Hello, there.
I badly need your assistants. I'm not able to use a bank application as it states as "This device does not meet the minimum security requirements for this application", I flashed patched recovery for Magisk Maanger (7.5.1)& the SafetyNet Check shows as "Success". Both ctsProfile & basicIntegrity is green with true against it.
I repacked the Magisk Manager to different name and enabled Magisk Hide option; also under "Magisk Hide" section, I have enabled the said bank application but still the above said error message popups. I badly want to access this application. I also face same issue with other gov application.
NOTE: I have other bank app which works perfectly by hiding it under "Magisk Hide" section but some Gov & this bank application doesn't work.
Apps use different methods to check for root. Maybe you are having root apps installed which are being checked.
I know that some apps show such a message when you have Titanium Backup installed. I know of other apps, which will show such a message when you have a TWRP folder on your sdcard.
Try using Rootbeer Fresh to check if any check in there fails.
BTW: by looking at the OOS Version 10.3.2 I assume you're not using an OnePlus 7T Pro.
Sajito said:
Apps use different methods to check for root. Maybe you are having root apps installed which are being checked.
I know that some apps show such a message when you have Titanium Backup installed. I know of other apps, which will show such a message when you have a TWRP folder on your sdcard.
Try using Rootbeer Fresh to check if any check in there fails.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your time & support.
Yes, you were right. I had installed Titanium Backup along with Root Checker.
After viewing your post, I tried uninstalling all the apps & its trace but still my bank & gov apps doesn't open.
I tried installing Roobeer application & I made it hide under "Magisk Manager" but the result was all green. Kindly find the attached screenshot for your reference.
Sajito said:
BTW: by looking at the OOS Version 10.3.2 I assume you're not using an OnePlus 7T Pro.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I'm using OnePlus 7T Pro India 10.3.2 HD01AA.
vinu4u4ever said:
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your time & support.
Yes, you were right. I had installed Titanium Backup along with Root Checker.
After viewing your post, I tried uninstalling all the apps & its trace but still my bank & gov apps doesn't open.
I tried installing Roobeer application & I made it hide under "Magisk Manager" but the result was all green. Kindly find the attached screenshot for your reference.
Yes, I'm using OnePlus 7T Pro India 10.3.2 HD01AA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Have you tried in Magisk Hide to check Google Play Services?
vinu4u4ever said:
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your time & support.
Yes, you were right. I had installed Titanium Backup along with Root Checker.
After viewing your post, I tried uninstalling all the apps & its trace but still my bank & gov apps doesn't open.
I tried installing Roobeer application & I made it hide under "Magisk Manager" but the result was all green. Kindly find the attached screenshot for your reference.
Yes, I'm using OnePlus 7T Pro India 10.3.2 HD01AA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Check your device storage if any folders related to Titanium Backup are still present. Some apps check if those folders exist. Also they might cache the result, so you should delete app data before trying again.
slapman said:
Have you tried in Magisk Hide to check Google Play Services?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for your reply.
As you said, the Google play services was not completely selected. Only a couple of them ver hidden.
I made all dependent Google service hidden & removed all the Root apps along with Titanium Backup application & it's leftovers. Restarted n number of times... Still I'm not able to use bank & gov apps.
Pls help
Sajito said:
Check your device storage if any folders related to Titanium Backup are still present. Some apps check if those folders exist. Also they might cache the result, so you should delete app data before trying again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for ur reply.
Yes I used Revo uninstaller to remove the Titanium Backup application & it's leftovers but still no luck.
vinu4u4ever said:
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your time & support.
Yes, you were right. I had installed Titanium Backup along with Root Checker.
After viewing your post, I tried uninstalling all the apps & its trace but still my bank & gov apps doesn't open.
I tried installing Roobeer application & I made it hide under "Magisk Manager" but the result was all green. Kindly find the attached screenshot for your reference.
Yes, I'm using OnePlus 7T Pro India 10.3.2 HD01AA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think you should update to OOS 10.0.8
Which is the latest build. Here you can find what you need with instructions. These are for OnePlus 7T Pro they have all versions Global, EU, India...
https://forum.xda-developers.com/7t-pro/how-to/rom-stock-fastboot-roms-oneplus-7t-pro-t3991189
slapman said:
I think you should update to OOS 10.0.8
Which is the latest build. Here you can find what you need with instructions. These are for OnePlus 7T Pro they have all versions Global, EU, India...
https://forum.xda-developers.com/7t-pro/how-to/rom-stock-fastboot-roms-oneplus-7t-pro-t3991189
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I'm at the latest build. The build number for Indian region is different.
For HD01AA Global : - 10.0.8 (Build version from start 10.0.3 - 10.0.4 - 10.0.5 - 10.0.7 - 10.0.8)
For HD01AA India: - 10.3.2 (Build version from start 10.0.3 - 10.0.4 - 10.3.0 - 10.3.1 - 10.3.2)
Is there anything to do with Magisk Manager or anything else?
Have you rooted your mobile? If so, please do try to install "Doha Bank" application & check whether it is opening in your mobile?
Thanks
Do you maybe have an TWRP folder present which might be detected?
Unfortunately I cannot test the app for you, since SafetyNet is failing on my device.
Tested this method I use for another app and it worked.
Download Shelter from Google play store
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.typeblog.shelter
It creates a work profile on your phone. You should have another Google play store with a little blue suitcase icon. Install your banking app from that. Don't uninstall the old one.
Now in magisk go to magisk hide and tick the app if you haven't. Untick playstore and other Google services. Now go to settings and click Hide Magisk manager. Just name it manager or something other than Magisk.
Now open your banking app with the little blue suitcase.
Install titanium backup and all other apps again, should still work. :laugh:
vinu4u4ever said:
Thanks for your reply. I appreciate your time & support.
Yes, you were right. I had installed Titanium Backup along with Root Checker.
After viewing your post, I tried uninstalling all the apps & its trace but still my bank & gov apps doesn't open.
I tried installing Roobeer application & I made it hide under "Magisk Manager" but the result was all green. Kindly find the attached screenshot for your reference.
Yes, I'm using OnePlus 7T Pro India 10.3.2 HD01AA.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
vinu4u4ever said:
I'm at the latest build. The build number for Indian region is different.
For HD01AA Global : - 10.0.8 (Build version from start 10.0.3 - 10.0.4 - 10.0.5 - 10.0.7 - 10.0.8)
For HD01AA India: - 10.3.2 (Build version from start 10.0.3 - 10.0.4 - 10.3.0 - 10.3.1 - 10.3.2)
Is there anything to do with Magisk Manager or anything else?
Have you rooted your mobile? If so, please do try to install "Doha Bank" application & check whether it is opening in your mobile?
Thanks
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes, I'm rooted I have EU 10.0.8 I'm in U.S. I tried installing "Doha Bank" but doesn't work when I tap the app it just appear and disappears very quickly. Over here I use Google Pay no problem. Sorry couldn't help you.
Sajito said:
Do you maybe have an TWRP folder present which might be detected?
Unfortunately I cannot test the app for you, since SafetyNet is failing on my device.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh.. I see... No probs... Thanks for helping...
Zhico said:
Tested this method I use for another app and it worked.
Download Shelter from Google play store
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.typeblog.shelter
It creates a work profile on your phone. You should have another Google play store with a little blue suitcase icon. Install your banking app from that. Don't uninstall the old one.
Now in magisk go to magisk hide and tick the app if you haven't. Untick playstore and other Google services. Now go to settings and click Hide Magisk manager. Just name it manager or something other than Magisk.
Now open your banking app with the little blue suitcase.
Install titanium backup and all other apps again, should still work. :laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Perfect brother! It works like charm... Thank you very much.... Yahooo
slapman said:
Yes, I'm rooted I have EU 10.0.8 I'm in U.S. I tried installing "Doha Bank" but doesn't work when I tap the app it just appear and disappears very quickly. Over here I use Google Pay no problem. Sorry couldn't help you.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No problem... Thanks for your help... Much appreciated...
I tried shelter application which creates work profile & those bank & gov applications are working fine...
vinu4u4ever said:
Perfect brother! It works like charm... Thank you very much.... Yahooo
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your welcome. Glad it worked! :victory:
Hello, there.
I'm suffering from same problem as well.
I need too assistance from you.
I'm using (Pixel V2+) Android version 5.1 Indian.
I have tried many times to download a application of qatar gov METRASH2 but it's doesn't open.
and viewing, this device does not meet the minimum security requirements for this application
I see everyone here is facing the problem from qatar... i had the same problem as well thanks to the above mentioned shelter app it helped
Zhico said:
Tested this method I use for another app and it worked.
Download Shelter from Google play store
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=net.typeblog.shelter
It creates a work profile on your phone. You should have another Google play store with a little blue suitcase icon. Install your banking app from that. Don't uninstall the old one.
Now in magisk go to magisk hide and tick the app if you haven't. Untick playstore and other Google services. Now go to settings and click Hide Magisk manager. Just name it manager or something other than Magisk.
Now open your banking app with the little blue suitcase.
Install titanium backup and all other apps again, should still work. :laugh:
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
working- (island also can be used)
thanks
I just had the same problem when updating my rom (EvolutionX), I have magisk 26 and android 13. Were you able to solve it?
Sorry for my english
Related
On Angler (Nexus 6p) I flashed the latest stock rom. (After a complete wipe) Afterwards I flashed TWRP and unzipped Magsik. Subsequently I did update to the latest version. After that I changed the packagename of Magsik manager. Furthermore I installed Xposed framework. Afterwards I enabled root hide for the TAN app:
https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.starfinanz.mobile.android.dkbpushtan&hl=en
This software is meant to give you the tan without using sms services.
Still, the app crashed right at the start without any error notification. Android Version is 8.1 and Magsik is v16. While I did the test, the bootloader was unlocked and TWRP was still the recovery. Can these two things affect the verification of the Banking app? I tried this several times ago in the past, but I was never to make this app running.
If anyone would be able to give helpful advice here, it would be very much appreciated.
Best,
scarline
I have heard that DKB Tan2Go does not work with newer Android versions like Oreo 8.1.x at all.
I can also confirm that. I tried it on a Sony cellphone. The cellphone was not rooted and with a completely new and 'clean' ROM. It was to no avail.
A friend has been forced to buy a chip reader. I am fortunate to be able to use normal TAN lists at the moment. If the DKB tries to exclude me from online banking, I will change the bank.
DKB Tan2Go seems to be one of the worst and most insecure apps ever. The reviews in Google PlayStore confirm this conclusion.
Maybe there will be a solution someday?
DKB TAN2go works with Magisk:
1. Install the TAN2go app (but don't open it)
2. Add the TAN2go app in Magsik Manager in the menu "Magisk Hide"
3. Reboot the phone (I don't know if this is necessary)
4. Open TAN2go, works fine.
**** DKB and this stupid security features which bring absoltuely no security.
That's exactly what I tried - without success. I read that it only worked with an old, obsolete version of Tan2Go. However, I could not find this version and I'm not sure if it still works at all. Did you have the latest version of Tan2Go from Google PlayStore? According to DKB, the recent Tan2Go does not work with devices that was once rooted or had a CustomROM. Even if you go back to stock the Root Counter changed and DKB Tan2Go will never work on this device. Unfortunately, I have to confirm that.
I am working on it to change the bank, because of that.
exaveal said:
DKB TAN2go works with Magisk:
**** DKB and this stupid security features which bring absoltuely no security.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Indeed!
Yes, I have installed the latests version of LineageOS, latest version von Magisk and the latests version of the TAN2go app.
I tried that to no avail. I heard once the root counter has a value other than 0, one can't go back. Probably it is also the Sony bootloader and it is different with other devices?
exaveal said:
Yes, I have installed the latests version of LineageOS, latest version von Magisk and the latests version of the TAN2go app.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have a Xiomi Mi5 rooted with Magisk and Tan2go used to work for the last year or so. But yesterday I tried to make a transaction and BOOM! App crashed without an error message. Tried to use a newer Magisk, tried reinstalling the App, nothing helped.
The worst thing is that I do not know if some of my programs have a battery checker or a screen reader plugin that I am not aware of, or if Tan2Go suddenly detects my root. Regardless, crashing without an explanation is like the worst programming practice ever.
Since I do not need this kind of ****e in my life I will probably change Bank, I mean what good is an internet Bank if you cannot do transactions over your mobile device?
Well, willy-nilly I try to use the only other option from DKB: the German TAN Generator. Every other bank equips you with such a device, if they want you to use it. The DKB does not. Actually, I ordered the 3rd TAN Generator and fully paid for it. The first one drains the battery within days. The second one let me type in all the numbers and for no reason the TAN code does not show up on display.
These devices are very annoying anyway, because you have to type in a lot of numbers for every money transfer, the characters are very small (on the laptop) and you have to carry the TAN Generator + the DKB debitcard all the time. Of course this is less secure.
I would change the bank immediately, but want to keep the Visa credit card. I have higher limits on it. That's the only reason. As soon as I found an alternative bank in Europe, I will leave the DKB for good.
It dont worked with Lineage 14.1 but with 15.1 unoffical build on Samsung S4 together with latest Magisk .Rom from here
https://www.cyanogenmods.org/forums/topic/lineageos-15-1-for-galaxy-s4-lte-android-8-1-oreo/
Works for me
Just tried again. It hasn't been working for me in the past. When downloading & opening the app, I had the same problems.
Then I simply followed the above advice: downloading the app again, didn't open it, hide with Magisk, reboot and opened the app - worked well and was able to register for tan2go.
I am using Lineage 16.0 and Magisk v18.0
DKB already updated their app - they patched it
kyodhin said:
Just tried again. It hasn't been working for me in the past. When downloading & opening the app, I had the same problems.
Then I simply followed the above advice: downloading the app again, didn't open it, hide with Magisk, reboot and opened the app - worked well and was able to register for tan2go.
I am using Lineage 16.0 and Magisk v18.0
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The app version from September (version 2.3.0) does work, the newer app version from 4.4.19 (version 2.4.0) does not...
Tested working combination: Magisk 18.0, Magisk Manager 6.1, DKB version 2.3.0
Can confirm that, working with magisk and 2.3.0. Not working anymore with 2.4.0.
I have another Tan app from another bank and with the new version it also stops working. Seems that magisk is now quite to popular and they working on better detection. Magisk hide is useless on the recent version of these tan apps.
That really sucks. No way to get 2.4.0 working. Hoping for a magisk fix. Are the magisk developer informed that there are problems with magisk hide? I think others will have similar problems too.
I successfully got 2.4 working again, after it got updated and refused to start.
Following the steps from this post made it work again (German):
https://www.android-hilfe.de/forum/...trotz-magisk.901517-page-2.html#post-11532359
I installed Magisk 19.0 (beta) but contrary to the above mentioned post I left my Magisk modules installed as they were before the update.
Both the Magisk modules as well as TAN2Go 2.4 are now working again.
I had to authenticate the new TAN2Go installation by adding it as a "new device" using SMS verification.
I was not able to get it to run with the above mentioned instuctions.
Device: Nexus 6P (angler), ROM: LineageOS 15.1-20190419, Magisk modules: MagiskHide Props Config (required for ctsProfile test), Busybox for Android NDK (required for MagiskHide Props Config).
DKB Tan2Go crashes immediately when started.
Same for me. The above instruction doesn't work.
Downgrade to 2.3.0
I experienced the same problem. Had to do an important transfer yesterday. And of course Tan2Go-2.4.0 crashed. I'm using Magisk v18.1.
Today I did a downgrade via Aptoide to 2.3.0 and had to register the smartphone again via SMS. This worked without any problems.
To avoid the update problem and keep with 2.3.0:
Start Titanium Backup
Select the DKB Tan2Go App
Long click on the App.
Connect with Google Play Store (forced)
Long click the App again.
Disconnect from Google Play Store
Hope it helps. I don't think there's much to change in the DKB Api. I'll use 2.3.0 until they block it via the API.
If more people confirm the proposed solution with Magisk v19, I'll try it maybe.
I got it working with v2.4.0, but don't know which step was the solution. Switching to the "Canary" channel of Magisk or hiding the Magisk Manager in the settings. I think the last one was the solution.
Can you guys try and give feedback?
Don't forget to uninstall and install the app before testing again.
musv said:
If more people confirm the proposed solution with Magisk v19, I'll try it maybe.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I have the same issue. Hopefully it can be fixed via Magisk one day.
Worked with T2G 2.4, 19, 7.1.1
Walhalla said:
I got it working with v2.4.0, but don't know which step was the solution. Switching to the "Canary" channel of Magisk or hiding the Magisk Manager in the settings. I think the last one was the solution.
Can you guys try and give feedback?
Don't forget to uninstall and install the app before testing again.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Hi Walhalla,
Hi All
In Settings "General">"Hide" via other apk name it worked for me. V19.0, v7.1.1, Tan2Go 2.4
Hey mates
I recently rooted my pocophone and before I did that I did a "adb backup –all –f c:\backup.ab"
That worked fine, but now i have some Apps not working which I really need. Mainly a banking app.
So im considering going back to unroot the device.
What would be the correct way to do that? Use Xiaomi Flash Tool and then do the restore or can I do the restore just now?
Also is there a way to backup some apps like google authenticator?
Thanks for the help!
Fittoni said:
Hey mates
I recently rooted my pocophone and before I did that I did a "adb backup –all –f c:\backup.ab"
That worked fine, but now i have some Apps not working which I really need. Mainly a banking app.
So im considering going back to unroot the device.
What would be the correct way to do that? Use Xiaomi Flash Tool and then do the restore or can I do the restore just now?
Also is there a way to backup some apps like google authenticator?
Thanks for the help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
use magisk hide
relock pocophone
Fittoni said:
Hey mates
I recently rooted my pocophone and before I did that I did a "adb backup –all –f c:\backup.ab"
That worked fine, but now i have some Apps not working which I really need. Mainly a banking app.
So im considering going back to unroot the device.
What would be the correct way to do that? Use Xiaomi Flash Tool and then do the restore or can I do the restore just now?
Also is there a way to backup some apps like google authenticator?
Thanks for the help!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Just watch below video ....
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29X7bcGUqek
Mooatreides said:
use magisk hide
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
would this "Magisk Hide" allow me to stay rooted and fool the banking applications that the device is not rooted?
Killa-Bee said:
would this "Magisk Hide" allow me to stay rooted and fool the banking applications that the device is not rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thats exactly what it does
Just to post my solution here...I tried using magisk hide which sadly didn't help.
But finally I solve it with the app Island in Google Play Store (Can't post links yet)
I've also flashed the custom rom Pixel Experience
Thx for your Help!
Killa-Bee said:
would this "Magisk Hide" allow me to stay rooted and fool the banking applications that the device is not rooted?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes It Will But If It's Still Doesn't Work Then Hide Magisk Manager (By Hiding It Will Repackage The App With An Random Name So Banking And Other Apps Doesn't Detects Root Access) And Re-Install The App Or Clear The App Data (You Doesn't Need To Clear Data/Uninstall And Install The App This Is Just To Make Sure That The App Doesn't Detect Root Access Even When Root Access Hided Apps Like Fortnite Detects Root Access After Hided So You'll Need To Uninstall/Clear App Data)
ZETRONIX said:
Yes It Will But If It's Still Doesn't Work Then Hide Magisk Manager (By Hiding It Will Repackage The App With An Random Name So Banking And Other Apps Doesn't Detects Root Access) And Re-Install The App Or Clear The App Data (You Doesn't Need To Clear Data/Uninstall And Install The App This Is Just To Make Sure That The App Doesn't Detect Root Access Even When Root Access Hided Apps Like Fortnite Detects Root Access After Hided So You'll Need To Uninstall/Clear App Data)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Oh thanks, that works for me too now.
ZETRONIX said:
Yes It Will But If It's Still Doesn't Work Then Hide Magisk Manager (By Hiding It Will Repackage The App With An Random Name So Banking And Other Apps Doesn't Detects Root Access) And Re-Install The App Or Clear The App Data (You Doesn't Need To Clear Data/Uninstall And Install The App This Is Just To Make Sure That The App Doesn't Detect Root Access Even When Root Access Hided Apps Like Fortnite Detects Root Access After Hided So You'll Need To Uninstall/Clear App Data)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Can you please stop using caps for the first letter of every word? Makes reading and understanding difficult.
[/COLOR]
ZETRONIX said:
Yes It Will But If It's Still Doesn't Work Then Hide Magisk Manager (By Hiding It Will Repackage The App With An Random Name So Banking And Other Apps Doesn't Detects Root Access) And Re-Install The App Or Clear The App Data (You Doesn't Need To Clear Data/Uninstall And Install The App This Is Just To Make Sure That The App Doesn't Detect Root Access Even When Root Access Hided Apps Like Fortnite Detects Root Access After Hided So You'll Need To Uninstall/Clear App Data)
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
it worked on two apps, but not on my HSBC APP, any idea how can I fool my HSBC APP?
how do I Hide Magisk Manager? I am not sure I understand the steps needed?
Hiding Magisk Manager
Killa-Bee said:
[/COLOR]
it worked on two apps, but not on my HSBC APP, any idea how can I fool my HSBC APP?
how do I Hide Magisk Manager? I am not sure I understand the steps needed?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Simply go to Settings in Magisk Manager, the option to hide is the fourth from the top. Then uninstall and reinstall the app which is giving you trouble (HSBC app).
tnsmani said:
Simply go to Settings in Magisk Manager, the option to hide is the fourth from the top. Then uninstall and reinstall the app which is giving you trouble (HSBC app).
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
i thought I already mentioned it. I did that already and it worked on two apps but not on HSBC,
when you goto Hide manager you see a list of apps installed on your phone. those you mean? if so I did that already... and I uninstalled and installed the HSBC app after
Killa-Bee said:
i thought I already mentioned it. I did that already and it worked on two apps but not on HSBC,
when you goto Hide manager you see a list of apps installed on your phone. those you mean? if so I did that already... and I uninstalled and installed the HSBC app after
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
No. What you are talking about is Magisk Hide in Settings. What I was talking about was Hide Magisk Manager, the fourth option in Settings. This hides Magisk Manager itself by renaming it. You simply click it and you will get a popup saying that the Magisk Manager was renamed as xxxx. Try it.
Youtube version is 17.17.37
My understanding is that this is the version included in Android 13 factory image for P6. Is it possible to downgrade to an earlier version? So far I am experiencing failed installs using earlier .apks. I assume this is because it was an app included in the factory image? IS there a workaround?
I am rooted and stock, FWIW
I used magisk module "debloater" to uninstall apps like YouTube.
After, you should be able to install a lower version.
[MODULE][Terminal] Debloater v17.3.2 - Debloat Systemlessly!
[TERMINAL] DEBLOATER Debloat your phone Systemlessly! Debloating can sometimes be device specific. OEM apps can sometimes be a trash to a user but not to the other. So I decided to make a module to Customize the uninstallation of a system app...
forum.xda-developers.com
snake218 said:
I used magisk module "debloater" to uninstall apps like YouTube.
After, you should be able to install a lower version.
[MODULE][Terminal] Debloater v17.3.2 - Debloat Systemlessly!
[TERMINAL] DEBLOATER Debloat your phone Systemlessly! Debloating can sometimes be device specific. OEM apps can sometimes be a trash to a user but not to the other. So I decided to make a module to Customize the uninstallation of a system app...
forum.xda-developers.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
interesting. I'll look into it
deusfaux said:
Youtube version is 17.17.37
My understanding is that this is the version included in Android 13 factory image for P6. Is it possible to downgrade to an earlier version? So far I am experiencing failed installs using earlier .apks. I assume this is because it was an app included in the factory image? IS there a workaround?
I am rooted and stock, FWIW
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You have to force YouTube to a user app instead of a system app.
Then you can uninstall the updated (installed) version.
Rooted with Magisk you can use a module to kick YouTube to a user app.
I made a module awhile back to do just this.
Replace System YouTube - [GitHub] - Link
Not sure if the module will work as is with a13.
You might need to adjust it a bit to work with a13.
Cheers.
Edit:
PS.
Just checked.
Seems everything is still the same on a13.
So I did a quick test on my Pixel 5a, no issues.
snake218 said:
I used magisk module "debloater" to uninstall apps like YouTube.
After, you should be able to install a lower version.
[MODULE][Terminal] Debloater v17.3.2 - Debloat Systemlessly!
[TERMINAL] DEBLOATER Debloat your phone Systemlessly! Debloating can sometimes be device specific. OEM apps can sometimes be a trash to a user but not to the other. So I decided to make a module to Customize the uninstallation of a system app...
forum.xda-developers.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
How did you manage to install this? There's no recovery in pixel 6, do you have a tut ot something? Thanks
deleted
ipdev said:
You have to force YouTube to a user app instead of a system app.
Then you can uninstall the updated (installed) version.
Rooted with Magisk you can use a module to kick YouTube to a user app.
I made a module awhile back to do just this.
Replace System YouTube - [GitHub] - Link
Not sure if the module will work as is with a13.
You might need to adjust it a bit to work with a13.
Cheers.
Edit:
PS.
Just checked.
Seems everything is still the same on a13.
So I did a quick test on my Pixel 5a, no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
will this cause issues with next OTA update? would I have to reverse the process in any way before taking it? disable or remove the module?
also is there a version for YouTube Music?
ipdev said:
You have to force YouTube to a user app instead of a system app.
Then you can uninstall the updated (installed) version.
Rooted with Magisk you can use a module to kick YouTube to a user app.
I made a module awhile back to do just this.
Replace System YouTube - [GitHub] - Link
Not sure if the module will work as is with a13.
You might need to adjust it a bit to work with a13.
Cheers.
Edit:
PS.
Just checked.
Seems everything is still the same on a13.
So I did a quick test on my Pixel 5a, no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
hi I'm trying to solve this problem on pixel 7 pro. i'm not sure I understand what this module does? you mention in this post it kicks it to a user app, but on the github page it says it just overwrites the existing youtube apk with zero bytes?
deusfaux said:
will this cause issues with next OTA update? would I have to reverse the process in any way before taking it? disable or remove the module?
also is there a version for YouTube Music?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Apologize for the delay.
I did not intend to ignore your question, it just got lost in my list of replies.
As for OTA updates, it should not affect anything.
I never tested with an OTA update. I download the full version and use fastboot to update.
If you disable the module it will revert back to the newer system version.
The older version that you installed, will be uninstalled.
---
As for a YTMusic version..
I never needed one but, it would be easy to do the same.
Should have time this weekend to look into it.
Cheers.
whatsisnametake2 said:
hi I'm trying to solve this problem on pixel 7 pro. i'm not sure I understand what this module does? you mention in this post it kicks it to a user app, but on the github page it says it just overwrites the existing youtube apk with zero bytes?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
When an app is included in system (app, priv-app, product, ...).
Newer versions get installed into userdata, regardless if it is an update from PlayStore or manually installed.
Both will be found and the newer version will be loaded.
You can only uninstall the update (userdata) version since system is read-only.
It will revert back to loading the version in system.
By replacing the system app version with zero byte file(s), the system version can not be loaded.
This leaves only the version that is installed in userdata.
It is then treated the same as any other user app.
If you uninstall the version in userdata, it will be gone since there is no system version available to load.
Cheers.
deusfaux said:
<SNIP>
also is there a version for YouTube Music?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ipdev said:
<SNIP>
As for a YTMusic version..
I never needed one but, it would be easy to do the same.
Should have time this weekend to look into it.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Replace System YouTube Music - [GitHub] - Link
Cheers.
Nice. Thanks
ipdev said:
Replace System YouTube Music - [GitHub] - Link
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Any chance for a version of this for OOS13? System YouTube Music resides in /my_bigball/app/YTMusic/YTMusic.apk
If you are rooted you can use the “let me downgrade” module
aBikeLife said:
Any chance for a version of this for OOS13? System YouTube Music resides in /my_bigball/app/YTMusic/YTMusic.apk
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Not sure off hand but, it should be able to be modified to include yet another OnePlus directory.
I checked on my 7T (Android 12) and it was in
/my_bigball/del-app-pre/YTMusic_del/YTMusic.apk
So it let me just uninstall it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I found a (renewed) 9 Pro a few days ago.
Should be here by the end of next week and I test more then.
Cheers.
ipdev said:
Not sure off hand but, it should be able to be modified to include yet another OnePlus directory.
I checked on my 7T (Android 12) and it was in
/my_bigball/del-app-pre/YTMusic_del/YTMusic.apk
So it let me just uninstall it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I found a (renewed) 9 Pro a few days ago.
Should be here by the end of next week and I test more then.
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Awesome, thanks!
ipdev said:
Not sure off hand but, it should be able to be modified to include yet another OnePlus directory.
I checked on my 7T (Android 12) and it was in
/my_bigball/del-app-pre/YTMusic_del/YTMusic.apk
So it let me just uninstall it. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
I found a (renewed) 9 Pro a few days ago.
Should be here by the end of next week and I test more then.
Cheers.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
FYI, I'm unable to uninstall from /my_bigball/app/YTMusic/YTMusic.apk
ipdev said:
You have to force YouTube to a user app instead of a system app.
Then you can uninstall the updated (installed) version.
Rooted with Magisk you can use a module to kick YouTube to a user app.
I made a module awhile back to do just this.
Replace System YouTube - [GitHub] - Link
Not sure if the module will work as is with a13.
You might need to adjust it a bit to work with a13.
Cheers.
Edit:
PS.
Just checked.
Seems everything is still the same on a13.
So I did a quick test on my Pixel 5a, no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
ipdev said:
You have to force YouTube to a user app instead of a system app.
Then you can uninstall the updated (installed) version.
Rooted with Magisk you can use a module to kick YouTube to a user app.
I made a module awhile back to do just this.
Replace System YouTube - [GitHub] - Link
Not sure if the module will work as is with a13.
You might need to adjust it a bit to work with a13.
Cheers.
Edit:
PS.
Just checked.
Seems everything is still the same on a13.
So I did a quick test on my Pixel 5a, no issues.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
thanks so much for this, worked on OOS 12 and was able to install vanced
A13 stock. Magisk 25203. PS Remote Play app 5.5, and hidden in the Magisk deny list, like other apps.
Other typical root detecting apps foiled, but not this one. Hiding the Magisk manager itself didn't help.
Suggestions?
Assuming you're on the stock ROM, else you might need to use MagiskHide Props Config. Try turning on Zygisk and adding Displax's version of USNF and Shamiko (note: Shamiko is a closed-source root hider, so your call if you trust it). Keep in mind that if you use Shamiko, then the "enforce deny list" switch needs to be off. Shamiko reads from the list and handles it instead (so you do still need to have Google Play Services and PS Remote Play in the deny list). So far I haven't had anything detect root with this setup as long as it's in my deny list, though I don't have a PlayStation so I can't test it with this specifically.
I am on A13 stock. I'll look into this. FWIW, one doesn't need a PlayStation to see the app PS Remote App fail the root check, which is upon opening it, resulting in error 88001003
PS Remote Play - Apps on Google Play
Access your PS5 or PS4 wherever you go.
play.google.com
Interesting, it's happening the moment you open the app? I don't have a Playstation account, but I can open the app and get in far enough to see the account login screen with no error. That's on my system with the above utilities installed as well as Magisk and LSposed, running the Android 13 QPR1 beta. If you set all that up and it's still happening, try clearing the PS Remote Play app's data, too.
Jaitsu said:
Interesting, it's happening the moment you open the app?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yes. It may be using some data from the general PS App to auto-login, but it appears as instantaneous error to me, even after full storage/cache wipe and force close.
I just updated USNF, and installed the MOD version on top of that as you suggested, still no go. Disney+, Nintendo, other apps that check still work. Play Store certified, pass YASNAC.
Haven't tried the Shamiko thing yet
Are you hiding the Magisk app itself?
I'm using Canary manager, btw
deusfaux said:
Yes. It may be using some data from the general PS App to auto-login, but it appears as instantaneous error to me, even after full storage/cache wipe and force close.
I just updated USNF, and installed the MOD version on top of that as you suggested, still no go. Disney+, Nintendo, other apps that check still work. Play Store certified, pass YASNAC.
Haven't tried the Shamiko thing yet
Are you hiding the Magisk app itself?
I'm using Canary manager, btw
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I am hiding the Magisk app itself, with the default "Settings" name. Normal release (25.2/25200) of Magisk. Do you have any other root-related apps the PS Remote Play app might be looking for? (Though I myself have Fox's Magisk Module Manager, LP, the TWRP app, and Franco Kernel Manager installed on my phone and they don't seem to be setting it off.)
I'd suggest turning off USB debugging. I had similar issue with some of my banking and other apps and tried every possible solution but didn't work. Finally I read somewhere to turn off USB debugging and Eureka!!
I've narrowed it to something the recent app version 5.5 is doing
Versions 5.0 and earlier have no problems loading.
My USB debugging is/was off.
It must be looking at / for some other app I have installed, which is really annoying to troubleshoot
Hello,
As you said, I downgraded the app to the version 5.0 ans now I can login
But I can't associate the playstation
It ask me to upgrade to the last version and if i refuse, the association failes.
Do you have the same problem ?
Thx
twingo_man said:
Hello,
As you said, I downgraded the app to the version 5.0 ans now I can login
But I can't associate the playstation
It ask me to upgrade to the last version and if i refuse, the association failes.
Do you have the same problem ?
Thx
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Ver 5.01 asked me if I wanted to update but i could choose 'later' and successfully connect to my PS5
i choose later but I can't connect to my ps5
i will try to put it on wifi...
twingo_man said:
i choose later but I can't connect to my ps5
i will try to put it on wifi...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
We should also try to determine what exactly latest version is detecting and preventing app from working
I have a rooted Samsung SG10Exynos/OS9 that bypasses SafetyNet with the help of Magisk 26.0 & safetynet-fix-v2.4.0-MOD_1.2 (meets BASIC INTERGITY) that I have been using the Starling Bank app 2.92.1.79025 without an issue. I stupidly upgraded to the latest version and got the attached screenshot saying that I had 14 days to restore the device to factory settings (I was still able to use the app after pressing ok). I even more stupidly thought that I could revert back to the previous version that I was using, using Titanium Backup which failed (the app would just flash continuous on launch) and then Swift backup (where it would just repeatedly crash even even before being launched requiring a force stop)
If I wipe data/uninstall/restart phone and install fresh from google play, I now get the attached screenshot saying again to restore to factory, but the button says close app. So being a digital bank, I'm now locked out of my account.
I've tried to install previous versions from APKMirror mirror after wiping data/uninstall/restarting phone, and then just restoring my data with my Titanium/Swift backups but still no joy.
Does anyone know how to downgrade/install not the latest version of Starling Bank, which doesn't have the increased STRONG INTERGITY check?
nukescript said:
I have a rooted Samsung SG10Exynos/OS9 that bypasses SafetyNet with the help of Magisk 26.0 & safetynet-fix-v2.4.0-MOD_1.2 (meets BASIC INTERGITY) that I have been using the Starling Bank app 2.92.1.79025 without an issue. I stupidly upgraded to the latest version and got the attached screenshot saying that I had 14 days to restore the device to factory settings (I was still able to use the app after pressing ok). I even more stupidly thought that I could revert back to the previous version that I was using, using Titanium Backup which failed (the app would just flash continuous on launch) and then Swift backup (where it would just repeatedly crash even even before being launched requiring a force stop)
If I wipe data/uninstall/restart phone and install fresh from google play, I now get the attached screenshot saying again to restore to factory, but the button says close app. So being a digital bank, I'm now locked out of my account.
I've tried to install previous versions from APKMirror mirror after wiping data/uninstall/restarting phone, and then just restoring my data with my Titanium/Swift backups but still no joy.
Does anyone know how to downgrade/install not the latest version of Starling Bank, which doesn't have the increased STRONG INTERGITY check?
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It will force you to use the latest app.
Block firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com
theoneofgod said:
It will force you to use the latest app.
Block firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Also having the same issue. Is this something I should be blocking in Zygiskhide? I can't see it there. Googling the above isn't helping me.
Undeadwolfy said:
Also having the same issue. Is this something I should be blocking in Zygiskhide? I can't see it there. Googling the above isn't helping me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You could try Magisk Delta as it now acts as whitelist so you add only what you want with root. This won't bypass Starling security though. You need to also block address above.
Undeadwolfy said:
Also having the same issue. Is this something I should be blocking in Zygiskhide? I can't see it there. Googling the above isn't helping me.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Blocking this address (firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com) through AdAway has fixed it for me! That is along with all the things that were needed to run it previously.
theoneofgod said:
You could try Magisk Delta as it now acts as whitelist so you add only what you want with root. This won't bypass Starling security though. You need to also block address above.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think the part where I'm stuck is, what would you suggest to block that address? I can't do that in HMA or in Denylist because it doesn't exist.
I've tried blocking in AdAway and manually adding and still getting Starling recognising root.
I've blocked anything Google Play Services, Play Protect, Wallet too. Starling is my main bank. Has only been an issue in the last couple weeks.
A13 P6 Pro running the April security update 13 (TQ2A.230405.003.E1), Magisk 26101, USNF 2.4.0 Mod 1.2, passing Safetynet Basic+ CTS.
Will look at Magisk Delta next.
marian42 said:
Blocking this address (firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com) through AdAway has fixed it for me! That is along with all the things that were needed to run it previously.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This isn't working for me :/. Can you share what other modules you're running/how you've set up Magisk?
I followed the directions in this video.
I didn't do the final step where he renames the Magisk app, seems that it isn't necesary.
The YASNAC app shows that the device passes "Basic integrity" and "CTS profile match".
Also remember that blocking firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com might break other apps that use this domain (I've found one so far).
Undeadwolfy said:
I think the part where I'm stuck is, what would you suggest to block that address? I can't do that in HMA or in Denylist because it doesn't exist.
I've tried blocking in AdAway and manually adding and still getting Starling recognising root.
I've blocked anything Google Play Services, Play Protect, Wallet too. Starling is my main bank. Has only been an issue in the last couple weeks.
A13 P6 Pro running the April security update 13 (TQ2A.230405.003.E1), Magisk 26101, USNF 2.4.0 Mod 1.2, passing Safetynet Basic+ CTS.
Will look at Magisk Delta next.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's a recent update that broke it.
Try Magisk 26.1, enable Zygisk and enforce deny list. Add systemless hosts. Add only Starling to the deny list.
Install safetynet fix 2.4.0 mod 1.2 by displax.
Add the domain I posted to adaway blocklist. Make sure its enabled and in root mode.
theoneofgod said:
It's a recent update that broke it.
Try Magisk 26.1, enable Zygisk and enforce deny list. Add systemless hosts. Add only Starling to the deny list.
Install safetynet fix 2.4.0 mod 1.2 by displax.
Add the domain I posted to adaway blocklist. Make sure its enabled and in root mode.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
That's exactly how I have it running now. No change.
Undeadwolfy said:
That's exactly how I have it running now. No change.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
It's the domain that did it for me. Working fine as of now.
theoneofgod said:
It's the domain that did it for me. Working fine as of now.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for updating. I have both of these in my AdAway too
Code:
firebaseinstallations.googleapis.com
firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com
Nothing doing
Undeadwolfy said:
Thanks for updating. I have both of these in my AdAway too
Code:
firebaseinstallations.googleapis.com
firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com
Nothing doing
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Clean install for Starling? I'm trying to think if I did something else.
Oh. Have you "hidden" Magisk?
Just to weigh in here, I can confirm blocking:
firebaseremoteconfig.googleapis.com
Does indeed allow the Starling app to work. Yes blocking Firebase is going to stop some applications working, but you could always pause AdAway until you are done using the problematic app then resume AdAway when you want to use Starling.
Many thanks @theoneofgod
Not working
Reverting the Starling app back to version 2.95.1.79953 fixes things - just don't forget to re-add it to the Deny List.
I'll probably stay on this version until a new fix is found for the current version 2.96.0.80202.
darsh said:
Reverting the Starling app back to version 2.95.1.79953 fixes things - just don't forget to re-add it to the Deny List.
I'll probably stay on this version until a new fix is found for the current version 2.96.0.80202.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Wild, even this didn't work for me. No idea why I'm having issues.
Hi All
Quick update - Can confirm that rolling back to 2.95.1.79953 does fix things for now
This is using adaway to block the Firebase URLs in a custom host file and using enforce denylist. It doesnt work beyond that for now.
I swapped over to Magisk Alpha for now but i dont know what Starling are doing in the background to see that you have root at this point. Its very annoying
- Edit 2
They seem to be detecting the Enforce Denylist in Magisk (In any form)
Disabling it on version 2.95.1 shows the app can see root. Enabling it allows the app to proceed as if you are not rooted.
Give KernelSU a try if you can. No modules or any workarounds required.
theoneofgod said:
Give KernelSU a try if you can. No modules or any workarounds required.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Isnt that the same as the setting in magisk that hides root from everything not on the su list. Which also doesnt work.