Community development strength - Moto G5 Real Life Review

You're a power user. Can the Moto G5 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Moto G5. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!

Lineageos working - virtually bug free
Requires official LineageOS support for 5*

XDA_RealLifeReview said:
You're a power user. Can the Moto G5 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Moto G5. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Found that the few custom ROMs available are all very good ,easy to install (I am not technically minded )very smooth in their use All of the devs who have applied their know-all to these ROMs should be applauded for their great work , but it does seem to be not very many ROMs for this phone as there is for the other Moto versions out there. Hopefully in the not to distant future more ROMs will be made available and also more updates for all the ROMs .Thank you for all your work so far long may it continue.

XDA_RealLifeReview said:
You're a power user. Can the Moto G5 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Moto G5. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I need the blank flash for the Motorola G5 because many of the users have suffered and are suffering from hardbrick in this incredible phone and therefore there is no support for our phone to stay alive or revive.

rees54y said:
Found that the few custom ROMs available are all very good ,easy to install (I am not technically minded )very smooth in their use All of the devs who have applied their know-all to these ROMs should be applauded for their great work , but it does seem to be not very many ROMs for this phone as there is for the other Moto versions out there. Hopefully in the not to distant future more ROMs will be made available and also more updates for all the ROMs .Thank you for all your work so far long may it continue.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This phone has a lot of development under the blankets, but no buildbots to make roms. Check my github for instance. https://github.com/Motorola-Common/
---------- Post added at 08:42 PM ---------- Previous post was at 08:41 PM ----------
NABECKER16 said:
I need the blank flash for the Motorola G5 because many of the users have suffered and are suffering from hardbrick in this incredible phone and therefore there is no support for our phone to stay alive or revive.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
You cant go around requesting this, its not easy to make. + we have a way to unbrick already. + the bricks were because the users didnt read the thread on how to not brick the phone

i am loving this phone and what im finding for it so far. had it about a week now. i had an Xperia XA for 2 days before and after many attempts still could not even get it rooted. this one is running LineageOS with a new kernel, rooted, and now making new magisk modules for it

Its a great device, I love the Viper OS ROM, as I've been using cyanogenmod and lineage os for too long j needed a change. The device is 64-Bit, which makes quite a lot of difference for me as my moto G6 Play is only 32bit, and the G5 gets better benchmark results.
Also why is lenovo so bad at innovation compared to Motorola when Google owned moto?

Related

Community development strength

You're a power user. Can the Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Xiaomi Redmi Note 4. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
There are tons of Roms already. Good going. Kudos to devs.
As others said the community and developers threw tons of mods, tweaks, roms, kernels and modifications to us including the newest updates.
5/5 since we have no reason to complain.
A huge crowd here.
Something I don't understand is, which ROMs are for the Snapdragon version and which others are for the mediatek version
BlondCleric said:
Something I don't understand is, which ROMs are for the Snapdragon version and which others are for the mediatek version
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Mido=Snapdragon
Mikel=mediatek
MTK
Amazing, there's so much development going on, to the point it even gets a bit confusing.
There are ROMs comparatively, BUT not many MIDO users achieved/tried same. Reason....
*UNAWARE* OR *AFRAD* OR *UNREADY* TO TRY.
Just a handful of users (less then 1000 lol) playing on custom ROMs on MIDO.
Compared to other handsets/brands.. *countdown is unlisted* even on forums.
Everytime more on XDA since it is dedicated portal for knowledge.
MI* users
-- stuck on thoughts
-- neglect to change there mind from user percussion.
-- dont go advanceD
-- always stuck on Bootloader
Strongly suggest a required mechanism for daily users to fix regular issues.
(via XDA or official MI forums)
(CONTACT ME PERSONALLY FOR SAME HERE VIA REQUIRED MECHANISIMS)
WE JUST SUPPORT HEAVILY.. on entire internet..
Edited a little again.. for mi officials.
IODroids said:
There are ROMs comparatively, BUT not many MIDO users achieved/tried same. Reason....
*UNAWARE* OR *AFRAD* OR *UNREADY* TO TRY.
Just a handful of users (less then 1000 lol) playing on custom ROMs on MIDO.
Compared to other handsets/brands.. *countdown is unlisted* even on forums.
Everytime more on XDA since it is dedicated portal for knowledge.
MI* users
-- stuck on thoughts
-- neglect to change there mind from user percussion.
-- dont go advanceD
-- always stuck on Bootloader
Strongly suggest a required mechanism for daily users to fix regular issues.
(via XDA or official MI forums)
(CONTACT ME PERSONALLY FOR SAME HERE VIA REQUIRED MECHANISIMS)
WE JUST SUPPORT HEAVILY.. on entire internet..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Your forums are cluttered with JUNK/SPAM and you have no ideas..
Testing other company never hurts for a quick fix. .
Regards,
lob
One could never ask for more!
XDA_RealLifeReview said:
You're a power user. Can the Xiaomi Redmi Note 4 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Xiaomi Redmi Note 4. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This development forum has everything. The phone had its meager and weak beginning from Marshmallow and we are all the way down to Pie! If you are still unsatisfied then you have a wide assortment of custom kernel of all sorts for both battery-saving and performance freaks alike. What more! We even have the community-powered Sailfish OS if you have Android fatigue and the experimental dual boot patcher if you want the best of both worlds! Heck, even the legendary Franco Kernel is in active development for this budget friendly device. Seems like this device would have a long and fruitful life.
One of the few devices to receive such enormous development support. Really good.

Community development strength

You're a power user. Can the Xiaomi Mi Max 2 keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Xiaomi Mi Max 2. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
As on January 24, 2018, there is next to zero development for this device, Don't know what it takes to get the developers interested...
I can confirm that zero development right now
With xiaomi.eu rom, miui pro and lineage os we have something for everyone, and that without the sources. now that the source code has been released, the development will really start I guess. we also have aokp and ressurection remix which both look promising. people are just underestimating the effort it takes to create a rom.. the development is not that strong, but when you consider that it's a special device (not everyones taste) and that the sources had just been released it's looking good
Some ROMs are there. But development is extreme slow. Faulty bought.
faulty bought? lol
ok what do you need from 3rd party non-miui rom over miui?
Miui 9 pretty much includes alot of features that 3rd party rom has so there no real point to go for other roms unless you have specific need which doesn't give a good enough reason for any devs to go in and spend their precious time and probably end up with bunch of whiny users asking for update EVERYDAY....
to me, i found by root and install mi-globe rom + install google camera apk pretty much completes this phone already.
no issue spotted. also i'm using Lspeed for system tuning.
you have to learn to adapt the current world.
Yes RR does look promising, but then other phones got RR pretty soon, it's just that this one is taking a good long wait ...
The present RR is unusable BTW..
pakudaboy said:
faulty bought? lol
ok what do you need from 3rd party non-miui rom over miui?
Miui 9 pretty much includes alot of features that 3rd party rom has so there no real point to go for other roms unless you have specific need which doesn't give a good enough reason for any devs to go in and spend their precious time and probably end up with bunch of whiny users asking for update EVERYDAY....
to me, i found by root and install mi-globe rom + install google camera apk pretty much completes this phone already.
no issue spotted. also i'm using Lspeed for system tuning.
you have to learn to adapt the current world.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
could you please share the zweaks you did in l speed? are there any noticable performance improvements or downsides?
Xiaomi4X said:
Yes RR does look promising, but then other phones got RR pretty soon, it's just that this one is taking a good long wait ...
The present RR is unusable BTW..
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
the developer stopped development until february
Not even one oficial rom builder, and those unofficial roms are full of bugs.

Custom ROM usability

I've been eyeing this phone for a while and I'm probably going to buy either this or the Oneplus 5T. But since I apply custom ROMs to all my phones, I'd like to know a few things before I decide:
How much does installing a custom rom affect funcionality? I'm talking about:
-The wide angle camera (big selling point for me)
-Quad DAC funcionality
-Quick charging and battery life
-Other aspects
I am aware most of this stuff depends on the ROM you install, but I mean on a general level.
I've heard the LG ROM is quite bloated and I do enjoy the customization options I get from custom ROMs, but the stock camera and audio apps offer a lot of options I wouldn't want to lose.
Thanks in advance
You may want to take a look at the ROM development section here. There's not much going for this phone right now. This device isn't that open at the moment. If a custom ROM is what you want, go with the OnePlus 5T
jsgraphicart said:
You may want to take a look at the ROM development section here. There's not much going for this phone right now. This device isn't that open at the moment. If a custom ROM is what you want, go with the OnePlus 5T
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
But if you want a phone with great specs (much better than OnePlus) and be assured that development is coming, stick with the V30.
US998U just got bootloader unlock today.
Sent from my official open market LG US998 V30+

Community development strength

You're a power user. Can the Xiaomi Mi 8 Lite keep up? Rate this thread to express how "healthy" the development scene is for the Xiaomi Mi 8 Lite. A higher rating indicates available root methods, kernels, and custom ROMs.
Then, drop a comment if you have anything to add!
Really like to know users comment on this
I think the Mi 8 Lite is not so popular, so the developments seen here appears at a very low rate. I love my Mi 8 Lite, but I think it does not have the required "development-strenght" I would like.
pablotrin said:
I think the Mi 8 Lite is not so popular, so the developments seen here appears at a very low rate. I love my Mi 8 Lite, but I think it does not have the required "development-strenght" I would like.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Thanks for the comment!
I don't know why this device is not so popular like redmi note 5 pro. it has all the best things in a affordable price. But number of official ROMs are not bad either.
It took my current device (redmi 4 prime) about 1 year to get its first official ROM, so I think Mi 8 lite is doing kinda good here.
BTW I'm probably getting this device in 2-3 days. It's Mi 8 lite or redmi note 6 pro. Still not quite sure :/
nimbold said:
Thanks for the comment!
I don't know why this device is not so popular like redmi note 5 pro. it has all the best things in a affordable price. But number of official ROMs are not bad either.
It took my current device (redmi 4 prime) about 1 year to get its first official ROM, so I think Mi 8 lite is doing kinda good here.
BTW I'm probably getting this device in 2-3 days. It's Mi 8 lite or redmi note 6 pro. Still not quite sure :/
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
I think devel is actually quite good. Well, with the exception that 2 or 3 devs are releasing all the available ROMs. That actually means that support for a single ROM is not that great, usually taking days until the dev replies, if at all. In my case, never. Something else that makes this phone very difficult to support, is the fact that individual ROMs are closely reliant on the firmware installed. Many ROMs require a specific firmware version. Most users are totally obvious to this. Look how many users have posted they cannot dial, or no sound, simply because they didn't update their firmware. To me, this is not a good road to go down and honestly makes MIUI a bad choice.
However, I love to fix and compile things, so my phone works great and this is probably the best and fastest phone I have ever owned, included all my previous Samsungs.. I plan on purchasing the top of the line Mi 9 in the next month or so and selling this one., but I do love it!
lexridge said:
I think devel is actually quite good. Well, with the exception that 2 or 3 devs are releasing all the available ROMs. That actually means that support for a single ROM is not that great, usually taking days until the dev replies, if at all. In my case, never. Something else that makes this phone very difficult to support, is the fact that individual ROMs are closely reliant on the firmware installed. Many ROMs require a specific firmware version. Most users are totally obvious to this. Look how many users have posted they cannot dial, or no sound, simply because they didn't update their firmware. To me, this is not a good road to go down and honestly makes MIUI a bad choice.
However, I love to fix and compile things, so my phone works great and this is probably the best and fastest phone I have ever owned, included all my previous Samsungs.. I plan on purchasing the top of the line Mi 9 in the next month or so and selling this one., but I do love it!
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Uh, so just not installing latest firmware causes all these weird issue that people have :|
I hope devs deal with this weird situation and keep the development alive.
All I want from a phone is active community here on xda and also good battery life.
Guess I should double check my options in this price range so I don't regret it in future
BTW congrats on soon to come Mi 9. It's a beast
nimbold said:
Uh, so just not installing latest firmware causes all these weird issue that people have :|
I hope devs deal with this weird situation and keep the development alive.
All I want from a phone is active community here on xda and also good battery life.
Guess I should double check my options in this price range so I don't regret it in future
BTW congrats on soon to come Mi 9. It's a beast
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
This phone is doesn't need a custom ROM to be awesome. Even stock rooted, this phone still rocks! Now that the kernel source is out there, hopefully things will get much better regarding custom ROMs.
lexridge said:
This phone is doesn't need a custom ROM to be awesome. Even stock rooted, this phone still rocks! Now that the kernel source is out there, hopefully things will get much better regarding custom ROMs.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Yeah it has Pie which is latest till now and I guess Android Q will come by Xiaomi. This phone specs are too good to not get
I read a few comments above that this device is not very popular and does not have sufficient support from the developers, I came from the Zenfone 3 zoom and it was a year of terror.

Question Custom Roms

Could anyone share a list of custom roms compatible with the Pixel 6? I see 2 in the development thread but I was wondering if there are others. I saw a Graphene but don't know if it's compatible.
JimmyL216 said:
Could anyone share a list of custom roms compatible with the Pixel 6? I see 2 in the development thread but I was wondering if there are others. I saw a Graphene but don't know if it's compatible.
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
The truth is, most of the custom ROM scene is much more active on telegram. There is a ROM update Channel which you will find when you search on telegram. There are couple more roms available there, but overall such a disappointed device when it comes to custom roms . My previous mi 9t pro had such good optimized ROM, that it was factually smoother than pixel 6. Tried side by side myself obviously. Sure more brute force power by the pixel SoC but the software tuning is bad. Much more framedrops on pixel 6 than my much older previous phone. Sorry for the little rant, but it has to be said when you are talking about custom roms...
Way more than a rom but i highly recommend checking out GrapheneOS!
cacio_confusa said:
The truth is, most of the custom ROM scene is much more active on telegram. There is a ROM update Channel which you will find when you search on telegram. There are couple more roms available there, but overall such a disappointed device when it comes to custom roms . My previous mi 9t pro had such good optimized ROM, that it was factually smoother than pixel 6. Tried side by side myself obviously. Sure more brute force power by the pixel SoC but the software tuning is bad. Much more framedrops on pixel 6 than my much older previous phone. Sorry for the little rant, but it has to be said when you are talking about custom roms...
Click to expand...
Click to collapse
Probably just different governors set so that the "faster" feeling one cranks the cpu to max sooner.
I flashed derpfest for oriole a few days ago and so far everything is running well. I even got face unlock with the rom.

Categories

Resources