubuntu stops using my CPU completely after ~10min.) This is just a very bare bones stock Rom, with Trebuchet as a launcher. There are no special system tweaks added to it. Regarding that topic, I am working on tethering, it has been very difficult though. Samsung's smali files are a huge mess to work with. I can get the "you are not subscribed to this service" notification to stop, but tethering still won't start. Are you missing any options that would normally be available on stock? If so, I would definitely like to fix that ASAP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thank you for getting back to me an good luck with your build on a custom kernel for this phone we can really use one !! Thanks again !
Spaceminer said:
SpacesungGalaxy J727P
(J727PVPU3ARC2)Disclaimer:
I am not responsible for what you do with your device. If you decide to flash this software then you are accepting any risks involved. Including, but not limited to; bricking your device, missing alarms, missing calls, loss of your job, repossession of your car, and maybe even spilt milk.
About:
This is very much a personal project that I felt others would appreciate. I enjoy retro gaming very much, and as some of you may know, emulation is very CPU intensive. Hence the reason for making Spacesung. My goal was a stock rom that was lag free, debloated, and buttery smooth for gaming. I believe I have achieved this, and so, I give this to the you, to enjoy, use, modify, and share at your discretion.
Features
•Deodexed
•Debloated- I have removed all unnecessary Samsung, Google, and Amazon apps.
•Removed all Amazon symlinks. (Libs are next.)
•Deknoxed- Note: Some leftovers may be present. If you find any please let me know.
•Rooted- SuperSu is included.
•Up to 10gb+ of internal storage is available. This number will change depending on what you install afterwards, and what you have already stored on your internal SD.
Instructions:
1. Download the ROM from here.
2. Download GoogleKeyboard. You will need this after installation because the Samsung keyboard has been removed.
3. Make sure both files are on your internal, or external storage. Either is fine.
4. Reboot to recovery and wipe, data, system, cache, & dalvik cache.
5. Install Spacesung.
6. Reboot and wait. SuperSU will cause it to boot loop once. This is just root sinking it's teeth into the system. Don't interrupt it. After the aforementioned loop, it'll take about ~5-8min to start up. This only applies to the very first boot. Afterwards it only takes ~10 seconds to startup.
7. Skip all the setup steps that require typing. This can be done after you install GoogleKeyboard.
8. Enjoy!
Special notes:
*Google play, and Google services are still installed. You can disable both if you want to. You must disable it as a device administrator under the security options first, or it will be grayed out.
*Syncing will not work, since it has also been removed.
*Device encryption and secure storage shouldn't work either.
*Chrome is still installed. It can also disabled. There is no way to remove it yet, as the 7.0 framework uses it for webview. I'm still searching for a workaround to save more space.
*Anything not listed, should be working perfectly. If something is broken, let me know. And please remember, that anything already listed is not a bug, it is intentional. If you have any issues with 3rd party apps, I will try to help you, though I make no promises.
*As always, anything that I make is free to use for other projects, public or personal, without my permission. No need to ask me, just do it! Credit is always appreciated, though not required.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Downloaded and installed nicely. Tried to switch superuser with magisk but no go, need stock boot image but all in all a good clean debloated Rom. You should include a keyboard though, your link did not work so I downloaded one on my PC and transferred to internal sd and installed. If you can get magisk instead of superuser, you will have a winner !
Sent from my SM-J727P using Tapatalk
J727P
Spaceminer said:
SpacesungGalaxy J727P
(J727PVPU3ARC2)Disclaimer:
I am not responsible for what you do with your device. If you decide to flash this software then you are accepting any risks involved. Including, but not limited to; bricking your device, missing alarms, missing calls, loss of your job, repossession of your car, and maybe even spilt milk.
About:
This is very much a personal project that I felt others would appreciate. I enjoy retro gaming very much, and as some of you may know, emulation is very CPU intensive. Hence the reason for making Spacesung. My goal was a stock rom that was lag free, debloated, and buttery smooth for gaming. I believe I have achieved this, and so, I give this to the you, to enjoy, use, modify, and share at your discretion.
Features
•Deodexed
•Debloated- I have removed all unnecessary Samsung, Google, and Amazon apps.
•Removed all Amazon symlinks. (Libs are next.)
•Deknoxed- Note: Some leftovers may be present. If you find any please let me know.
•Rooted- SuperSu is included.
•Up to 10gb+ of internal storage is available. This number will change depending on what you install afterwards, and what you have already stored on your internal SD.
Instructions:
1. Download the ROM from here.
2. Download GoogleKeyboard. You will need this after installation because the Samsung keyboard has been removed.
3. Make sure both files are on your internal, or external storage. Either is fine.
4. Reboot to recovery and wipe, data, system, cache, & dalvik cache.
5. Install Spacesung.
6. Reboot and wait. SuperSU will cause it to boot loop once. This is just root sinking it's teeth into the system. Don't interrupt it. After the aforementioned loop, it'll take about ~5-8min to start up. This only applies to the very first boot. Afterwards it only takes ~10 seconds to startup.
7. Skip all the setup steps that require typing. This can be done after you install GoogleKeyboard.
8. Enjoy!
Special notes:
*Google play, and Google services are still installed. You can disable both if you want to. You must disable it as a device administrator under the security options first, or it will be grayed out.
*Syncing will not work, since it has also been removed.
*Device encryption and secure storage shouldn't work either.
*Chrome is still installed. It can also disabled. There is no way to remove it yet, as the 7.0 framework uses it for webview. I'm still searching for a workaround to save more space.
*Anything not listed, should be working perfectly. If something is broken, let me know. And please remember, that anything already listed is not a bug, it is intentional. If you have any issues with 3rd party apps, I will try to help you, though I make no promises.
*As always, anything that I make is free to use for other projects, public or personal, without my permission. No need to ask me, just do it! Credit is always appreciated, though not required.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You may want to try this Build I Built on TomeGJ7p's WIFI BUILD it's a good one I THINK YOU WILL LIKE IT !
https://mega.nz/#!aUlU3CiD!QERLRerFDA8497aKopbqZqZh-ZSTVfZ9GhfQQy2mBrs
PS if you like it you can use it to Build on you have mine an tomeGJ7p's Blessing !!
Spaceminer said:
There are no kernel tweaks. I have been trying to build a custom kernel from source for this, however, ubuntu/virtualbox are not playing nice with my hardware. (Ubuntu stops using my CPU completely after ~10min.) This is just a very bare bones stock Rom, with Trebuchet as a launcher. There are no special system tweaks added to it. Regarding that topic, I am working on tethering, it has been very difficult though. Samsung's smali files are a huge mess to work with. I can get the "you are not subscribed to this service" notification to stop, but tethering still won't start. Are you missing any options that would normally be available on stock? If so, I would definitely like to fix that ASAP.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This ROM is totally debloated. I went back and tried it again, very smooth, very fast but Contacts would not sync so I could not call anyone. Google account would not sync so no play store apk update from old account.Samsung account missing so no way for me to bring certain apks and utilities from stock ROM. Bare-bones android op. But I will keep it on my sd card.
PS
I just remembered those system apks that are missing that I need, I could have installed thru Titanium Bkup! [emoji846]
Sent from my SM-J727P using Tapatalk
is there anyway you can upload a copy with sync enabled and would it be possible to also use a modified or even stock touchwiz launcher?? and Magisk... If I could have sync magisk and touchwiz Id run this as my daily driver
JeepinxJosh said:
is there anyway you can upload a copy with sync enabled and would it be possible to also use a modified or even stock touchwiz launcher?? and Magisk... If I could have sync magisk and touchwiz Id run this as my daily driver
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You can flash gapps for sync, I don't have the sync apps on hand or I would attach them. I've flashed pico without issue. I forget which one(s) has the sync apps, it's possible that all of them do. Magisk can be installed fairly easily. Grab Magisk v16. Open SuperSU, look in settings and choose full unroot. Select yes when asked to restore the stock boot image, and no to recovery. As soon as it reboots, hold Vol↑+Home to catch TWRP, then flash Magisk. As for Touchwiz, try installing the one in the attachments below. If it gives you any problems, let me know. If I update anything I will definitely be using Magisk, and I'll keep these options in mind for separate builds in the future.
Spaceminer said:
You can flash gapps for sync, I don't have the sync apps on hand or I would attach them. I've flashed pico without issue. I forget which one(s) has the sync apps, it's possible that all of them do. Magisk can be installed fairly easily. Grab Magisk v16. Open SuperSU, look in settings and choose full unroot. Select yes when asked to restore the stock boot image, and no to recovery. As soon as it reboots, hold Vol↑+Home to catch TWRP, then flash Magisk. As for Touchwiz, try installing the one in the attachments below. If it gives you any problems, let me know. If I update anything I will definitely be using Magisk, and I'll keep these options in mind for separate builds in the future.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks man
I used this rom as the base for my gaming phone and then stripped it down to only system framework apps. If the latter were removed it would crash the phone. Anything I removed to get to that point, had minimal impact on space (fifty or so megs) and bootup times compared to a fully loaded phone (5 seconds). Spaceminer did an excellent job on this.
Video here of bootup comparison between two Galaxy J7 Perx, one with the Spacesung rom:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=2&v=z9bcqwLVIAA
Is the Oreo stock ROM a battery chugger?
It's just me or anybody have experienced less stamina from their battery with the Oreo stock ROM even with all the de-bloat applied. Compared to the latest ARG2 Nougat it's almost halves the lifetime of the battery, even when on standby it consume a lot more.
ct760ster said:
It's just me or anybody have experienced less stamina from their battery with the Oreo stock ROM even with all the de-bloat applied. Compared to the latest ARG2 Nougat it's almost halves the lifetime of the battery, even when on standby it consume a lot more.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried turning off all the scanning features? Also in the dev options, the switch that keeps mobile data always on, is enabled by default. It's normally off in Nougat. Turning that off should help tremendously.
That being said, I do think Oreo is a battery hog, and I don't think there's any performance gain over Nougat. My best benchmarks with this phone are running Nougat (ARG2), debloated. My battery gives me 51-52hrs on Nougat, with 17-18hrs of that being screen on time. I plan on running Oreo this week to get a good comparison between them.
I just tried to flash open gapps 6/4/2020 stock for version 9 arm64, after I wiped cache and dalvik and rebooted all my gapps were gone but google pay was showing. I could see all the others were installed looking in system apps though. Trying to run google pay produced an error, see attached. Play services version seems to be broken? Help?
Confirmed, definitely broken. Logs attached. If anyone finds anyone in the open gapps project that actually cares feel free to let them know but from my past experiences it looks like open gapps stock is now over for 9. Might try a larger package, I'll post here if I do and it solves the problem.
Update: The Super package has the same issue.
There are other GAPPS like Nik GAPPS.
ChazzMatt said:
There are other GAPPS like Nik GAPPS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
True, but that's another set of issues, and wouldn't I have to get Open Gapps off first?
callihn said:
True, but that's another set of issues, and wouldn't I have to get Open Gapps off first?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, but let's back up a step...
What LOS custom ROM do you have installed, for which you need GAPPS?
Just want to make sure we're all on the same page.
LOS-16 and LOS-17 need different GAPPS and of course stock firmware doesn't use GAPPS.
ChazzMatt said:
Yes, but let's back up a step...
What LOS custom ROM do you have installed, for which you need GAPPS?
Just want to make sure we're all on the same page.
LOS-16 and LOS-17 need different GAPPS and of course stock firmware doesn't use GAPPS.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Of course stock uses gapps, unless you like wasting your storage to hold the updates and then having to re-update if you land up having to restore or do a factory reset, been doing it since Gingerbread and it works great, or it did, although the majority of updates can easily be moved to the system using Link2SD I have yet to find any realible means to move play services to the system without breaking things which is a major headache, gapps solves that issue and also allows me to choose which apps I want included in a rooted stock rom. The reality is that custom/non-stock ROMs are generally broken in one way or the other and more often than not it's just not something I'm willing to deal with, in addition there's useally too much junk included that I just have no need for and if I did I'd change my stock rooted ROM to fulfill that need. I've actually never seen a stock ROM that didn't use gapps. I'm perfectly happy with rooted and reasonably de-bloated stock and change things I feel are needed, for example adding in call recording, most custom ROMs would actually leave me doing more work to take things out and put things back in, like why take out the native sms, clock, calculator, calender, keyboard etc. they work, they are free and ad free, they are useally small and thus not really bloat and they are often hard to replace with similar function anywhere near their size.
callihn said:
Of course stock uses gapps, unless you like wasting your storage to hold the updates and then having to re-update if you land up having to restore or do a factory reset, been doing it since Gingerbread and it works great, or it did, although the majority of updates can easily be moved to the system using Link2SD I have yet to find any realible means to move play services to the system without breaking things which is a major headache, gapps solves that issue and also allows me to choose which apps I want included in a rooted stock rom. The reality is that custom/non-stock ROMs are generally broken in one way or the other and more often than not it's just not something I'm willing to deal with, in addition there's useally too much junk included that I just have no need for and if I did I'd change my stock rooted ROM to fulfill that need. I've actually never seen a stock ROM that didn't use gapps. I'm perfectly happy with rooted and reasonably de-bloated stock and change things I feel are needed, for example adding in call recording, most custom ROMs would actually leave me doing more work to take things out and put things back in, like why take out the native sms, clock, calculator, calender, keyboard etc. they work, they are free and ad free, they are useally small and thus not really bloat and they are often hard to replace with similar function anywhere near their size.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No, you never flash custom ROM GAPPS on STOCK firmware. It already has built in GAPPS. GAPPS are usually only for LOS/AOSP custom ROM, not even stock based custom ROM. So there's your problem.
If you want to do it, go ahead, but I just know what I've been told by several devs.
When I read your question again, it seemed strange the way the wrote it, so that's why I wanted to clarify.
ChazzMatt said:
No, you never flash custom ROM GAPPS on STOCK firmware. It already has built in GAPPS. GAPPS are usually only for LOS/AOSP custom ROM, not even stock based custom ROM. So there's your problem.
If you want to do it, go ahead, but I just know what I've been told by several devs.
When I read your question again, it seemed strange the way the wrote it, so that's why I wanted to clarify.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No my problem is that suddenly play services in Open Gapps does not work, worked fine until this flash. Open Gapps is just Gapps, all versions should be the same as released by Google, as stated I've been doing it since Gingerbread and the only issues it's ever caused is when Open Gapps is broken as mentioned in the first post and photos has also been broken for awhile now as it no longer runs in system/app so I install that from play store and move that myself with Link2SD which puts it in system/priv-app where it works. Not sure which question you are referring to, Open Gapps is broken currently and it's my understanding that all Gapps have to be removed to switch to any other and then there's the learning curve that will come with it. If I had the time I'd just create and maintain a package for just core that wouldn't touch the rest. That will likely become a necessity in the future at the rate things are going. So yes, after all these years I'll continue doing it since it's proven to work, assuming it ever gets fixed though I doubt it will as photos has yet to be fixed and that just requires a change in the install script.
callihn said:
No my problem is that suddenly play services in Open Gapps does not work, worked fine until this flash. Open Gapps is just Gapps, all versions should be the same as released by Google, as stated I've been doing it since Gingerbread and the only issues it's ever caused is when Open Gapps is broken as mentioned in the first post and photos has also been broken for awhile now as it no longer runs in system/app so I install that from play store and move that myself with Link2SD which puts it in system/priv-app where it works. Not sure which question you are referring to, Open Gapps is broken currently and it's my understanding that all Gapps have to be removed to switch to any other and then there's the learning curve that will come with it. If I had the time I'd just create and maintain a package for just core that wouldn't touch the rest. That will likely become a necessity in the future at the rate things are going. So yes, after all these years I'll continue doing it since it's proven to work, assuming it ever gets fixed though I doubt it will as photos has yet to be fixed and that just requires a change in the install script.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How long have you owned the V30?
You'll need to factory reset the phone to remove the extraneous GAPPS you installed when stock firmware has GAPPS and different resolution versions of the apps.
You still haven't explained why you need gapps on stock firmware. Every V30 dev who creates a stock firmware ROM says do not install GAPPS.
From Aeron Li, the A.IS. and A.I.X. (stock firmware based ROM) dev, who says NOT to do what you are trying to do:
the bad thing is that he can flash/install mismatched gapps and that may make firmware work wrong, or even make safetynet issues and not working Gapps-related things
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Boombox dev (another stock ROM) and JohnFawkes one of the devs who create the TWRP flashable zips has said not to flash GAPPS over stock firmware.
You're probably going to cause conflicts. But it's your phone.
ChazzMatt said:
How long have you owned the V30?
You'll need to factory reset the phone to remove the extraneous GAPPS you installed when stock firmware has GAPPS and different resolution versions of the apps.
You still haven't explained why you need gapps on stock firmware. Every V30 dev who creates a stock firmware ROM says do not install GAPPS.
From Aeron Li, the A.IS. and A.I.X. (stock firmware based ROM) dev, who says NOT to do what you are trying to do:
Boombox dev (another stock ROM) and JohnFawkes one of the devs who create the TWRP flashable zips has said not to flash GAPPS over stock firmware.
You're probably going to cause conflicts. But it's your phone.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I dunno never had any issues and flashed open gapps a few weeks ago, 20200513 to be exact on this phone, no issues. Actually it was explained in detail. Updates take up space, wiping data removes them and hence bandwidth and time is wasted. Moving updates into system saves space and bandwidth. Again I don't do anyone's ROMs I use stock and make the few changes I desire. The only real issue that requires it is moving play services to the system since everything else is movable using Link2SD.